Pizza is pretty good if you scrape off the toppings from the crust and put it on a roof tile!
Mike Henshaw
Always a great meal. I've been going since they opened back around 1990 I think.
Diane Alumbaugh
Best pizza around. Genious toppings, quality ingredients, fast, and friendly.
William Bramer
Stumbled upon this local pizza shop... Had heard a lot of things about it. I decided to give it a shot. In a small building on the corner it looks very unassuming but it hides a delicious secret. Pizza on Midwestern flop/fold crust with block mozzarella cheese cooked in a stone oven. I had left my card behind and walked outside and the lady who taking my order brought it out with my pizza. Good hearted folks keeping old fashioned pizza alive. Reminded me of home. While it is a little pricey, it's definitely a place to try!
Marsha Young
You guys were always so great...WHAT HAPPENED? Last pizza was Dry, short of sauce and pepperoni. I'll miss you.
Mark Mellett
$30 for a 14" pizza w/3 ingredients? I like these guys and always appreciate supporting local business. Is it $10 better than Papa or pick a place? Yeah, but not on my speed dial list. And WHAT pizza place closes at 11 on a Saturday night? Guess it is a hobby for them. Update 11/2021. Apparently changed their sauce. Not a good choice imo. They will be toast when the new road rolls thru anyway. Zero taste now.
Kim Small
Ordered a meat pizza for delivery and got one with mushrooms and olives. All the things a 4 year old won't eat. Called them back and was told by the employee it was his fault but I would still have to wait another hour for my food and they would not compensate anything for it. The manager wouldn't even get on the phone just talking loudly in the background. Great business
Christopher Peters
I don’t care what anyone says firehouse pizza is the best pizza in the state! The pizza is always consistent and always has plenty of toppings. Always go for extra cheese!
Tonya Capps
Absolutely great pizza!!! Delicious!!! Our favorite pizza place... Highly recommend!!!
Jodi
We have ordered for years from Firehouse Pizza. Their deluxe is always extremely delicious. I appreciate that they are open and people have shown up for work. I’d highly recommend their pizza.
Their deluxe pizza is one of my favorite in town. I like the banana peppers. All of the toppings go well together.
Drennan Cannon
After reading the reviews, I decided NOT to try this place. The owner clearly needs to fix these problems, I’m not risking it
Tiffany Watters
Worst pizza I ever had! The sauce tastes like tomato paste, and the mushrooms are definitely from a can. It had no flavor, didn’t have the green pepper I asked for and was charged. You can tell the breadsticks were frozen and the cheese dip was cold. The price was $32 with a coupon. Hardly do I write bad reviews but as a person that hates spending hard earned money on bad food I have to let everyone know. Frozen pizza would taste better and save you $$$
Caron Carter
Crust was like cardboard and without flavor. Wasn't a big fan of the sausage they used either.
Bryan Mitzelfelt
Best pizza in Westfield & Noblesville! Excellent and consistent pizza every time. Highly recommend.
Pizza is pretty good if you scrape off the toppings from the crust and put it on a roof tile!
Always a great meal. I've been going since they opened back around 1990 I think.
Best pizza around. Genious toppings, quality ingredients, fast, and friendly.
Stumbled upon this local pizza shop... Had heard a lot of things about it. I decided to give it a shot. In a small building on the corner it looks very unassuming but it hides a delicious secret. Pizza on Midwestern flop/fold crust with block mozzarella cheese cooked in a stone oven. I had left my card behind and walked outside and the lady who taking my order brought it out with my pizza. Good hearted folks keeping old fashioned pizza alive. Reminded me of home. While it is a little pricey, it's definitely a place to try!
You guys were always so great...WHAT HAPPENED? Last pizza was Dry, short of sauce and pepperoni. I'll miss you.
$30 for a 14" pizza w/3 ingredients? I like these guys and always appreciate supporting local business. Is it $10 better than Papa or pick a place? Yeah, but not on my speed dial list. And WHAT pizza place closes at 11 on a Saturday night? Guess it is a hobby for them. Update 11/2021. Apparently changed their sauce. Not a good choice imo. They will be toast when the new road rolls thru anyway. Zero taste now.
Ordered a meat pizza for delivery and got one with mushrooms and olives. All the things a 4 year old won't eat. Called them back and was told by the employee it was his fault but I would still have to wait another hour for my food and they would not compensate anything for it. The manager wouldn't even get on the phone just talking loudly in the background. Great business
I don’t care what anyone says firehouse pizza is the best pizza in the state! The pizza is always consistent and always has plenty of toppings. Always go for extra cheese!
Absolutely great pizza!!! Delicious!!! Our favorite pizza place... Highly recommend!!!
We have ordered for years from Firehouse Pizza. Their deluxe is always extremely delicious. I appreciate that they are open and people have shown up for work. I’d highly recommend their pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
Their deluxe pizza is one of my favorite in town. I like the banana peppers. All of the toppings go well together.
After reading the reviews, I decided NOT to try this place. The owner clearly needs to fix these problems, I’m not risking it
Worst pizza I ever had! The sauce tastes like tomato paste, and the mushrooms are definitely from a can. It had no flavor, didn’t have the green pepper I asked for and was charged. You can tell the breadsticks were frozen and the cheese dip was cold. The price was $32 with a coupon. Hardly do I write bad reviews but as a person that hates spending hard earned money on bad food I have to let everyone know. Frozen pizza would taste better and save you $$$
Crust was like cardboard and without flavor. Wasn't a big fan of the sausage they used either.
Best pizza in Westfield & Noblesville! Excellent and consistent pizza every time. Highly recommend.