The American Pizza Kitchen

107 SE 3rd St, Paoli
(812) 788-0765

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jacob Royer

When this first opened it was awesome ! About a year in I ordered a pizza and it was greasy slop so I gave them another chance and tried the buffet out and it was only ok the food wasn’t very fresh and the pizza was only ok I thought “maybe I just picked a bad day” so a few weeks ago I tried the buffet again and it was so greasy it was barely edible ! Again I thought maybe it was a bad day.. my wife tried the breakfast buffet yesterday and the biscuits were so dry they were inedible . I loved this place when it opened and gave them the benefit of the doubt but I will not be spending anymore money here ! Pizza Hut sucks in paoli but at this point has way better food and I hate to see this ! You all had be opportunity to do better and it’s not happening !

Julie P.

We've been here a couple times now and the food is consistent and good. We've had the lunch buffet and just pizza. Both are great.....LOVE the bread sticks. You have dipping sauce options, I get the garlic butter. I'd happily go here just for the bread sticks. The buffet is great and you can't beat the price, which includes your beverage, especially if you eat a lot. We still have to try the breakfast buffet, which we've heard great things about. It's a small place but we had no issue finding a place to sit and it's very clean. Every employee we've encountered has been very friendly. We will definitely be back.

Phillip Babcock Jr

The pizza is awesome, and the breakfast buffet is one of the best around

Renetta Hagler

So tasty! Full menu.

Nacole Swenson

Pizza and bread stixz... awesome special on Friday and Saturday. Free stixz when you buy a pizza. The meatsa pizza was delicious and the stixz were like garlic knots soooo good... great stop before the concatenate castle knoll amphitheater. Awesome workers spitting out pizzas left n right. Be patient if it's on the weekend they might be busy.

Kari Brown

100% best pizza and service around!

Raven

Ordered here for the first time…. It all tasted soo good! And my meal came with free breadsticks??? Heck yeah. Will be coming here regularly. 5/5

Vicki Powell

Buffet was good

Kevin M. Lloyd

The food is incredibly fresh and made to order. The salad bar is incredible and the pizzas are out of this world. Robin made one of the best pizzas we have had in a long time. The bread sticks are incredible as well

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler Tuell

I would be lying if I said this was not 100% the best pizza I have ever had in my life. I ordered a neat lovers it was extremely cheap. The cheese pull was amazing the meat
S all tasted freshly made to my order and the crust was buttery and pa ked with so much flavor! I will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeanice Satterfield

Very good pizza and bread sticks, friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Autumn Rae

The baked spaghetti is delicious. The meatballs are too! Yummy fresh salad and the staff is very friendly. I'm glad to see this in our little town of Paoli!

Carl Fuller

Really good food, cute girls ,good prices gluten free pizza option ,and a buffet bar . What more is there in a small town pizza joint ...5 stars parking could be better but over all great place to eat

Vegetarian options: Gluten free pizza big bonus as my wife is Gluten free

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Custom Lasagna Bowl, Stromboli, Cheesy Cheese Lasagna, Pepperoni Pizza

Kry Baby Katie

Wow! What a surprise this little place is. Everything was delicious. Our group included a 4 yr old, 13 yr old ,36 yr old abs 65 yr old. Pizza outstanding. Ravioli bowl best ever. Meatball appetizer wond er ful. Owner was so sweet and over the top hostess. Will worth the so abs we will return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victoria Glass

I got a order of breadticks and a ravioli bowl! The ravioli was delicious and the breadsticks were so soft and cooked perfectly!

Loading...

The American Pizza Kitchen

107 SE 3rd St, Paoli, IN 47454
(812) 788-0765