Pizza Stop & Subs

301 N First St, Pierceton
(574) 594-3535

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Blake Burman

Called to order subs and a pizza. She answers and says I’m not doing subs….click.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Doris Bush

Tried to call in an order but the gal was super rude and

Service: 1

Admin Office

Horrible customer service and the food is just as bad!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rocky Holcomb II

Stopped in to try and get a pizza and the Older lady said, sorry I'm too busy to help you. Unbelievable.. I will never stop here again. She seemed mad that we even stopped in.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

stone Rager

I consulted the menu I found online and decided to order 3 medium pizzas. The first one she takes down with no issue, and then I made the fateful error. The menu I saw online had Hawaiian and taco pizzas listed, but when I asked for them she HUFFED and said “Now you listen here! I haven’t done taco pizza in 10 years and I will NOT do Hawaiian!” *CLICK*I just stood there for a while, confused. I would have had no problem ordering something else if she had given me the chance ??‍♂️ I’ve tried to call several times since I moved here 6 months ago, and I guess now I know it just isn’t meant to be!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Stacy Snyder

She is a horrible human being. She don’t answer the phone when she is open and if she does she hangs up on you. Her food is good but her attitude makes me dislike everything about her and the Pizza Nazi…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ey_Mj_

Very Nice pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Renee Hawes

I heard good things about this place and I'm always willing to try a new pizza place. I heard many times that the owner is rude so I knew what to expect. She really is and the pizza was okay. Better off going to Burbon St pizza in North Webster. But she did thank me for my business and told me to have a good one.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Kenny Koneval

Great hometown pizza . Loved it .crispy thin crust, ample toppings , tasty blend of cheese.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jasmine Anderson

I’ve really been wanting to try this place, but she is just not open when she says she is. Even today (a Thursday) I called three times between 8-8:15pm, no answer. I went there physically to order in case her phone was messed up (I only live a couple blocks away), and she was walking out of the building at 8:20pm (40 minutes before she was supposed to close). Which means that she also purposefully ignored my 3 phone calls. Really disappointed and honestly tired of trying to eat here. I wanted to give it a shot since it’s local and I’ve heard the pizza is good, but it’s just not worth trying anymore.*edited to add that at the time of this review, both her google page and voicemail state that she is open from 4pm-9pm on Thursdays, taking orders until 8:30 pm, yet she was ignoring me and gone between 8-8:30pm.

NaturalCureQuest

Seriously, some of the best pizza I've ever had. Owner was all business but she was nice. I would definitely go back!

L Stanley

We were in from out of town and hoping to eat at the Train Depot and because it was closed we came here to find that it’s only take- out with no public restrooms or seating. We asked the lady working there for suggestions of a local sit down restaurant and she was quite unfriendly!

Denise Martin

Owner is extremely rude! Hung up on me while I was giving my order. I wanted the BLT pizza she informs me they aren't making those and ask if I want to cancel my order( I had already ordered the deluxe) I said no and that's when I heard "click". I tried calling back 4 times and she wouldn't pick up the phone. I will never order from there again! You better get some manners hunny!!!

Phyllis F

I wish I could rate this place a zero because we didn't eat any food from here. The place was empty. I was studying the menu to decide what I wanted and that nasty woman asked me to remove my mask among other snarly mean comments. I noticed she wasn't wearing a mask, so that was that. I was out the door fast. She should close up shop and get a job at Dick's Last Resort where meanness is expected, although they do it in a light-hearted way. Maybe the food is good. I don't know. She ruined my appetite with her mean spirited disposition.

Nadia Garcia

SO RUDE.

Loading...