Fenwick's
219 W Washington St, Rensselaer
(219) 866-3773
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Our server was excellent and a good conversationalist-she gave good advice about what to do and see, and described how painful the loss of St. Joseph's was for the students and town. My double pork burger, Alicia's mac & cheese with pulled pork (yes, we were Hoosier porkers) and a generous side of tater tots, and an incredible apple-caramel crumble with ice cream, made a delicious lunch and dinner in take-home boxes.
My family and I attempted to try this place out a few months ago. We went around lunch time and were seated right away with menus. We waited 15 minutes for someone to come and grab our drink order and now food orders. The lady who sat us was sitting and chit chatting with other customers. They were NOT busy as all. The customers who the hostess/waitress were talking to and one other family that was seated outside. After waiting 15 minutes we left. It’s sad that when a business that is not even busy during that time, can’t even keep customers.
Friendly informed service. Solid portions and prices. Good flavors. Fries have the delicious extra coating to make them extra crunchy.
FYI, this is only a Taproom, it is no longer a brewery. However, great beers and cocktails on tap!!!
Great food
Super awesome wait staff! Spot on recommendations, and the food was great! Fish and chips were huge and the Brussels were the best I've ever had, including my wife's! Hopefully she won't see this review! But don't hesitate, get down to fenwicks, do it now, get to the choppa!
We we're in town for our son's 4th
birthday party, and he wanted something good to eat for his birthday. My husband found this neat
restaurant on Yelp, and we all absolutely loved it. everything was
great from the food all the way down to the customer service. Our server was awesome. I forgot her name, but she is a manager/ waiter 👌🏾👌🏾👌🏾
Stayed in the area and this was recommended by the hotel staff. Had the smokehouse sampler. Mac and cheese and mashed potatoes, pretty much everything was good and reasonably priced. Wife and I couldn't finish everything. Stay away from the beef tips, those are not good. They should change the recipe. Try the Puma drink, it's amazing! They should bottle it up and sell it like their bourbons and others.
We had the absolute pleasure of being served by Leah, who is not just a waitress but a superstar in disguise! From the moment we sat down, she graced us with her humor and charm, making our dining experience unforgettable. Leah's exceptional service was the highlight of our visit. She anticipated our needs before we even knew we had them and delivered everything with a smile. Leah, you're a rad human and a true gem! Can't wait to come back and be entertained by you again!
Terrible service! Moved from inside to outside just to get a beer. The food took longer than we normally wait on food. Food was good!
Great drinks, had the ribeye, and was cooked perfect.
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent brisket, bourbon, and service.
Great food and service.
The brews are great! Food is great!The staff is great! If you haven't had the garlic parm fries, you're missing our, and you're a loser. 🤣 Seriously, drop in and have a Will You Be My Neighbor. You won't regret it.
Have had several times before and never disappointed but went again yesterday for lunch. I got the jalapeño popper burger with the garlic parm fries. It’s been awhile since I’ve been that impressed. Please never take off menu, I will forsure be back!!! 10/10
Wonderful atmosphere and food. If possible, I'd give them a 4.9 only because I'd love to see their menu expand a bit, but I bet you'll love whatever you order there!
Loading...