Hot Toddy's

15009 Gray Rd, Noblesville
(317) 701-1810

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jill Sachse

Hot Toddy’s saved me in a pinch when I needed a cake last minute. The carrot cake is amazing! I was so pleasantly surprised by the cute atmosphere and surroundings. I wish I could have tried one of everything! Will be going back for sure!

Barbara George

The Hot Toddy's Pumpkin Bread Was A True Hit!!!!
And All the other Items were gone quickly from the table. Thanks to the Team!

Lori Weaver

Seriously the best find in bakery needs! We purchased a Carrot Cake for Easter, which was the most delicious we've ever tasted! I wish I would have taken a picture before we dove into it because, it was beautifully frosted. I love everything about Hot Toddy's...relaxed and friendly service, fair prices for delicious desserts and in the same building as our two other favorite finds, Broccoli Bills and Slapfish.

LA

Between Thanksgiving and Christmas I have had lots and I mean LOTS of desserts. I am left with this thought and needed to share. Nothing and this is key point. Nothing I have tasted compares to the taste and quality of the cakes, cookies, and pies from Hot Toddy’s. The Mexican wedding cookies are the most delicious I’ve ever tasted. The key lime pie. Incredible. The apple pie. Scrumptious. The coconut cream made me gasp it was so good. The homemade cinnamon rolls. Decadently delicious. I am actually so grateful, as a person who can’t bake, that there is an option to bring homemade fresh baked and perfectly executed desserts into my home to share with others (and enjoy myself) throughout the year. Thank you Todd!

Taryn Gross

Got my 18th birthday cake from this place and was absolutely blown away, got a gluten free red velvet and it was delicious, couldn’t even tell it was gluten free, super moist!!

Jeff Woloshin

They are amazing.

Kaitlyn Caruso

Had the pleasure of meeting one of the owners today. I was debating between two cookie flavors and he helped me decide on the ginger molasses. Holy cow, they were incredible! Soft and the perfect about of ginger. I'm be back to get more and try the other flavors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Higginbotham

Delicious cinnamon rolls! And the lemon doodle and oatmeal butterscotch cookies were also delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erika Eskridge

I was in the are and wanted a regular cookie not like crumbl . I got a lemon doodle, candy cool and a cinnamon roll and it was so good and simple!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zach Tannehill

The cinnamon rolls are better than anywhere I've ever eaten.

Ms Pow

Delicious muffins

David Mueller

Hot Toddy’s is great. The cinnamon rolls are excellent. This is a go to spot for chocolate chip cookies. Highly recommended.

Julia Irwin Wadsworth

Amazing baked goods! Made with real butter, no nasty oils. The gluten free brownies are to die for!!!

Jon Tiede

Their cinnamon rolls are amazing!

Meg Bradley

The BEST peanut butter cupcakes EVER!!!

Loading...