Arrenellos Pizza
2556 45th St, Highland
(219) 924-2525
Customers' Favorites
Cheese and Sausage Deep Dish
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Mushroom Pepper Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Great Chicago style deep dish pizza loaded with delicious ingredients! My pregnant grown adult daughter is craving their delicious pizza to bad it’s 3 hours away. Drone delivery yet? lol
I started having Arrenellos at the Tinley Park location when i lived there over 10 years ago. Thats where I met with the owner. I performed a speach about pizza at a local college naming Arrenellos my absolute favorite by a longshot. After moving to Crete IL I drove 25 minutes to pickup our pizza from the Glenwood location often. Now living in Cedar Lake IN I make the drive occasionally to the highland IN location. The quality and consistency is perfect among the three locations....
Arrenello's is great, but the quality is declining. Definitely way less cheese than there used to be on their pizzas. Also, the thin crust pies are almost always not rolled thin enough, and the dough taste/texture in general is off.
Used to be the best - still great! Just declining in quality. Hopefully they turn things around
Used to be the best - still great! Just declining in quality. Hopefully they turn things around
You May Also Like
Butterfingers Highland - 2552 45th St
![]()
Bakery, Dessert
Kui Korean BBQ - 9628 Indianapolis Blvd
![]()
Korean, Vegetarian, Barbeque, Korean barbecue
R-Bar and Grill - 9521 Indianapolis Blvd
![]()
Bar & Grill, Sports Bar, American, Mediterranean, New American