Sara's Goodies

462 S Main St, Martinsville
(317) 748-5994

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Barbara Holman

Best cheese cake ever!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ken Halsne

Love the cheese cakes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Gray

Sara’s coffee and treats are all super delicious! I love trying her new cheesecake flavors, and I also love her breakfast sandwiches. Sara herself is so fun and kind and my kids absolutely love coming to visit her! Would definitely recommend!

Kid-friendliness: My two young children will ask to come here, not only for the yummy food, but also just to visit with Sara.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amber Hughes

Oh my goodness!! I had heard of Sara’s Goodies but never made it to her shop, THEN I found out Shively’s farm stand right by my house had her cheesecake! I went yesterday to their amazing little stand and got FARM FRESH BACON and 3 pieces of cheesecake!! Banana pudding, vanilla bourbon, and Nutella. I tried the banana pudding and vanilla bourbon. Both were absolutely amazing. My son had the Nutella and said it was so good. This will definitely not be my last time from the farmstand and from Sarah’s goodies!!

sophia fisher

Small and homey!! Sara is very friendly and always greets people with a warm welcome!!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free options for food and Dairy Free options for coffee

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Apple Cider Donuts, Scone

Keelie Freese

Went in today for the first time and tried to order a gluten free Oreo cake pop, she told me those are for gluten free customers only. Not sure why she assumes I’m not gluten free? I also wanted to try an Italian soda, but whoever was taking my order was also not very friendly, I decided not to order. Not happy with the service and will not be returning.

Alexandra Makris

Sara did the cake and cupcakes for our wedding reception and everything was delicious! She was very kind and flexible to work with as well. I definitely recommend her services!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erin Timco Cromer

Sara made my son’s graduation cake - gluten free chocolate cake with strawberry frosting. It was soo good! Even non gluten free guests commented on how delicious it was. We have also had her cheesecake, scones, and cake pops. All were delicious!

Baron Allstars

Really nice coffee shop, staff was friendly, service was quick, reasonable pricing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brenda R

Don't miss out on Sara's delicious coffees and baked goods! Enjoyed this spot 3 mornings in a row while in town and everything was fantastic. Tried the scone breakfast sandwiches, muffins and cheesecake and it was all fresh and tasty!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Travis Durham

Excellent local business! I visited multiple times while in town. Enjoyed the coffee, scones and cheesecake. Very friendly folks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jenny Cragen Runnebohm

This is one of my all time favorite places to come!! Everything I’ve ever had has been amazing. My favorite are the cheesecake’s Sara does. Every week is something different and so yummy. And Sara herself is so amazing she treats you like family!!!

Brenda Ratke

Delicious lattes and fresh baked goodies! Scone breakfast sandwiches and cheesecakes are incredible!

Ilse Quiroz

Best white chocolate mocha in town, love all the different flavors of coffee she has. Also the scones are delicious. My favorite is the jalapeño/ sausage one.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vonda Whitney

Cheesecakes are homemade and amazing. The homemade scone breakfast sandwiches are the best I have had.

Food: 5

Loading...