Farina's Supper Club

3311 Pottawattomie Trail, Michigan City
(219) 874-7729

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert

Quaint Italian restaurant in the middle of a neighborhood. Great ambiance, awesome food and service.

Ron

Macee was a great server. The food was on point as always. Wife and I come here every year for our anniversary, never been disappointed. Love this place!!!

Bev

Evening out with friends at Farina's Supper Club was great! The food was excellent and the servings were so large two of us took home tomorrow's lunch. The appetizers were equally delicious and generous servings The drinks were good, especially the Blackberry Whiskey Sours. Our server was attentive, but not hovering and gave clear and helpful descriptions of the menu items when we asked for more information. The chocolate cake and gelatos for dessert pushed it all over the top for us!!!' We all appreciated the peaceful ambiance of the restaurant. It made it easy to have conversation without shouting over any noisy clatter or loud music that we experience in many restaurants. Impressed with the manager stopping by our table to ask how the food and service had been. We definitely will be returning again.

Opentable Diner

Beautiful place. Super large portions, everything was so delicious! Staff were professional and so friendly. This is a must try!

Joseph

We enjoyed a delicious holiday brunch experience at Farinas Supper Club this past Easter Sunday. Starting with cocktails at the bar all the way through dinner it was fantastic. Eggs Benedict from the Easter menu followed by lamb chops velasco and Sunday salad followed by the neighborhood platter were our selections and one was better than the other. Staff was friendly and service was top notch. highly recommend trying it if you haven't already.

Michael

Food and Service was excellent. Our only issue was our table was right outside the kitchen door. It was extremely noisy at that table. We know now to ask to be seated away from the Kitchen.

Mary

We were there early before the crowds arrived. Our waitress was very attentive. The food was delicious. The portions are large, and are easily shareable. Our guests hadn't been there before and loved it.

T B

Decent First time experience. Kelsey was fantastic as a bartender. Pork chops came out a bit on the drier side, but calamari was fire 🤤

Service: 5

Tara LaRose

Food was phenomenal, staff was phenomenal! Shout out to our sweet waitress, Kendra! Tucked back in a nice wooded neighborhood. Highly recommend!

Steve B

This restaurant is amazing. Food, service and ambiance are all top of the line. Recommend going here.

Service: 5

Pat Bruton

Very upset with this place. I paid $42 basically for a plate of risotto and 4 medium size scallops. Ridiculous ! And their food caused me indigestion for half of my evening. I will never go back and do not recommend this restaurant. Dining room has a strange odor, which should of been my clue to leave, but I've wanted to try this supper club for a while. Such a disappointment. The only good I can say, is that my waitress was excellent.

Service: 5

Y U

It's a fabulous place to celebrate any occasion!

Lisa Stoffregen

This is a restaurant with wonderful Italian food.

Service: 5

Margaret O'Donnell

This place is a one of a kind treasure! It's set in a beautiful beach side neighborhood and is quite romantic yet lively for family and friends. There is an incredible cozy pub off the lobby (it was an inn at one point) and then the large restaurant is spread throughout a few grand rooms/spaces throughout 1 level which makes the entire atmosphere more intimate and interesting. In the summertime, there is a wonderful stone patio set within the trees which adds to the atmosphere. The food is amazing! We always order wine because they carry so many authentic wines I can't find anywhere around here. I love their bread but always need to be sure to save room for dinner. We sampled several of the delicious appetizers family-style between the group (the calamari is a must and we had the famous meatballs) then moved on to some incredible entrees. My lamb chops were so tender and the portion was so big that I was able to enjoy them for lunch the next day! We were stuffed by the end of the meal but have learned to take home a dessert to share for later because they are THAT good. I love this place and am so glad it is so close to home. It's like Chicago (or Italy) are in my backyard!

Service: 5

olufemi fabode

Had a pick up order, food was delicious and didn't have any wait.

Service: 5

Loading...