Catello’s Italian Art Cuisine

Over all it was a good dinner. Party of 8. We seemed to sit there for a while before a server came to us. Most if not all of the men would have preferred beer but a couple of us did get wine. We all enjoyed the night.

Great food. Loved the Bruschetta appetizer. We had 4 different main courses which were all great.

Beautiful quaint restaurant. The meals we had were all wonderful! I will definitely go back as this is authentic Italian. We had the Cheese Wheel and it was so much food. It was a super cool experience! Thank you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

True Italian restaurant
Delicious Italian special dishes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood, Salmone \u0026 Verdure

If you want true authentic Italian food. This is your place. The quaint town of Pendleton does it again with this hidden gem. After your meal. Pop in back to the Gelatp that is made fresh in the restaurant by Cattelo. The Deli in back also carries his homemade sauces, bread and pasta. If you have not been. Put it on your list.

No notes! Hands down best Italian food I’ve had in the states. And on top of that, it’s very well priced.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

From the warm welcome to the friendly good byes, this was an enjoyable dining experience. The service was top notch and the food brought back find memories of my time in Italy. This was my first visit to the restaurant, but I am a frequent patron of the INItaly Pizzeria & Bar. The addition of live music, makes the whole experience even more enjoyable. I will be back again. The drive from east Indianapolis is so worth it, dining with good people, eating wonderfully prepared food, and relaxing, knowing you are being taken care of.

I made a reservation to celebrate our anniversary on a Saturday at 7:30pm we select the wheel cheese experience. We passed from “it will take couple minutes to be sit” to 30 minutes wait no matter if i made the reservation almost a week before the day. The next excuse was that they were making sure the table we get is ok to do the experience. The truth was the restaurant was overbooked and we were sit on the first table right in front of the entrance and all the wind from every time someone open the door hit me (now I'm sick thanks!). While we wait we have not offered any drink to at least keep us entertained, once we sit it took about 10 minutes to have someone to serve us water and bread without having a chance to order a drink. Once the server went to our table just went to take an order (no recommendations just an order taker). We ordered our appetizer and wine was really good. When we finished our appetizer is when the server went to take the details of the entree (the wheel cheese experience) we added an 8oz filet mignon and the server asked how much we want this cooked and we said medium and it was well done, the pasta was overcooked and the cheese wasn't enough melted with the pasta, either my husband or myself couldn't finish the plate and order to put togo to just trash that next day was impossible to eat. Last but not less important we order dessert (the only thing that the server offered during the entire time we spent there) the tiramisu was really good and the cannoli just good. I feel very disappointed, i took us almost 40 minutes drive to get there and we were excited to eat in a authentic italian restaurant and it was a fail!

We were celebrating our anniversary. Everything was at a very slow pace to get any kind of service! The food was just okay for the price. Its ridiculous to have to pay for extra bread when you are paying so much for the food! We asked if they do anything extra for Anniversary celebration. We were told they give you a candle??? I the waitress ended up giving up a scoop of chocolate gelato.

Food was simply excellent. Wine excellent and good value. Would have like more choice with cocktails.

Phenomenal experience.. Absolutely loved it.. pricey for the location.. but still I would go again.. very personalized service and catered as requested.. amazing service .. gr8 live music.. and over all gr8 experience...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mushroom Ravioli, Desserts, Salads, Chocolate Mousse Cake, Gelato

This restaurant gets great reviews but I've been twice and both times felt it was lacking. The ambience is great and with music added, that makes it better. However, the food is not great. The menu is very limited. I ordered the filet with fettuccine noodles. The filet was well done and cut into pieces and tossed into the fettuccine noodles that were swimming in olive oil. We ordered the burrata cheese appetizer and when it arrived, I asked if it came with bread or crackers. We were told it was an upcharge. Of course we ordered it. Just seems strange cheese comes with nothing. We were interested in lasagna. Apparently you can only get that at lunch. The gelato was great.

We had a lovely experience with piano music to accompany our meal. Our starters were so well plated and the calamari was the best we have ever had. Dinner was risotto and raviolis. Everything was perfection. For dessert everyone had tiramisu and coffee once again everything was perfect.

We thoroughly enjoyed out first visit, to celebrate a birthday. Upon our arrival we were cordially greeted and promptly seated. The waitstaff were both prompt and attentive. Our respective Caesar and Caprese salads were fresh and perfectly dressed. My. husband's Genovese entree was uniquely savory and comforting; my Ravioli Funghi couldn't have been more decadent and flavorful! We topped our meals with creamy Tiramisu and Chocolate Lava Cake with Coconut Gelato. We found our experience to be an excellent value and can't wait to come back!

Been trying to try this place for several years. Definitely lived up to the reputation and reviews I've read.