Ice Cream Plus
201 E Pendleton Ave, Lapel
(765) 609-9267
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Good ice cream
This was a great place to stop by yesterday while it was incredibly hot outside. The ice cream was great and the service was fast and polite.
Good ice cream.
Ice cream was good. Service quick, but out of hot fudge, out of bananas, out of Reese cups, and out of Sprite. Everything we order had to be modified or was missing ingredients.
I love just about everything they serve!!! Great place, friendly staff! 🥰
Awesome ice cream and friendly service ❗️❗️
Looks like they have not opened for the 2025 season yet. Maps lists them open but they are not. Looks like the winter dirt and dust hasn't been touched yet.
This place is never open during the business hours they say they're open for. I've given this place three chances and it's been closed all three times. What a joke!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ice Cream Minus... At least that's what it should be called! I've never been a fan of this place but the kids enjoy it (they would enjoy freezer burnt store brand ice cream just the same). A few weeks ago my wife brought me home a chocolate shake and it was the best shake I've ever had. It was made with their new hard pack ice cream. I've since ordered 2 more, but it was horrible and nothing like the first. Come to find out they won't make shakes with the hard pack anymore. Ok fine. I went to get just a scoop of chocolate ice cream... I'm sorry we don't carry chocolate ice cream in hard pack any more. What kind of ice cream place doesn't sell chocolate ice cream? Ok well what else do you have? Chocolate chocolate chip. The name would imply that's a chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips right? Nope! Plain old vanilla with a few chocolate chips in it. When I asked what chocolate chocolate chip meant, they couldn't explain but offered to change it out. Chocolate maybe? Disappointing. I'll be going to the place in Fortville instead. It may be a further drive but they carry the same hard pack, a ton more flavors including chocolate, and guess what? Their shakes are made with the hard pack.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Love the Ice cream , it is amazing. Staff is very friendly and nice.
Kid-friendliness: The game out out front is fun to play while waiting for your ice cream
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and ice cream! My dog even loved it
1st time visiting with my mom. Sat outside at one of the picnic tables. Food was ready pretty quickly---waited less than 10 minutes even though they were busy. Bacon cheeseburger was pretty good. Mom had ice cream and I had sorbet. Highly recommend either. Great stop in a small town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had no food, we had expensive ice cream but it was delicious. Will go if I get a chance. Get friendly employees. They told us they had tired ever ice cream in there . I had key lime on a waffle cone. It was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Parking: A little tough to find a spot when they are busy but totally worth the hassle!
Kid-friendliness: There's a game set up
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Split, Apple Pie Sundae, Hot Fudge
This place used to be a fun hometown ice cream shop. The last two times I have taken my family here it took an extremely long time to get our order while the workers casually talked and socialized.
Today we were 5th in line when we arrived and it took 54 minutes to get 4 soft serve cones.
Waiting this long with kids basically takes all the fun out of going out to get ice cream. The ice cream is good, but you won't miss any quality of you get McDonalds soft serve instead. I think I'm finally throwing in the towel on Ice Cream Plus.
Atmosphere: 2
Loading...