Over the Top Bakery Cafe

Had their potsticker salad special and it was fabulous! Takes a while but it is made to order

Delicious doughnuts and apple fritters. Reasonably priced and friendly service. Worth a stop if passing through North Liberty, IN or worth the trip itself.

I own The Cornerstone at Cedar wedding venue in Bourbon, Indiana. We enjoy cupcakes every weekend from different bakeries, but these are definitely some of the best cupcakes. They are moist, and the frosting is perfect . Job well done!

Great small town bakery/cafe! We got donuts and an apple fritter. All were delicious. Great atmosphere as well. We will be back.

This bakery has THE BEST plain cheesecake, topped with strawberries, I’ve ever had! I ordered the cheesecake because it’s my nephew’s favorite and we were celebrating his birthday. Everyone thought it was so light and creamy and it was topped with enough strawberries for every bite. It didn’t last long! The only downside is they don’t sell individual slices, as of this review, because I know others who would like to try it vs having to order an entire cake. I’ll be ordering my cheesecakes from here going forward.

Donuts and cupcakes are good and prices are decent, but when we got three breakfast sandwiches the bacon was burned black on two and the sausage was burned as well. Wasn't going to write this, but after talking to some young lady behind the counter today I decided to make a review, for her no care attitude. We did like the place and would have continued to frequent the place but no longer--thanks for the no care attitude!

She made a cake for my son’s first birthday half banana half strawberry it was amazing everyone loved it! 10/10!

My daughter ordered her wedding shower cupcakes and wedding cake from Over the Top bakery and both were amazing!! The hummingbird cake was hands down the best cake I’ve ever had and the cake was decorated beautifully! Thank you so much for excellent quality and service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

After finding nothing but fast food in nearby Walkerton, we continued on to North Liberty to try this bakery and it's an absolute gem. Great country cooking, excellent breakfast, yummy treats, and attentive service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place hands down has the best donuts you’ll ever have. A little expensive and the sitting are is small, but I still come here when in the area!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love this place ! It's always a wonderful experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The most perfect small-town bakery/cafe. Super friendly, hard-working, and amazing food. Wish they served the tea by the gallon. They have a variety of donuts, pies, breads, and café-style breakfast and lunch items. All amazing! And the price is definitely lower than anyone I've found near the South Bend area. Try it once, and you'll be back again and again.

Dietary restrictions: They have a fridge with items for people with dietary restrictions, including gluten-free.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Doughnut, Wedding Cake, Sheet Cake, Wrap, Apple Fritter

The most perfect small-town bakery/cafe. Super friendly, hard-working, and amazing food. Wish they served the tea by the gallon.

Love this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So I was born and raised in North Liberty util the sixth grade and then we moved away. I recently moved back to this nice little town last fall. I had totally forgotten about this little bakery until one of my friends told me how great there donuts were.
I have to be honest, I thought for sure that being in a small town that they would be very pricy. ?‍♂️?‍♂️
I went is this morning and got two very big donuts and was presently surprise that it was only $3.
The place was clean and very well decorated. The two ladies behind the counter were very friendly and met me with a smile.
When I got to my truck and took that first bite I was in heaven because they were still warm inside and probably the best donuts I have ever eaten.
Of course I can't speak for anything else that they make there (Not yet anyways) but I can tell you that I am glad that I gave them a chance because they just earned a life long customer and I will tell everyone I know about this little hidden gem!

Keep up the good work! ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnut