Margaritas Mexican Restaurant

500 Spring Valley Dr, Middlebury
(574) 825-5454

Recent Reviews

Candace Anderson

This place is the worst “Mexican” restaurant I have ever been to! $70 for three of us to eat. the chimichanga was a tostada with greasy meat! The shrimp cocktail was $16 with barely any shrimp the cocktail with almost to sour to eat! We all felt sick that night after eating there! Plus they are rude… DO NOT Recommend!! If there was an option for O stars I would have did that instead of 1

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kristen Hanson

Good was so bland we couldn't finish service wasn't much better. It was my first and last time going here.

Service: 1

William Coffey

This come from a deer friend that just eat at restaurant. Service was terrible. They need retrain staff in bei g human beings. No internet at last minute. Then tell customers cash only. Then get up set with customers that don't have it.

Gregory Richards

Little storefront restaurant. Good food, friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Manuel Rios

Visited 11-19-24. Had the pollo loco plate. It looks very simple, but it has great taste. The rice had good flavor and texture, but the beans tasted a little sour. The plate don’t come with tortillas, but I ate it with tortilla chips. The dipping sauce is really good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Tamara Lemon

Great food!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steven Mullet

We are currently sitting in the restaurant and they are out of salsa, lemons, lime, and the water tastes awful, the mellow yellow is watered down, and the bathroom only has hot water. Hopefully the food is better than everything else has been so far.

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 2

Whitney Churchill

Severely overpriced! I ordered take tonight's(1/19/24). I ordered the chimichanga meal and a small side of the queso. The online menu says that meal is 8.99 and when I picked it up I rang up at $24. When I asked the kid about the price (showed him the online menu) he showed me their menu that says 12.99. He was all kinds of sorry and even said he’s mentioned it to the owner multiple times.

Food: 2

Barry Kercher

Ordered a 2 taco meal with rice and beans for $13.99. At the end of the meal, we didn't receive an itemized bill...was told to go up to up to the register to pay. Still no itemized bill. Waitress rang up our charge for $24...for 2 tacos and small amount rice and beans. When asked to see an itemized bill, they up charged lettuce, cheese and onions on the tacos. I don't remember the exact charges but approximately...$1.50 cheese,$2 lettuce and $1.10 for onion ON EACH Taco.Unfortunately, we will not be back. Owners need to reconsider their business practices.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Charlene H

Food was ice cold when brought out, after waiting nearly an hour for food. No one ever brought drinks after asking twice, and They are chronically understaffed & terrible service. We won't be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jerry Beechy

Was one of our go to restaurants we went to regularly . Since opening 2nd location food Quality and service has went down. Ordered a grande burrito ( which was usually full) came out not even half of burrito was filled. Service wasn't much better.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Rj

We love the food and the margaritas!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Burrito Deluxe and Enchiladas Verdes, Refried Beans, Mango, Chicken Mole, Burrito Supreme, Steak, Enchilada, Taco Salad, Quesadilla, Chimichanga, Tamale, Cheese Dip, Grande Burrito, Burrito, Taco, Beef Tamale and Chicken Flauta, Guacamole, Salsa

Jon Hall

We ate here around 2pm on November 11th 2023 .We walked in , no one else in restaurant and stood there about 5 minutes before someone came from back and acknowledged us and there were NO OTHER CUSTOMERS in the restaurant. A lady came in behind us and 4 ladys came in just before we left . Bean dip got cold within a couple minutes . We ordered Dr.Pepper and he brought us root beer which my wife can't stand . Argued with us that it was Dr.Pepper . I ordered the dinner steak fajitas cause I didn't want the small lunch portion . He brought it out and there was a huge pile of onions and peppers and very little meat , less than the lunch portion . When I questioned it , he argued that it was the dinner portion . I said that isn't worth $10 little alone $18 and I wouldn't be back . He made some sound and walked off . Then a young lady came out of the back and leaned against the wall staring at me . I started staring back and she shook her head and went back in the back area .This used to be a great place 2 years ago and now it's horrible . They have lost our business . The food gets cold extremely fast and less than a lunch portion on a dinner portion that you pay double for and the young guy server has no customer service skills ! I only gave a 2 on the food because it had decent flavor but not worth what you pay and gets cold extremely fast !!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Brandy Wilson

They were super busy due to the events in the area. Our server did great! Food was delicious and drinks were strong!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Lora Knapp

Came here to celebrate our son's birthday. Worse restaurant experience we've ever had. Need to train servers. Only 4 tables when we arrived. Asked for napkins and ice 3 times. Husband ordered seafood enchiladas,came out as beef. All of our food was very small portions. burrito was literally a 1/4 inch thick with burnt chorizo and literally 3 small chunks of chicken. Spent 110 dollars and had to come home and fix food. Stood at counter literally 30 minutes to pay. Had to ask twice if someone could ring us up. We will never be back. I'm sure a lot of the people that came in tonight are saying the same

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More