You should were a jacket. The cooling system, whether it needs to be on for the customer does for the grill cook. And he is just behind the bar. The evening we were at the Yellow Tavern was beautiful T-shirt weather. Luckily I had a sweatshirt and raincoat in the car as it was freezing indoor for dinner. Our waitress came back to the table once. With the ticket. I do not remember what food we ordered. I was too cold and just wanted out. Others did seem to be enjoying themselves.
Ruby Reynolds
Definitely will be back! Great food, Great environment!
Ben Smith
Meh. This is one of those places locals love but no one knows why. Three of us showed up for lunch. There was maybe 4 other tables. The bartender/server was definitely overwhelmed. Watching her work was excruciating, for drink refills she would grab one cup at a time walk back to the bar, refill it, then come grab another one. The burgers were incredibly overcooked and dried out. It's cash only, so that's always fun.
Charles Scates
Great vibes and really good pizza!
Dwight Esche
Never been there
Val Sei
The Yellow Tavern has a cozy atmosphere in the beautiful town of New Harmony, Indiana. They offer a nice selection of spirits and tasty food items. Their pizza is great, along with their steaks and homemade dessert of the day. Cash only. Popular restaurant.
Dragontrik
Food wasn't that good for the price. The waitress was friendly but you could tell she was over worked. She tried and did a good job. I gave an extra star cause of her other wise it would of been 2 star.
Shari
Average food. Service was nice. They do not take debit or credit cards, but there is an ATM machine.
Mr Strouth
Great food, great place. Love it. FYI, cash or check, no credit cards.
We love their pizza. The toppings are fresh and the crust was just right. Great food!
Roxie TEMPUS
Sadly after a fun day roaming around shops in New Harmony, we thought we would stop in for dinner before heading to our room. I say sadly because we did not feel welcome, we did not feel appreciated and our server acted like we were an inconvenience . The fried mushrooms we had as an appetizer were great and that is where the “great ended”. Our patty melts were ok. The meat was cooked perfectly. My husband said that maybe it was because we did not order a beer or any liquor. I did order a soft drink with my meal, but it seemed to annoy her to get me a refill and one refill is all I got. Our waters were not even refilled. Then to top it all off, when the check came, that is when we found out that they didn't take cards and only accepted cash or checks. Good thing I had both! First time there and last time. Should have gone to our room and had the fresh tomatoes and Armenian cucumbers that were given to us by another business in town. Everyone has a bad day, and maybe that was the case with our server. Maybe tomorrow will be better, but someone else can try it.
Vegetarian options: We did see vegetarian chili available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Anthony Wood
Pizza was good and the kraut balls were excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Loaded Pizza
Todd Lewis
The Pork chops were cooked perfectly tender and moist, the baked potato, broccoli w/cheese accommodated the meal well. Great service at a reasonable price.
Parking: You can park on street for free maybe 8 close spots out front, around back (ally) there's 10 potential spots
Wheelchair accessibility: I don't remember seeing any.
There was a bit of a wait, but only because they're shortstaffed. Despite the wait, the waitress was attentive and checked up on us often. The food was AMAZING. I will be thinking about that pizza for the rest of my life. Best pizza I've ever had. And super cheap too.
Great food
You should were a jacket. The cooling system, whether it needs to be on for the customer does for the grill cook. And he is just behind the bar. The evening we were at the Yellow Tavern was beautiful T-shirt weather. Luckily I had a sweatshirt and raincoat in the car as it was freezing indoor for dinner.
Our waitress came back to the table once. With the ticket.
I do not remember what food we ordered. I was too cold and just wanted out.
Others did seem to be enjoying themselves.
Definitely will be back! Great food, Great environment!
Meh. This is one of those places locals love but no one knows why. Three of us showed up for lunch. There was maybe 4 other tables. The bartender/server was definitely overwhelmed. Watching her work was excruciating, for drink refills she would grab one cup at a time walk back to the bar, refill it, then come grab another one. The burgers were incredibly overcooked and dried out. It's cash only, so that's always fun.
Great vibes and really good pizza!
Never been there
The Yellow Tavern has a cozy atmosphere in the beautiful town of New Harmony, Indiana. They offer a nice selection of spirits and tasty food items. Their pizza is great, along with their steaks and homemade dessert of the day. Cash only. Popular restaurant.
Food wasn't that good for the price. The waitress was friendly but you could tell she was over worked. She tried and did a good job. I gave an extra star cause of her other wise it would of been 2 star.
Average food. Service was nice. They do not take debit or credit cards, but there is an ATM machine.
Great food, great place. Love it.
FYI, cash or check, no credit cards.
Restaurantji Recommends
We love their pizza. The toppings are fresh and the crust was just right. Great food!
Sadly after a fun day roaming around shops in New Harmony, we thought we would stop in for dinner before heading to our room. I say sadly because we did not feel welcome, we did not feel appreciated and our server acted like we were an inconvenience . The fried mushrooms we had as an appetizer were great and that is where the “great ended”. Our patty melts were ok. The meat was cooked perfectly. My husband said that maybe it was because we did not order a beer or any liquor. I did order a soft drink with my meal, but it seemed to annoy her to get me a refill and one refill is all I got. Our waters were not even refilled. Then to top it all off, when the check came, that is when we found out that they didn't take cards and only accepted cash or checks. Good thing I had both! First time there and last time. Should have gone to our room and had the fresh tomatoes and Armenian cucumbers that were given to us by another business in town. Everyone has a bad day, and maybe that was the case with our server. Maybe tomorrow will be better, but someone else can try it.
Vegetarian options: We did see vegetarian chili available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Pizza was good and the kraut balls were excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Loaded Pizza
The Pork chops were cooked perfectly tender and moist, the baked potato, broccoli w/cheese accommodated the meal well. Great service at a reasonable price.
Parking: You can park on street for free maybe 8 close spots out front, around back (ally) there's 10 potential spots
Wheelchair accessibility: I don't remember seeing any.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breaded Pork Tenderloin Sandwich, Bread Pudding, Ruben Sandwich, Bacon Cheeseburger, Loaded Pizza, Patty Melt, Ribeye Sandwich, Pistachio Cake
There was a bit of a wait, but only because they're shortstaffed. Despite the wait, the waitress was attentive and checked up on us often. The food was AMAZING. I will be thinking about that pizza for the rest of my life. Best pizza I've ever had. And super cheap too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...