Sara's Goodies

462 S Main St, Martinsville
(317) 748-5994

Recent Reviews

Baron Allstars

Really nice coffee shop, staff was friendly, service was quick, reasonable pricing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brenda R

Don't miss out on Sara's delicious coffees and baked goods! Enjoyed this spot 3 mornings in a row while in town and everything was fantastic. Tried the scone breakfast sandwiches, muffins and cheesecake and it was all fresh and tasty!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Travis Durham

Excellent local business! I visited multiple times while in town. Enjoyed the coffee, scones and cheesecake. Very friendly folks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ilse Quiroz

Best white chocolate mocha in town, love all the different flavors of coffee she has. Also the scones are delicious. My favorite is the jalapeño/ sausage one.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Taylor S.

Sara makes the best cheesecake I've ever had in my entire life! Her store is always so clean and she and her staff are always so nice and quick!

Vonda Whitney

Cheesecakes are homemade and amazing. The homemade scone breakfast sandwiches are the best I have had.

Food: 5

Eleanor S

Love this place! Great cheesecake, coffee, Italian Sodas and other baked goodies. Sara and Porsche are both the BEST!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbi Nunemaker

I'd like to commend Sara, as a small business owner, for providing outstanding customer service! Her willingness to go above and beyond for her customers is truly commendable and sets her apart from the rest! Keep up the fantastic work Sara, and know that your efforts are truly appreciated by your customers and the community you serve.I reached out to Sara, and told her I would like to have a surprise delivered to my boss for Bosses day. She gave me some recommendations for a treat she may enjoy, and went out and purchased a Bosses day balloon on her own time to include in the surprise! I can’t wait to hear from my boss this afternoon when her surprise is delivered!

Jimmy Greeson

Delicious goodies!

Mikaela B.

Literally everything she makes is amazing. Coffee, italian sodas, scones, macarons, CHEESECAKE! She literally has something for everyone. She is the nicest person as well. If you are ever in town, you have to go here. Lots of comfy seats around to enjoy your goodies.

Hannah Erdos

Sara has made me multiple custom cakes and cheesecakes and they are always absolutely incredible! I can't imagine going anywhere else. She has so many flavors to choose from, and they are all delicious. And her coffees are amazing too! Tons of options, including non-dairy milk and decaf. Her customer service is simply the best, if I lived closer I would be there every day! An absolute must try, you'll love it.

Christina Anderson

Best cheesecake around! Great service and hospitality!

Mikaela Bialy

Sara is incredibly kind and everything she makes is amazing! The cheesecake-stuffed-cakes are to die for.

Lisa Tyler

Great selection of coffee, teas, lattes and baked goods! Sara’s goodies also offers her divine cheesecakes and other goods to order or for catering! Sara’s fall seasonal selection of lattes and sweets are fabulous! You’ve gotta try the jalapeño cheddar scones and the cheesecakes!!!! To die for!!!

Haley Tomlinson

Sara & her daughter are absolutely lovely❤️ The sweets are SO amazing and definitely made with love!❤️ Pictured is the Apple butter cheesecake & apple cider donuts they were both to die for!You HAVE to get a box of apple cider donuts, you will not regret it! Definitely stop in for great service and delicious treats!✨

Load More