Casey's

8330 Kepley Drive NE, New Salisbury
(812) 485-9859

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ginger Kitterman

Great respect employees and very clean.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Russell Goodman

Let's be realistic people. This is a gas station. The atmosphere is a gas station. The staff is friendly, however, this being a new store they seem to have a lot of issues with the equipment in the store. Store. They had the door voltage shut for quite some time because it literally fell off the hinges. HVAC went down, the pizza ovens went down, the fountain drink machines went down. I love the store. The store I still stop there all the time and I get pizza from them because they have good pizza.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jeremy Williams

Nothing like Casey's everything, especially the Pizza 🍕!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bradly Frederick

God service quality fountain drinks

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

James Davidson

Best pizza at a gas station. Staff's always friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tommie Seibert

Best food EVER!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charles Conrad

Nice clean new store. Still getting the bugs worked out but it will be a nice spot for gas and quick visits. Hot food available also. Fresh pizza has always been good when I have ordered it

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Benjamin Reinhart

Everything I pre-order a pizza from this location it is not ready, nor even cooked by the time that I arrive. Staff makes excuses and is rude.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Gregory Milburn

Stopped for Quick Food Stop, Not Much Ready, waited 10 minutes for Chicken Tenders, Charge 50 cents for Sauces, Good Tenders, but Service not that great, not real friendly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

charles henderson

Sorry to the staff and employees there at Casey. To those saw my star ratings was. A mistake, I took Casey and Dairy Dip!. So for give me. For false information. They had no wrong doings. BECAUSE of my era. Im sure that these people at Casey have good food and nice folks.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Scott

You will get sick eating here, employees not well trained in food Safety. Stay away if you value your health.

Robbie Hawkins

Overall a good gas station I unfortunately can't give it 5 stars though because they are very inconsistent with there hot food being available and they are bad about keeping cups stocked for their fountain drinks.

Logan Waynescott

Would love to give 5 stars, however its difficult when almost everytime I walk in the line to checkout is always wrapped halfway around the store and one poor employee is working their butts off to keep up leaves a bad impression. Also at 4 in the afternoon pizza should be readily available. There was no pizza, burgers, tater bites, regular chicken sandwiches, the only thing available was spicy chicken sandwiches. Definitely needs more people working!

Brenda osman

Out of cheese, out of lettuce. Out of tomatoes. Out of banana peppers, its only wed.
Ordered 2 pizzas today wasted 2 hours of my day. Sold my first one out from under me. The next one I called in they said 20 minutes I walked in 23 minutes later the order hadn't even been started. Management couldn't even apologize, the assistant.
They are way beyond the new stage.
The audacity of the cashier telling me they doing the best they can???? The store was empty and I replied doing the best they can would be putting the order in as they are called in. I spent over 100 dollars in there today. Beyond insanity !!!
As far as being out of everything ALL THE TIME why is the management not checking the truck orders. Zero excuses at this point.
Last week I ordered a taco pizza and it had 3 tomatoes, 5 banana peppers which i was charged extra for and no taco chips, zero
My daughter the next day very same thing.
Back to small town support.
Screw corporations and big box.
7 chances and all 7 a miserable fail

Rose “Rosie”

This store is such a breath of fresh air for this area. The building is very clean and organized. Along with that, the food is really good, especially for gas station standards. The staff has been so friendly the past few times I've been there. Since it's a newly opened store, there are a few hiccups such as online/app orders not being available and some confusion with coupons, which is understandable since they have been so busy the first few days. But I'm confident they'll get the kinks straightened out. Hang in there and keep up the great work. :)

Loading...