Barton's Pizzeria
3925 45th St, Highland
(219) 924-6200
Customers' Favorites
Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Stuffed Cheese Bread
Beef Sandwich Pizza
Deluxe Style Pizza
Double Pickle Pizza
Jumbo Pizza Slice
Meat Lovers Pizza
Garlic Fingers
Monday Special
Boneless Wings
Menu
Photos
+60 photos
+59 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I order here all the time! Pizza is great like always. The mozzarella sticks were horrible. The cheese was not even melted at all inside. I threw them all away. Will not waste my time with that app again.
Bartons has been my favorite pizza for over 45 years! I don't live in the area anymore but I make sure to stop in to grab a pizza to take with me whenever I'm in the area ❤️
We travel from Lowell to Highland and have been going to Barton’s forever! We moved to Indiana from Connecticut 35 years ago and had the hardest time finding Pizza that reminded us of home. After trying place after place we stumbled upon Barton’s. and it’s been our pizza and calzone to-go place ever since! They are the best!
You May Also Like
Schoop's Hamburgers Highland IN - 3905 45th St
![]()
Hamburger, Burgers, Hot Dogs
Koroke Asian Cuisine - 3901 W 45th St
![]()
Asian, Chinese, Japanese, Vegetarian
China Koon - 905 N Broad St
![]()
Chinese, Thai, Vegetarian