The worst overpriced barbecue I have ever eaten. The brisket was dry and did not taste anything like barbecue. The sides were terrible. We'll never go back.
Judy Jarvis
That was the most overpriced meal I have ever had! No BBQ taste what so ever, the meat was very dry and the sauces they had didn't taste like BBQ sauce.
Food: 1
James Johnson
This place is a gem! The most tender brisket EVER and the most flavorful and moist pulled pork EVER! An unbelievable beer selection and awesome staff!
Excellent service, fast, good price and excellent quality. Fascinating, the owner and the cooks, good vibes and gave us a complimentary dessert
Lindsay
Wow, amazing. I’m not even a huge meat eater! Spicy bbq sauce was delish too, I typically don’t like bbq sauce because it’s too sweet. Definitely one of my favorite carnivorous stops in the US ;)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Collord
Best restaurant in Indiana, period.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rib
Brian McDonough
First time trying Rusted Silo. Ordered pickup. In short, some of the best Q (pork, chicken, brisket) I've tasted in some time. Got the Chuck Norris sandwich - how can you not order a sandwich named Chuck Norris, and it had pimento cheese on it. Potato salad - 5 stars. Beans - 5 stars. You get the picture. Order was ready promptly and the staff was very friendly. Will be back again soon.
Had the brisket, the honey slaw and the ranch beans it was all very delicious!The pecan pie is to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Boles
Excellent small town authentic barbecueParking: Parking lot is small and alongside active railroad track. It is one lane in and out . If several large pickups are here then you may have difficulty parking
Worst BBQ I've ever had .I'll never eat there again. I was very disappointed in the brisket it taste more like chuck steak .. asked for extra BBQ sauce and they wouldn't give me any .
Quaint little location with possibly the best barbecue I've ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Cole Slaw, Sausage Platter, Full Rack of Ribs, Spare Ribs, Potato Salad, Alabama White, BBQ Chicken, BBQ Ribs, Baby Back Ribs Mac N Cheese, Pulled Chicken, Rack of Ribs with Potato Salad and Baked Beans, Rib, Brisket, Bourbon Pecan Pie
Chuck Westcott
Picked up a rack of ribs and these are the worst ribs I've had -Overcooked and maybe cooked the day before.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Steven Schwartz
Read a review online that Rusted Silo Southern BBQ was voted Best in Indiana and Best BBQ within an hour of Indianapolis so I had to take a drive out to try and cast my own vote! All I can say is WOW!! I TOTALLY agree! This small little shack on the side of the road with a tiny BBQ sign is absolutely FANTASTIC!!! One of the best BBQ places I’ve been. I have the pulled pork and brisket with Mac n cheese and honey slaw. The pork and brisket melts in your mouth, Tender and delicious! The crew could not have been more friendly. It’s west of Indianapolis but totally worth the drive. You should come early because the place is so good they sell out quickly! Enjoy!!
Read a review online that Rusted Silo Southern BBQ was voted Best in Indiana and Best BBQ within an hour of Indianapolis so I had to take a drive out to try and cast my own vote! All I can say is WOW!! I TOTALLY agree! This small little shack on the side of the road with a tiny BBQ sign is absolutely FANTASTIC!!! One of the best BBQ places I've been. I have the pulled pork and brisket with Mac n cheese and honey slaw. The pork and brisket melts in your mouth, Tender and delicious! The crew could not have been more friendly. It's west of Indianapolis but totally worth the drive. You should come early because the place is so good they sell out quickly! Enjoy!!
The worst overpriced barbecue I have ever eaten. The brisket was dry and did not taste anything like barbecue. The sides were terrible. We'll never go back.
That was the most overpriced meal I have ever had! No BBQ taste what so ever, the meat was very dry and the sauces they had didn't taste like BBQ sauce.
Food: 1
This place is a gem! The most tender brisket EVER and the most flavorful and moist pulled pork EVER! An unbelievable beer selection and awesome staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Potato Salad, Ranch Beans, Brisket, Brisket Sandwich
Excellent service, fast, good price and excellent quality. Fascinating, the owner and the cooks, good vibes and gave us a complimentary dessert
Wow, amazing. I’m not even a huge meat eater! Spicy bbq sauce was delish too, I typically don’t like bbq sauce because it’s too sweet. Definitely one of my favorite carnivorous stops in the US ;)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best restaurant in Indiana, period.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rib
First time trying Rusted Silo. Ordered pickup. In short, some of the best Q (pork, chicken, brisket) I've tasted in some time. Got the Chuck Norris sandwich - how can you not order a sandwich named Chuck Norris, and it had pimento cheese on it. Potato salad - 5 stars. Beans - 5 stars. You get the picture. Order was ready promptly and the staff was very friendly. Will be back again soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Potato Salad, BBQ Chicken, Ranch Beans, Brisket, Brisket Sandwich
Had the brisket, the honey slaw and the ranch beans it was all very delicious!The pecan pie is to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent small town authentic barbecueParking: Parking lot is small and alongside active railroad track. It is one lane in and out . If several large pickups are here then you may have difficulty parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Peach Cobbler, Rib Sammich, Brisket Sandwich
Fabulous fish taco special for lent, always something interesting. Greens continue to be a favorite, special place, special people.
Restaurantji Recommends
Worst BBQ I've ever had .I'll never eat there again. I was very disappointed in the brisket it taste more like chuck steak .. asked for extra BBQ sauce and they wouldn't give me any .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cole Slaw, Pulled Chicken, Brisket
Quaint little location with possibly the best barbecue I've ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Cole Slaw, Sausage Platter, Full Rack of Ribs, Spare Ribs, Potato Salad, Alabama White, BBQ Chicken, BBQ Ribs, Baby Back Ribs Mac N Cheese, Pulled Chicken, Rack of Ribs with Potato Salad and Baked Beans, Rib, Brisket, Bourbon Pecan Pie
Picked up a rack of ribs and these are the worst ribs I've had -Overcooked and maybe cooked the day before.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Read a review online that Rusted Silo Southern BBQ was voted Best in Indiana and Best BBQ within an hour of Indianapolis so I had to take a drive out to try and cast my own vote! All I can say is WOW!! I TOTALLY agree! This small little shack on the side of the road with a tiny BBQ sign is absolutely FANTASTIC!!! One of the best BBQ places I’ve been. I have the pulled pork and brisket with Mac n cheese and honey slaw. The pork and brisket melts in your mouth, Tender and delicious! The crew could not have been more friendly. It’s west of Indianapolis but totally worth the drive. You should come early because the place is so good they sell out quickly! Enjoy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Honey Slaw, Brisket
Read a review online that Rusted Silo Southern BBQ was voted Best in Indiana and Best BBQ within an hour of Indianapolis so I had to take a drive out to try and cast my own vote! All I can say is WOW!! I TOTALLY agree! This small little shack on the side of the road with a tiny BBQ sign is absolutely FANTASTIC!!! One of the best BBQ places I've been. I have the pulled pork and brisket with Mac n cheese and honey slaw. The pork and brisket melts in your mouth, Tender and delicious! The crew could not have been more friendly. It's west of Indianapolis but totally worth the drive. You should come early because the place is so good they sell out quickly! Enjoy!!