Y-Not Pizza & Lounge

45 E Main St, New Palestine
(317) 861-5225

Recent Reviews

Trina H.

Charming small town pub. Other guests were so very friendly and that added to the charm. Service was awesome, and the pizza was delicious! Give it a try!

Shannon K.

Love this locally owned pizza place. The staff is always friendly and helpful. The pizza and breadsticks are a hit with our family. We particularly love the crumbled sausage and bacon pizza. This is in one of our permanent rotation for pizza night.

Jamie

Ok generally the pizzas are great thats why we return. And I gave it a 2 star because the staff are friendly and accommodating.However today was not up to par. I ordered 2 LG pizza's and bread sticks. I ordered the crust hand tossed which I believe is 2.00 more unfortunately the crust was not done so sad. I dont understand how you can get crust so thin not cooked all the way. We finished cooking it in our oven we we got home. Not going to be the same but what can you do.?

Chaz W.

Pizza always good. Always ask for extra pepperonis. Willing to pay the cost. Today over the phone he said that they come with it. Went to pick it up. And he forgot the one that "come with it" when reminded him this is what I got. Rather pay for the extra then get this one the house. Love the pizza tho. To me the pepperonis are the one that's make it.

Not Today

First time visit to this pizza joint.We received coupons in the mail.We decided to use the "Y-Not" deal coupon- large 1 top/ breadsticks/ 2 liter $20. I called in, told them the coupon I had, gave them the order ( half pepp& half mushroom). They gave me a total- $21 and change, pick up in 20 min.When my husband walked out to the truck, he only had a pizza and the coupon. I showed him where it said we were supposed to get the breadsticks and 2 liter.I called in to the store, asked why we didn't receive the others, and they said we added toppings. But they would get the breadsticks and 2 liter.He (very) reluctantly walked back in, and came out but had to pay an additional $3.60/ $3.80 something. They didn't give a receipt.So because we had half and half toppings, it was that additional charge.I was NOT happy, but whatever.Got home and tasted it.VERY chewy (pre-made) crust. Hard to chew. I mean- my jaws were getting sore so I just ate the toppings after a few pieces. The breadsticks were hot, but dry- even with the cold cheddar cheese.Overall- would NOT recommend this at ALL! Will NOT be back.Parking: Hard to maneuver in the back lot. The door opened to the kitchen.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Maureen Leland

Decided to give them another try. I should not have done that. Lesson learned, will never order from them again. The pizza was cold and appeared to have been sitting for some time, dried out and worse than any frozen pizza i have ever eaten. Don't waste your money!!!

Food: 1

Scott Folck

I live in walking distance, I asked for one simple request. No onions.. they put onions on the sandwich I ordered. So I walked there, and tipped.. which is crazy on my end. And they did apologize.. which is great.. but they lied and told me they had got super busy in the 20 minutes that I ordered the sandwich. I can literally see this place from my back porch. And they decided to lie instead of owning up to a mistake or making it better. I gotta say, that was disappointing. Very disappointing. Hopefully management can learn how to take an order, or simply make a customer (that lives basically next door) a little more satisfied. What a waste of $17.. can't believe I threw them a tip. They just lost a customer. I mean they couldn't even communicate when they switched the phone to the manager. Smh.. wow. Oh, I almost forgot jalapenos are included upon request, of course they forgot that. And don't get nachos. Apparently they have a cheese shortage. What an incompetent place. And yes, I'm going to complain a whole $17 worth.. maybe they digest this post better than the food I ate. I threw it away half way through. Again..wow.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Scott F.

I refer you to my Google review if you're really considering ordering from this place. To sum it up, I'd spend your hard earned dollar elsewhere.

Robert brown

Never answer the phone. Call someone else.

Seth R

Man the pizza is amazing the service though always sucks. And the building itself is like falling apart in places.My real gripe is with the rude older woman who works in the kitchen and the fact that they charge an extra percentile to process card payments. I tried to suggest other payment processors and she got huffy with me like I had insulted her. Idk I'll order carryout here but I'll wait for other people to cash me out.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Two Toppings Pizza

Paul Warner

Megan was our beer tender, was very nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adam Smith

Kitchen was closing, pulled in starving after a long work day in the cold rain. Manager opened the grill back up to make sure we didn’t go home hungry. Can’t tell you how much that means and I want others to know this small town pizza joint is the place to go. 5 out of 5!!!!

Rick Farmer

This has the feel of a little mom & pop hole in the wall that seems to cater to local regulars. It looked old and tired. Our marginal food was served in paper lined plastic baskets, justified by somewhat reasonable prices.Kid-friendliness: Too kid friendly as a 10 year old boy was allowed to play video games the bar.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

kerstin paulson

Fresh hot soooo good! Looks like they’re making some changes also hope they stay open for much longer

Mark Strater

Best bartenders ever, food is awesome

Load More