Islamorada Fish Company

This restaurant has a relaxed vibe inside and provides a pleasant dining experience with wonderful staff. The food is good but they don’t offer anything particularly special.

Thank you dberryman41 for your excellent 5-star review. How incredibly flattering of you to mention our fresh seafood and beautiful atmosphere. We strive to keep great customers like you coming back again. Thanks!! Sincerely, Guest Relations

I remember the great service and quality from the beginning days of the portage location. Since the recent years, I feel though the quality and service does not meet the expectation of the price you pay. Granted as I was part of a large party, the restaurant didn’t offer any support to the waitress we had (who did a good job with no help from Managment). Very little was done to meet the customers need. I will unfortunately not be back.

My first time to Islamorada. I got a burger, very dry, burned, over cooked. The other person that got a burger didn’t like theirs as well. Brisket Mac and cheese had very little brisket, and also not good. Beard hair in two other dishes. Fish and chips were greasy. Islamorada portfino was bland. Majority of the group didn’t like their meals. One server for 24 people, poor girl. Will not be returning.

Fun time. Ate with one of the servers, since they were off today. Food was good too

Islamorada is located within the Bass Pro Shop location just off of I-94 in Portage IN. The ambiance is casual. The staff is friendly. We ordered the special of the day, which was all you could eat shrimp at a reasonable price. We also ordered the steak sandwich. The bread that is served upon arrival is tasty and warm. There was cross training happening the day of our visit so our food arrived late. The server and the manager apologized and adjusted our bill. Both dishes were delicious.

Always a great place to stop! For business meetings or just for some great food! Thank you for yet another 5 star experience!!

Thanks for the feedback and for stopping in to visit., It was a pleasure to serve you, Noisy41. Your feedback is helpful to us. We appreciate you, and hope you will come back soon! Thank you!

Service was fast and accurate. The burgers and fish were good. The beer was cold but, the crab cakes were not up to my standards.

The Alligator, the burgers and the shrimp alfredo was really good! Fried pickles not so much. The seasoning was really good on them but they were sliced really thin & because of that, they were greasy & u could taste more batter than pickles. If they were spears, they would be perfect!

The Red fish is amazing. We keep going back for it. Their drinks are not so great so beer is a safer choice.

Customer Service was Horrible. No Greetings from Hostess, No Eye Contact from Waitress, we felt as if we were a bother to even be eating here.

It's not good for business to keep people waiting when you have inner ten tables visibly open and not seated. Staff your restaurant accordingly, it's a Saturday for goodness sake!

Thank you, 857kathyp, for posting a review. We are sorry that your experience was not of the quality you expected and deserve. We will share this feedback with the kitchen staff and use it to fix, educate and improve. We thank you for your business.

It was good. Our server, May, was great! We come here occasionally and usually the food and service is good. We love sitting in the fish tank room! My only complaint is I think it's a little overpriced.