Fenwick's

219 W Washington St, Rensselaer
(219) 866-3773

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Scott kyger

Great food! Philly burger was awesome. Great service. An hour away from home but we will be back. Nice outdoor seating and easy parking.

David

Julie is the absolute worst waitress I've ever encountered. We waited over an hour and 20min for food, people that had a different waitress that sat down 10-30min later than us got their food 20min before we did and we were only 4 people. One lady saw we had been waiting forever and gave us 5 dollar off coupons, when we finally went to pay the lady didnt add the coupons that we handed her on either of our bills and i got charged for a lemonade that i never had, i had water. Didnt notice until after we left because i just wanted to get out of there. Holy crap she does not belong in the industry, she'd do well at a bmv or somewhere its okay to be incredibly slow and terrible at your job.

riley fleming

This place is horrible. Waited an hour and a half for our food. We didn't get the food until we complained to someone else. We were then given a $5 coupon to use. When we paid for our food we gave our waitress the coupon and she never put it on our bill.

Steven Schram

Outstanding customer service from Alexis and the entire staff

Shawn Williams

We met the chef who share all about the gazpacho. The queso was wonderful with the pretzels. The burgers were hot and large (1/3rd pound). Our waitress was super busy, but always attentive!

Jim Mullet

You can go anywhere for bad service.
I won’t be back.

Jeff Hough

Great place, but they no longer brew their own beer and have not updated their website.

Paula Meyers

Wow, what an outstanding dining experience! Our party of five started off with wings and fried green beans which were ample, delicious and perfectly prepared setting our expectations for a forthcoming meal of hopefully the same caliber. We were not disappointed! Each member of our group ordered a different menu item and the comments were consistently outstanding. Tender, perfectly seasoned brisket, enormous portions of flaky fish, burgers perfectly charred and chicken Alfredo with a creamy, rich sauce and juicy, flavorful chicken. Collectively we were all equally impressed with our dining experience and our friendly, attentive, efficient server. Major kudos to the talented chef and team of Fenwick Farms for proving Indiana can be on par with renowned dining in Tampa that our family experiences routinely. We look forward to visiting again soon!!

Sally Skinner

Terrible service. Couldn’t even get someone to seat us ( there is a sign instructing patrons to wait to be seated ). This has happened on more than one occasion.

Mary Cantu

Excellent Food & Service!!!!!

Haley Selby

The food was fantastic and the service was great.

Julie Lewis

My husband and I both got the Brisket Sandwich tonight, and it was the best Brisket we have ever had. It was so delicious, lots of flavor with the diced pickles and fried onion strings. I highly recommend giving it a try. You will NOT be disappointed!!!

kisha Swartz

Always delicious! Call in order, it was ready when I got there and perfectly made.

Rich Love

Thai PB&J Burger is good

Pir8Radio

I previously gave these guys a good review, then they got a new chief, and the food went down hill (few years ago). Today we decided to see if anything changed, and glad we did! Different chief, new menu, they are back on top! Server was awesome (Jessica), food was fancy but not over the top, still had a little small town feel but big city taste. Guess we will start coming here again! ☺️

Loading...