Papa Johns Pizza

1625 N Michigan St, Plymouth
(574) 936-6500

Recent Reviews

Crystal Weaver

Apathy opened lately put something because they were not prepared to open and accept orders, currently ringing 20-25 minutes behind and then had to remake part of the

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Mark Ellis

I wouldnt know how the food is. Their call center took my order and said we could pick up in 10 minutes then the store called me and said they were already closed. No pizza for me today i guess...

Service: 1

Edna Morton

Delicious, hot pizza & garlic knots!! Friendly service! This location has never disappointed us.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Gina S.

The calzone bites were made, sloppy they weren't rolled up. The stuff fell out of them every time I picked them up, Didn't use gloves, I will tell you that the Oreo bites were good and they were nice and eat so that is a plus, woman was on the phone only one dude cooking training needs to be more helpful with helping to roll the calzones

Dying Meadow

Closes an hour early, then takes three days to get a refund.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

jody Thornton-Wolfe

Employees were very nice & delivery on time with hot food upon arrival.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Audrey Baker-Robinson

All I can say is what amazing staff. My husband has been sitting in the parking lot of papa John's for almost 2 hours waiting on a tow truck. Out of no where a young gentleman walked up to my husband with a fresh hot pizza on the house the kid hoped my husband's day gets a little better.That young man brought tears to my eyes, for having such a big heart.Thank you to all the kind staff that made the decision to help brighten my husband's day and to make sure he ate dinner.You are all so very kind, Bless each and everyone of you that worked at 6:30 pm on September 13th.Pizza is delicious ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary Ann Raderstorf

Pizza's r never consistentChocolate brownies were dried out completely. Over cookedBut will be going back and give this Papa Johns another try.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Pizza

Becka Snyder

I wish they would have given me all my sauces I paid extra for!!! I did not receive any and I paid for quite a few extras. Very dissatisfied

Julie and Melvin Snyder

Doesn't have a very big lobby,but food service and quality make up for it. Never get tired if papa John's. Pizza is always hood,but the papadias rock.

Julie Snyder

Doesn't have a very big lobby,but food service and quality make up for it. Never get tired if papa John's. Pizza is always hood,but the papadias rock.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Sandra Kemp

The pepperoni parmesan pizza is really good!

Jolene Harwood

Let me start off by saying the manager that works at this location is the worst I have ever worked with at a pizza location. She is rude, loud, disrespectful and lies. This franchise location is dirty, and gross everywhere you look. She treats her employees like trash. She needs to be addressed and let for the sake of this location. She thinks she can speak to customers any way she wants because of her title. I would enjoy speaking and address my concerns with her outside of papa johns.

David Dady

Ordered for delivery, 7 items, waited an hour before the food showed up, then it was only 3 boxes out of 7 that came. Called store and complained, was told by the manager that they would remake the whole order and send it again, waited an hour again(so up at 2 hours now and have hungry kids) after an hour food shows up but instead of it being the whole order as the manager said, it was just the items they had forgotten, no refunds, no discounts, no coupons, just wait forever for food. Won’t be ordering from them again anytime soon, we used to order almost every other week but not anymore. Zero stars!

Luke Hoffman

Ordered two pizzas only after confirming they were still delivering and the pizzas never showed up. BUT my credit card was charged.

Load More