I grew up in Cincinnati, and we had a brick and mortar Godfathers, and I loved it. It closed down and was saddened by it. I grew up thinking that I wouldn't ever be able to taste that buttery crust only the way they did it ever again. I moved to Mt Vernon, Indiana, and found out that there was one in one of the local gas stations. I was very skeptical about going there until I just said, "Well, the only thing that could happen is that it's not how I remembered." Much to my surprise, it still tasted the exact same as I remembered. The nostalgia I felt in the first bite! It took me right back to being a kid again, only being able to eat just half a slice because of how my dad used to order the pizzas. The guy that works at the particular location, his name is Dre and is awesome!! He always has a smile on his face and now knows me by name and knows the exact thing I'm ordering as soon as I walk in.
Vegetarian options: They veggie style pizzas
Parking: It's a gas station
Kid-friendliness: It's a gas station
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cassie W
It's a gas station. Do not get high hopes.
Food: 2
Service: 3
The Burden Sisters
Led me on for 5 minutes not saying everything was closed just said not atm everytime I asked for a food waste of time
Martin Berry
Always great pizza
Audra Wood
Very decent pizza, the breakfast pizzas are the best.
Favorite pizza 🍕🤤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Favorite pizza 🍕🤤
Always clean and very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I grew up in Cincinnati, and we had a brick and mortar Godfathers, and I loved it. It closed down and was saddened by it. I grew up thinking that I wouldn't ever be able to taste that buttery crust only the way they did it ever again. I moved to Mt Vernon, Indiana, and found out that there was one in one of the local gas stations. I was very skeptical about going there until I just said, "Well, the only thing that could happen is that it's not how I remembered." Much to my surprise, it still tasted the exact same as I remembered. The nostalgia I felt in the first bite! It took me right back to being a kid again, only being able to eat just half a slice because of how my dad used to order the pizzas. The guy that works at the particular location, his name is Dre and is awesome!! He always has a smile on his face and now knows me by name and knows the exact thing I'm ordering as soon as I walk in.
Vegetarian options: They veggie style pizzas
Parking: It's a gas station
Kid-friendliness: It's a gas station
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a gas station. Do not get high hopes.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Led me on for 5 minutes not saying everything was closed just said not atm everytime I asked for a food waste of time
Always great pizza
Very decent pizza, the breakfast pizzas are the best.
Always great pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Fresh food; Good customer service.
Worse place in town to get food
Awesome place to grab a quick lunch
Great pizza
Decent pizza
Loading...