Lindsay was absolutely amazing! From the moment we sat down, she made us feel right at home with her friendly attitude and top-notch service. She recommended the hand-cut ribeye special, and it did not disappoint — perfectly cooked and full of flavor. For dessert, she insisted we try the homemade cheesecake, and wow… she was right again. It was rich, creamy, and the perfect way to end the meal.
Huge thanks to Lindsay for making the night memorable — we'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Conner
I had always heard great things about this establishment and let’s just say they were spot on. Absolutely loved the food, the service and the atmosphere. The Mac Daddy burger was fantastic along with the cheese curds! We will definitely be returning customers!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cory Tubbs
We just moved back home after 7 years and decided to give Prime Time Newburgh a shot for dinner. We’re used to our favorite spots in places like Bardstown Road and East Louisville, but wow—this was a great welcome back! The food was absolutely amazing. I tried their new smash burger (so good!), my husband had the prime rib sandwich, and both of our kiddos got the mac and cheese—which my husband insists deserves a shoutout for being super creamy and delicious.
But where Prime Time really shines is their service. It honestly deserves 20/5 stars. Our waitress was fantastic—super attentive, patient with all our menu questions, and checked in often. Even the manager stopped by multiple times to make sure we were doing well. Our kids are 3 and 5, so let’s just say things can get a little… energetic. Our daughter ended up busting her lip while playing in the booth. Within seconds of hearing her cry, our server was right there with a homemade ice pack, checking on her and making sure she was okay. Not long after, she came back with a surprise dessert to help cheer her up. Then the manager came out to check on her too. It was all incredibly thoughtful and above-and-beyond.
We left so impressed. A 10/10 experience, and we’re already looking forward to coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Denise Yoke
Great burger. Burgers were half price. Good onion rings and tots. Order was a little off but enjoyed the food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Ebony Donahue
man that big mac daddy burger was amazing the waitress was great but……… it was hot as i think hell would be i mean hot hot
Diana Clark
We have been there twice and enjoyed the food and great service both times. We will definitely go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick Martin
Great food, service and atmosphere. Love the steak salad!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jake Jones
We recently moved to Newburgh and have been trying to find the best local restaurants. We had passed Prime Time Pub once or twice and decided to stop in for dinner last night and couldn’t be happier with the place. The food was incredible, unquestionably the best burger I’ve had in the area so far. The prime dip looked and sounded so good that we came back again the next day and it didn’t disappoint. Very reasonably priced, especially considering just how good the food was. Our server Lindsey was phenomenal as well. Extremely attentive to the table making sure we were taken care of, as well as great recommendations and and courteous service. Prime Time will definitely be a place we visit often!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janice Jillson
We had a party of 14 there for a retirement lunch. Our server Lindsey was excellent. Food (orders ranged from chicken wrap to burgers to steak bowl) was wonderfully prepared and served on time. We will return for our next gathering!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac Daddy, The Prime Burger, Homemade Potato Chips, House Made Chips
Tina Forsythe
Our first visit & won't be our last!! The food was amazing!! Had prime sandwich & bourbon glazed mac & cheese. Lindsey our server gave us great recommendations & gave us outstanding service!! Oh and don't forget the beignets!!!!
The appetizer and sides were good, but the shrimp dinner and smothered chicken entrees were bland. The waitress was nice but kept messing up. For an 80 dollar dinner we expected more. It was our first time and I wish I had researched what their specialties were.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Elizabeth Massey
We have never had a bad experience here! The service and food is always outstanding, dining in or take out. The outdoor seating is an added bonus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shelby Evans
Nice decor. Friendly server and attentive. Food had good taste and wasn't too long of a wait. Little over $20 with tip. A bit higher than I usually like spending for lunch but it was good.
Khaleesi
Took my furbabies out to lunch today (05/11/2025) of course sat outside in the patio service was good, meat the heat burger (asked for a little pink) was dry as all get out!!!! Had to drink 2 glasses of water & that still didn’t help!!! Got a grilled chicken breast for the kiddos (didn’t know until I paid they have a dig menu) will take them back again, as I do like the meat the heat burger… thankfully it was half price burger Monday!!!
Lindsay was absolutely amazing! From the moment we sat down, she made us feel right at home with her friendly attitude and top-notch service. She recommended the hand-cut ribeye special, and it did not disappoint — perfectly cooked and full of flavor. For dessert, she insisted we try the homemade cheesecake, and wow… she was right again. It was rich, creamy, and the perfect way to end the meal.
Huge thanks to Lindsay for making the night memorable — we'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had always heard great things about this establishment and let’s just say they were spot on. Absolutely loved the food, the service and the atmosphere. The Mac Daddy burger was fantastic along with the cheese curds! We will definitely be returning customers!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just moved back home after 7 years and decided to give Prime Time Newburgh a shot for dinner. We’re used to our favorite spots in places like Bardstown Road and East Louisville, but wow—this was a great welcome back! The food was absolutely amazing. I tried their new smash burger (so good!), my husband had the prime rib sandwich, and both of our kiddos got the mac and cheese—which my husband insists deserves a shoutout for being super creamy and delicious.
But where Prime Time really shines is their service. It honestly deserves 20/5 stars. Our waitress was fantastic—super attentive, patient with all our menu questions, and checked in often. Even the manager stopped by multiple times to make sure we were doing well. Our kids are 3 and 5, so let’s just say things can get a little… energetic. Our daughter ended up busting her lip while playing in the booth. Within seconds of hearing her cry, our server was right there with a homemade ice pack, checking on her and making sure she was okay. Not long after, she came back with a surprise dessert to help cheer her up. Then the manager came out to check on her too. It was all incredibly thoughtful and above-and-beyond.
We left so impressed. A 10/10 experience, and we’re already looking forward to coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great burger. Burgers were half price. Good onion rings and tots. Order was a little off but enjoyed the food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
man that big mac daddy burger was amazing the waitress was great but……… it was hot as i think hell would be i mean hot hot
We have been there twice and enjoyed the food and great service both times. We will definitely go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, service and atmosphere. Love the steak salad!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We recently moved to Newburgh and have been trying to find the best local restaurants. We had passed Prime Time Pub once or twice and decided to stop in for dinner last night and couldn’t be happier with the place. The food was incredible, unquestionably the best burger I’ve had in the area so far. The prime dip looked and sounded so good that we came back again the next day and it didn’t disappoint. Very reasonably priced, especially considering just how good the food was. Our server Lindsey was phenomenal as well. Extremely attentive to the table making sure we were taken care of, as well as great recommendations and and courteous service. Prime Time will definitely be a place we visit often!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a party of 14 there for a retirement lunch. Our server Lindsey was excellent. Food (orders ranged from chicken wrap to burgers to steak bowl) was wonderfully prepared and served on time. We will return for our next gathering!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac Daddy, The Prime Burger, Homemade Potato Chips, House Made Chips
Our first visit & won't be our last!! The food was amazing!! Had prime sandwich & bourbon glazed mac & cheese. Lindsey our server gave us great recommendations & gave us outstanding service!! Oh and don't forget the beignets!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The appetizer and sides were good, but the shrimp dinner and smothered chicken entrees were bland. The waitress was nice but kept messing up. For an 80 dollar dinner we expected more. It was our first time and I wish I had researched what their specialties were.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
We have never had a bad experience here! The service and food is always outstanding, dining in or take out. The outdoor seating is an added bonus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice decor. Friendly server and attentive. Food had good taste and wasn't too long of a wait. Little over $20 with tip. A bit higher than I usually like spending for lunch but it was good.
Took my furbabies out to lunch today (05/11/2025) of course sat outside in the patio service was good, meat the heat burger (asked for a little pink) was dry as all get out!!!! Had to drink 2 glasses of water & that still didn’t help!!! Got a grilled chicken breast for the kiddos (didn’t know until I paid they have a dig menu) will take them back again, as I do like the meat the heat burger… thankfully it was half price burger Monday!!!
Very good meal and service was great.
Loading...