To start, I love Barton's, been going to the one on Calumet for over 30 years. I ordered from the Highland location since I live in Highland now. I ordered a sausage and and cheese, extra well done (I once had a severe case of food poisoning years ago so I try to make sure my food is thoroughly cooked)... Got my pizza home and it was baked like any other pizza, I called to discuss this with the woman that answered, I mentioned that I like my pizza very brown, just short of burning it, she was nice and asked if I could send her a picture of it to discuss this with her oven guy of 30 years. I sent her a picture cause she said she would call back, she never did. I told her that I love their pizza but now I can never order from them again.....
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
patrick Hippydog
Barton's is great pizza .. Buy one
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony Tortolano
Always hits the spot always the best value for top tier pizza!!!!!! Phone people are always polite quick and happy even when clearly busy.....keep being the best bartons in the region
First of all, we order a pizza from this place it’s our first time ordering here the customer service was cool in the store. We asked did they have honey barbecue sauce they say yes they have barbecue sauce which we later found out is just some makeshift version of open pit. I contact the store and I say hey we got a pizza, but the ingredients are literally off of the pizza because it was so soupy, I asked could the pizza be replaced or could we have a refund the store manager told me she needed to contact the store owne. Shortly after, the store owner contacted me and said we don’t give refunds or exchanges just because you don’t “like” the pizza then she proceeded to ask me did I get my nails done at her friend’s shop which I don’t even understand why that came up but she bought it up anyway saying “yea you got your nails done at Lyn’s” or some name. I said no what does that have to do with the pizza? and then she was just very condescending and rude and I told her it’s not because I don’t like the pizza. It’s because the pizza is not edible. The ingredients literally, slid off of the pizza and the bag ripped because it is do soupy and she said I’m not gonna argue with you and hung up in my face. I would never go back to this place again.UpdateYall just make assumptions and dont take accountability. I dont need nor want anything from your slime ball business for “free”. I did not get my nails done at that pathetic shop next door and I never would. Have you seen their work on Google?! I’m sure you have. I went to Sonny’s in Munster. Not sure why you assume I did or that I dropped the pizza but maybe it’s just because you’re an a** which you are. You obviously need the $14 more than I do. My son eats pizza once a week it is his favorite thing. The pizza yall made was trash and if it takes $14 to never deal with yall again I’d say we got the better deal. In fact I tipped so it was more than $14 but here’s a tip do better. Bank transactions included for proof because you continue to lie.
AnnMarie Ramirez
Perfect place to stop and grab a slice when we are out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Single Order
jamie quigley
Foods great ...whoever the manager is there lied about giving us a pizza after they made mistake on our pizza.. this has happened now 3 times altogether.... and for that I'm done with them sadly... I wasn't even the one who said I wanted a pizza they offered it each time... and each time I asked for it she said no all we can do give you $2 or $5 off your pizza....Sucks I ordered there 2 or 3 times a month...
Ummm. Why are people saying this is the best pizza. The pizza is basically, what would happen, if you took a napkin and soaked it in grease. Too thin, greasy and all u taste is bread.
Wade Hayes
Love Barton’s but wish they were open earlier and longer.
Jody Whittaker
Parking: Love the pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Combo Platter
Unqualified Professionals
Great Company, great people delicious food! Will definitely be back!👍
Not the pizza it was. Sad
To start, I love Barton's, been going to the one on Calumet for over 30 years.
I ordered from the Highland location since I live in Highland now.
I ordered a sausage and and cheese, extra well done (I once had a severe case of food poisoning years ago so I try to make sure my food is thoroughly cooked)...
Got my pizza home and it was baked like any other pizza, I called to discuss this with the woman that answered, I mentioned that I like my pizza very brown, just short of burning it, she was nice and asked if I could send her a picture of it to discuss this with her oven guy of 30 years.
I sent her a picture cause she said she would call back, she never did.
I told her that I love their pizza but now I can never order from them again.....
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Barton's is great pizza ..
Buy one
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always hits the spot always the best value for top tier pizza!!!!!! Phone people are always polite quick and happy even when clearly busy.....keep being the best bartons in the region
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love their dill pickle pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Pickle Pizza, Beef Sandwich Pizza
Best pizza ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First of all, we order a pizza from this place it’s our first time ordering here the customer service was cool in the store. We asked did they have honey barbecue sauce they say yes they have barbecue sauce which we later found out is just some makeshift version of open pit. I contact the store and I say hey we got a pizza, but the ingredients are literally off of the pizza because it was so soupy, I asked could the pizza be replaced or could we have a refund the store manager told me she needed to contact the store owne. Shortly after, the store owner contacted me and said we don’t give refunds or exchanges just because you don’t “like” the pizza then she proceeded to ask me did I get my nails done at her friend’s shop which I don’t even understand why that came up but she bought it up anyway saying “yea you got your nails done at Lyn’s” or some name. I said no what does that have to do with the pizza? and then she was just very condescending and rude and I told her it’s not because I don’t like the pizza. It’s because the pizza is not edible. The ingredients literally, slid off of the pizza and the bag ripped because it is do soupy and she said I’m not gonna argue with you and hung up in my face. I would never go back to this place again.UpdateYall just make assumptions and dont take accountability. I dont need nor want anything from your slime ball business for “free”. I did not get my nails done at that pathetic shop next door and I never would. Have you seen their work on Google?! I’m sure you have. I went to Sonny’s in Munster. Not sure why you assume I did or that I dropped the pizza but maybe it’s just because you’re an a** which you are. You obviously need the $14 more than I do. My son eats pizza once a week it is his favorite thing. The pizza yall made was trash and if it takes $14 to never deal with yall again I’d say we got the better deal. In fact I tipped so it was more than $14 but here’s a tip do better. Bank transactions included for proof because you continue to lie.
Perfect place to stop and grab a slice when we are out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Single Order
Foods great ...whoever the manager is there lied about giving us a pizza after they made mistake on our pizza.. this has happened now 3 times altogether.... and for that I'm done with them sadly... I wasn't even the one who said I wanted a pizza they offered it each time... and each time I asked for it she said no all we can do give you $2 or $5 off your pizza....Sucks I ordered there 2 or 3 times a month...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great food, great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I just started going there, my son-in-law and pDaughter order from Bartons all the time. Service is good, Pizza good, friendly people . I'll be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Style Pizza, Monday Special, Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Ummm. Why are people saying this is the best pizza. The pizza is basically, what would happen, if you took a napkin and soaked it in grease. Too thin, greasy and all u taste is bread.
Love Barton’s but wish they were open earlier and longer.
Parking: Love the pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Combo Platter
Great Company, great people delicious food! Will definitely be back!👍
Loading...