Pizza was ok. Its brick oven pizza and it looks like it. Smaller servings for more prices. Not alot of places to sit down. Marinara and ranch were very bland. I'm someone who can eat just about anything and I couldn't finish the leftovers. It was $37 for a personal pizza, cheesesticks and a drink. Not worth the price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Abe Pagota
As other reviewers have said, it's gone downhill. We loved the place when it first opened. The last two visits, both times they've brought out the pizza before the breadsticks. Then act surprised when you ask where the breadsticks are when you show them the receipt. When they finally bring them 10-15 minutes later, we're pretty well done eating our pizza and the breadsticks are burned on the outside and still partially uncooked/doughy on the inside. This is not during a busy time like Saturday night either. so not sure what the excuse is but after it's happened two visits in a row, we don't plan to come back. I can tell you it's never happened at Mother Bear's in Bloomington where they're literally one hundred times busier.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Johnathon Heyder
This place has really went downhill over the past 6 months. We used to eat here all the time because, despite the high price, the food was definitely worth it. Lately, however, it's only marginally better than your major discount pizza chains. the last 3 times I've gotten pizza here it has been missing an ingredient...and even when it's not missing, it's barely any...one time, no chorizo, one time no bacon, and most recently, there was 1 little piece of chicken and a few crumbles of chorizo on an entire pizza. Extremely disappointing. we won't be going back to pay premium prices for subpar pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Johnathon Heyder
This place has really went downhill over the past 6 months. We used to eat here all the time because, despite the high price, the food was definitely worth it. Lately, however, it's only marginally better than your major discount pizza chains. the last 3 times I've gotten pizza here it has been missing an ingredient...and even when it's not missing, it's barely any...one time, no chorizo, one time no bacon, and most recently, there was 1 little piece of chicken and a few crumbles of chorizo on an entire pizza. Extremely disappointing. we won't be going back to pay premium prices for subpar pizza
Cheryl Sanders
Very unhappy we call all the time no one will ever answer the phone so we can order a pizza bad business
Service: 1
Jeremy Penrod
My wife and I ate there and it was the best pizza we have had in a long time. We drove 69 miles just to eat there and it was GREAT! It is definitely a 10 out of 10. Great food, great service and great atmosphere. The owner was very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Freddy Sturgeon
The atmosphere, the staff, the food and OMG, the frozen cider. A WONDERFUL place to stop. We met up with some friends from Mitchell and I asked them to take me there as I had tried a sip of the frozen cider. I am not a drinker by any means, but oh, Heaven on earth it was DELICIOUS! Definitely gonna be back again when I have a driver!!!!! 5+ 🌟
Martha McBride
Need this great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Breadsticks
Sarah Stube
Best pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Parrott
Excellent pizza! The spicy red sauce is very good. I will definitely return and I recommend it highly.
This is the best pizza I’ve had yet! Fresh dough, great ingredients and wood fired! Cozy place but don’t be afraid to wait and grab a beer. You will not be disappointed. Try the garlic dipping sauce for your pizza crusts 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Abram
Hands down best pizza I’ve found. I’m in love with this place. So much as to where I compare every other pizza place to it. They’ve set the bar. I live in Bloomington a make the drive as often as I can to Orleans, just to indulge on these masterpieces. It’s wood fire, Neapolitan style. Delicious. So much to the point to where I no longer even like pizza elsewhere. Catch 22. The wife always does GF. She likes it as well. They’re only a few days a week. But hey, if you’re good, you can do that. At first I wasn’t a fan of the beer cheese, versus traditional nacho cheese. It grows on you though. The staff is over the top friendly. Little wait times. This place is a must.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Patricia New
We had pizza and bread sticks. Excellent!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Breadsticks with Cheese
Emilie Fleetwood-Miller
If I could give this more stars I absolutely would. The atmosphere is so unique and fun! All the pizzas have sun names that match the theme. A create your own section if you don't see something you love. We did a Baby Face Nelson and the cheese blend was ON POINT. I think with a lot of multi cheese pizzas, you end up with a heavy cheese flavor that can be to much. This one had a seasoning blend that matched the cheese so it was a great mix. Its still heavy cheese, but the flavor was perfection. I wish I had grabbed more pictures. Perfect local spot to support!
They have a changing table, so definitely family friendly. AND there's a great little park with play structures right across the street.
Pizza was ok. Its brick oven pizza and it looks like it. Smaller servings for more prices. Not alot of places to sit down. Marinara and ranch were very bland. I'm someone who can eat just about anything and I couldn't finish the leftovers. It was $37 for a personal pizza, cheesesticks and a drink. Not worth the price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
As other reviewers have said, it's gone downhill. We loved the place when it first opened. The last two visits, both times they've brought out the pizza before the breadsticks. Then act surprised when you ask where the breadsticks are when you show them the receipt. When they finally bring them 10-15 minutes later, we're pretty well done eating our pizza and the breadsticks are burned on the outside and still partially uncooked/doughy on the inside. This is not during a busy time like Saturday night either. so not sure what the excuse is but after it's happened two visits in a row, we don't plan to come back. I can tell you it's never happened at Mother Bear's in Bloomington where they're literally one hundred times busier.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place has really went downhill over the past 6 months. We used to eat here all the time because, despite the high price, the food was definitely worth it. Lately, however, it's only marginally better than your major discount pizza chains. the last 3 times I've gotten pizza here it has been missing an ingredient...and even when it's not missing, it's barely any...one time, no chorizo, one time no bacon, and most recently, there was 1 little piece of chicken and a few crumbles of chorizo on an entire pizza. Extremely disappointing. we won't be going back to pay premium prices for subpar pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
This place has really went downhill over the past 6 months. We used to eat here all the time because, despite the high price, the food was definitely worth it. Lately, however, it's only marginally better than your major discount pizza chains. the last 3 times I've gotten pizza here it has been missing an ingredient...and even when it's not missing, it's barely any...one time, no chorizo, one time no bacon, and most recently, there was 1 little piece of chicken and a few crumbles of chorizo on an entire pizza. Extremely disappointing. we won't be going back to pay premium prices for subpar pizza
Very unhappy we call all the time no one will ever answer the phone so we can order a pizza bad business
Service: 1
My wife and I ate there and it was the best pizza we have had in a long time. We drove 69 miles just to eat there and it was GREAT! It is definitely a 10 out of 10. Great food, great service and great atmosphere. The owner was very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The atmosphere, the staff, the food and OMG, the frozen cider. A WONDERFUL place to stop. We met up with some friends from Mitchell and I asked them to take me there as I had tried a sip of the frozen cider. I am not a drinker by any means, but oh, Heaven on earth it was DELICIOUS! Definitely gonna be back again when I have a driver!!!!! 5+ 🌟
Need this great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Breadsticks
Best pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza! The spicy red sauce is very good. I will definitely return and I recommend it highly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the best pizza I’ve had yet! Fresh dough, great ingredients and wood fired! Cozy place but don’t be afraid to wait and grab a beer. You will not be disappointed. Try the garlic dipping sauce for your pizza crusts 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down best pizza I’ve found. I’m in love with this place. So much as to where I compare every other pizza place to it. They’ve set the bar. I live in Bloomington a make the drive as often as I can to Orleans, just to indulge on these masterpieces. It’s wood fire, Neapolitan style. Delicious. So much to the point to where I no longer even like pizza elsewhere. Catch 22.
The wife always does GF. She likes it as well. They’re only a few days a week. But hey, if you’re good, you can do that. At first I wasn’t a fan of the beer cheese, versus traditional nacho cheese. It grows on you though. The staff is over the top friendly. Little wait times. This place is a must.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
We had pizza and bread sticks. Excellent!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Breadsticks with Cheese
If I could give this more stars I absolutely would. The atmosphere is so unique and fun! All the pizzas have sun names that match the theme. A create your own section if you don't see something you love. We did a Baby Face Nelson and the cheese blend was ON POINT. I think with a lot of multi cheese pizzas, you end up with a heavy cheese flavor that can be to much. This one had a seasoning blend that matched the cheese so it was a great mix. Its still heavy cheese, but the flavor was perfection. I wish I had grabbed more pictures. Perfect local spot to support!
They have a changing table, so definitely family friendly. AND there's a great little park with play structures right across the street.
Loading...