When Cheese Met Cake

200 S Emerson Ave suite b, Greenwood
(317) 851-9906

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jamee Scheid

ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! However, I thought $12 was a little pricey for the amount that you get. If you go, just be aware that it’s a little on the expensive side ?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Randy Young

The cheese cake was very good. That is all we had but we are going to go back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joshua Vincent

Very good cheesecake. Just expensive.

Holly Oswald

HOLY CRAP this mocha chip cheesecake was the best cheesecake myself, and our entire family, has ever had!! We even have two pretty good bakers in our family who can bake cheesecake! This was for my daughter 16th birthday-requested by her. We had a dinner at Olive Garden and provided the server with a piece of the cake as there was so much! A bunch of servers came out to our table to ask where we get this from. LOL! I tell you this is the best cheesecake you can buy in this city! Thank you for making this special day that much more special for our family!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake Pop, Ice Ice Baby, Heath Cheesecake, Simply Hazel

Katie Sherwood

Dani made a delicious blueberry lemon cheesecake for my husband's birthday. Everyone enjoyed it! You can tell she bakes with love!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob Earickson

The absolute best cheesecake I've ever had. We'll both a visit or two!

Sony Davis

We finally made it in for a treat and let me tell you, we were blown away with the taste of the two cheesecake slices we purchased! The gluten sensitive oreogasm is even better than it looks and sounds. Absolutely delicious, rich and the perfect combination of layered Oreos & cheesecake

Georgie O'Neil

Don't walk...RUN!!! TRULY THE BEST CHEESECAKE AND A FANTASTIC SELECTION!!! THE COOKIES N CREAM SANDWICH COOKIE IS THE BEST COOKIE I HAVE EVER HAD!!! DANNI IS AMAZING AT WHAT SHE DOES!!! STOP IN AND SEE HER N TARA I KNOW U WILL LOVE IT!!! ???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lacey Osborn

Such amazing fresh cheesecakes! Definitely worth checking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Pappe

This is a cute, quaint lil scratch-made bakery.

Essentially, they bake for the day and sell until they run out. There are a variety of rotating cheesecake flavors and a new menu is posted each day. In addition to the thick, creamy NY style cheesecake options, there are usually other sweet treats available.

A line typically forms at the door at opening time on weekends and selling out is a thing, which means the store may close early.

Follow them on social media for regular and consistent updates. They post menus, regular inventory status, etc. One day, just before closing the bakery posted the few slices they had left. I was nearby and commented that I was on my way! “I’ll be here was the response,” and they were. I got a few slices and left just before closing time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

commonsense238

What in the world is with this place and its hours of operation? You want business or...???***update***Hi Karen. I see you have a lot of free time on your hands to immediately respond to reviews. I've actually visited New York and I must say, the bakeries there sure do stay open much longer. You may think the hours work for you, but maybe think about paying customers, because while you think the hours work for them too, I can say you lost my party of 6. Another option is maybe try hiring workers?? Lastly dear, I did think about you being a small business; that's why I left the 1 star review, because I want people to be aware that this small business has terrible hours. If you can't take the criticism, you'll most likely remain a small business. Goodnight.

Service: 1

Stephanie Barnett

Everything we have purchased from this place has been amazing and the customer service is excellent. We love the variety and the rotating flavor menu of cheesecake. We have made this spot one of our weekly Wednesday errand runs. Do not sleep on this place, you'd be missing out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carol Hauersperger

Love the cheesecake here and the other goodies you make!!! Don't stress about the people complaining about your hours. You do great business within the hours you are open. You know a bakery is good if they sell out or nearly sell out every day!!! Keep up the good work!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jenifer Harder

When Cheese Met Cake has the best tasting cheesecake I’ve ever had (but don’t tell my grandma that ?). Everything she bakes is made to perfection and the customer service is impeccable. I live out of town, but it’s the first thing I think about when I get there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake Pop, Heath Cheesecake

David

Excellent cheesecake we Doordashed!! Can’t wait to get more!! Love locally run businesses that prioritize family!

Loading...