No. 423 Smokehouse

804 E Illinois St, Petersburg
(812) 354-2277

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sam S

Maybe we caught them on a bad day, but we were disappointed with the food. Mozzarella sticks were cold in the middle, mac n cheese was dry and tasteless. The main dishes (brisket and loaded potato) were good, but didn’t really stand out. However, I will say the service was excellent. No wait, friendly and very attentive.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Michelle Wade

We ordered off of the menu that was available on their Google page. When do we went to pick it up it was double the price. We paid it and and then call the talk to the manager to make him aware of the price difference because it was so large. Instead of trying to make something a little right, all he did was make excuses. The food there is always good. But It is not right to get blindsided with the price when you get there. It was a drastic difference. Also The manager passed us along to the owner. The owner was the one that made excuses instead of making it right. The manager was Super nice <3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Marie M

It's ok. Food was nothing special for BBQ but was unique with stromboli and a Reuben sandwich. Mac n cheese was just congealed and cold. Fish was lightly breaded and not greasy. The staff was pleasant but there were at least 6 of them and each one helped us at one point weirdly. For having only two tables occupied they would each come over but never cleared our appetizer plates or asked us if we needed a refill. And it took a long time for no one being in the restaurant or having so much payroll on staff just standing around.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Queen Au' king

The food was cold except for the fish. I'll probably go back one more time to see if it was a bad day for them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Wayne Myers

We stopped in and got their rib dinners to go. Service was great and fast! If you haven’t had their ribs, you’re missing out…:-)

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dante Hays

brisket was a 5 but my momma didn't like her food so 4

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Shanna

New ownership, but same great quality! We came in with just 30 mins to close. Asked if that was ok before we sat and noone acted annoyed and staff was great!

James Schulze

It located in a descent area. I ordered BBQ straws. The melted cheese on top needs to stay hot. I ordered a combo dinner with brisket and pulled pork. They were out of white meat chicken. I also got a creamy coleslaw and baked beans. I also ordered jalepeno popper bites. They have a nice slow burn. Would be great in the winter to warm the internals. The creamy coleslaw was very tasty. The baked beans were very plain. Add, bbq, some mustard, and a little bit of bacon to elevate the beans. The BBQ straw were different. Similar to the idea of loaded fries. The brisket was moist and had some really great seasoning. Not fatty and not lean. The pulled pork was cooked well and I got the BBQ sauce on the side. The sauce was not heavily vinegar base with a hint of hickory. The sauce was light and not heavy or thick.

Paul Felix

Stop scrolling. This is the place. If you come here get the ribs! Ribs! If you normally eat a full slab, only order a half slab here. A full slab will tilt the table down and it’s loaded with meat (not fat). Baked potato was tasty with a smoky taste. I hope to stop here again. Remember to congratulate the new owner on doing BBQ right.

Mr_Mike_Pancake

All around great place to eat, great food, great service. They were pretty busy and still got to us in a pretty fast manner and we had our food just as quick. 5 stars would recommend

Tenna Newby Nicely

We tried #423 SmokeHouse for the first time tonight. Our server Matt and the rest of the staff were very friendly and made sure our visit was a great one. My husband and I both had Stromboli sandwiches, the Italian and a regular, they had more meat than we have had at any restaurant in YEARS! They were fresh from the grill and yummy. We will definitely be back to try some other options!

Teresa Seitz

Great place to eat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Barry Wright

Sunday lunch. They were pretty busy, but we got a table right away. The staff was very friendly. Our appetizer came out quick. We never had an empty glass. I ordered a half rack of ribs and they were absolutely delicious! Huge portion! Fall off the bone tender and juicy. Good smoke flavor and the barbecue sauce was really good as well. Creamy cold, slaw and grilled vegetables Were a nice accompaniment. I also tried the pulled pork and it was delicious. Lots of different choices on the menu. Very clean. I will most definitely go back and eat here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ribs

Shannon Wells

Very good brisket. My super picky grandson liked the pizza and Kayla was the perfect server.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Autumn Murphy

We drive from Lynnville to eat here because the food is so delicious even my picky 9 year old loves the food. The staff are friendly and very attentive. The prices are very reasonable also. I highly recommend!

Loading...