Frosty Boy Drive In

40 W Main St, New Palestine
(317) 861-5433

Recent Reviews

Derek Gustin

If you like classic drive-in food, Frosty Boy is the place to go. I chose the tenderloin sandwich today. I would classify it as a pork fritter but it's still good and the toppings are fresh. The onion chips are excellent. Make sure you save room for ice cream. The shakes and flurries are both great. Be prepared to wait if you go during the summer.Parking: Angled parking all around the building.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Flurry, Onion Chips

Julie T.

Don't bother with going through the drive thru. They make you park the walk up to get your food. Extremely slow service and rude employees

Philip B.

Everything I love about small-town living. Service is great. Ice cream is great. Love the outdoor seating for times when we decide to eat there rather than take home. Highly recommend.

Jake P.

I've never spit out a cheeseburger until today. Plus after waiting 20 minutes for a single cheeseburger, no fries or anything else. Truly was the most disgusting burger I've ever had. I can still taste the grease. Gross.

Seth B.

Frosty boy is a local classic. Stopped in this evening and the service was good and staff was very friendly. They were still pretty busy close to closing time, and you could tell the staff was all working very hard to get orders out in a timely manner. I got a hot fudge sundae with cheesecake and it was delicious!

Chris B.

Went here tonight and the service was terrible. The employees do a good job there just aren't enough of them. You can probably drive to the nearest Dairy Queen, order your food, and drive home in the amount of time it takes to get your order here. This place is getting by on being the only game in town. If a good ice cream place moved into town they'd be in trouble. To the food. It's nothing great. It's not awful but definitely not worth the wait. If you're going by during the day and there's no line maybe give it a shot. But if you go when it's busy my suggestion would be to keep on driving because you'll be disappointed.

Michelle S.

This is a staple in New Pal. The ice cream is very good. The food is delish and they offer so many different treats. It is a great place to hang out with friends or after team events. The staff is friendly and courteous.

Craig W.

I like that I can order any menu item from Dairy Queen and no one corrects me, they just do their best to make something similar. Also saw a girl eating a crunch cone with a snake around her neck once. It was pretty good size too. +5 ambience.

Kari W.

Always fresh cooked food, yummy ice-cream & friendly fun atmosphere. Reasonable prices great variety for everyone & pretty speedy considering they are always busy. Great home town treats served with smiles!

LaDonna Whiteside

lines for drive thru crazy

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

LaRyne C.

This is one place that you cannot pass up when driving through town. From the food to their shakes and to their ice cream sundaes. If you grew up out here you know this was definitely a spot to go to when you got a sweet tooth craving. The staff is always kind to everyone and the prices are pretty good. I definitely recommend to stop by here!

Kristina Smith

Love this place. Definitely one of our favorite when it's

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Reese

patsy Richardson

Hot dogs are terrible. Tenderloin & fries good. Ice cream great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Whip

Cameron A.

Really good ice cream, nice place to sit outside and enjoy a treat. Tables are not very nice and verily ever clean. Always wrapped around building for drive thru. Sometimes, staff can be a little rude. But the product is fantastic. It would be nice if they were open all year, but they are not they close for winter. Would love to have inside dining and better parking. But it's never going to happen...just one of the small town businesses.

Santos Cortez

My first time here and my family enjoyed it very much! The food was delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Cheeseburger

Load More