McAlister's Deli

2014 E Tipton St, Seymour
(812) 777-8280

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Harvest Chicken Salad Contains Pecans

Sweet and Smoky Chicken

Black Angus King Club

Broccoli and Cheddar

Country Potato Soup

Four Cheese Melt

The New Yorker

French Dip 12

Potato Salad

Veggie Spud

McAlister's® menu has so many great items, it's hard making a choice. That's why we allow you to "Choose 2." You can have a half salad and a cup of soup too, no sacrificing one or the other required. You can pair a sandwich with a spud, or any other combination your heart desires. The more you try, the more you'll love coming back.

Clubs

McAlister's Club Wrap

Cut the carbs without cutting the taste.Get our famous McAlister's Club with smoked turkey, Black Forest ham and everything on it except the bread. Wrap it up in a wheat wrap instead. Includes a side and pickle spear.

McAlister's Club

Smoked turkey, Black Forest ham, bacon, sharp cheddar, Swiss, spring mix, tomato, mayo and McAlister's Honey Mustard™ on wheat. Includes a side and pickle spear.

King Club

Twice the ingredients of the McAlister's Club on country white. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Grilled Chicken King Club

Twice the ingredients of the Grilled Chicken Club on country white. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Black Angus King Club

Twice the ingredients of the Black Angus Club on country white. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Grilled Chicken Club

McAlister's Club with grilled chicken in place of ham and turkey. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Black Angus Club

Black Angus roast beef, bacon, sharp cheddar, Swiss, red onion, spring mix, tomato, horseradish sauce and mayo on wheat. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Craveable Classics

Ham & Cheese Melt

Black Forest ham, Swiss, mayo , spicy brown mustard, and tomato on toasted ciabatta. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Four Cheese Melt

Provolone, Swiss, American, Parmesan and Tomato on Toasted Ciabatta. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Harvest Chicken Salad (contains pecans)

Chicken salad with cranberries and pecans, spring mix and tomato on croissant. Includes a side and pickle spear. *This product contains pecans*

Grilled Chicken

Grilled chicken with spring mix, tomato, Swiss and McAlister's Honey Mustard™ on Croissant. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Chicken Ranch BLT

Seasoned grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon, tomato, spring mix, and buttermilk ranch on toasted country white bread

Big & Bold

The Italian

Black Forest ham, salami, provolone, house-roasted multicolored peppers, spring mix, tomato, red onion, black olives, Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinaigrette and spicy brown mustard on baguette. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Reuben

Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss and Thousand Island dressing on marbled rye. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Memphian® 12"

Smoked turkey, Black Forest ham and Black Angus roast beef, provolone, spring mix, tomato, mayo and spicy brown mustard on baguette. Includes a side and pickle spear.

French Dip

Black Angus roast beef and swiss on a baguette, served au jus. Includes a side and pickle spear.

French Dip 12"

Black Angus roast beef and swiss on a baguette, served au jus. Includes a side and pickle spear.

The New Yorker

Corned beef, pastrami, Swiss and spicy brown mustard on marbled rye. Includes a side and pickle spear.

The Italian 12"

Memphian®

Smoked turkey, Black Forest ham and Black Angus roast beef, provolone, spring mix, tomato, mayo and spicy brown mustard on baguette. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Rachel

Turkey, sauerkraut, Swiss and Thousand Island dressing on marbled rye. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Savory and Spicy

Spicy Turkey Melt

Smoked turkey, bacon, pepper jack, avocado, chipotle ranch, spring mix and tomato on toasted baguette. Includes a side.

Spicy Turkey Melt 12"

Smoked turkey, bacon, pepper jack, avocado, chipotle ranch, spring mix and tomato on toasted baguette. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Smoky Pepper Jack Turkey

Smoked turkey, bacon, pepper jack and McAlister's Honey Mustard™ on toasted ciabatta. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Jalapeño Turkey Crunch

Smoked turkey, jalapeño spud chips, bacon, pepper jack, avocado and mayo on toasted jalapeño roll. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Horseradish Roast Beef & Cheddar

Black Angus roast beef, sharp cheddar, red onion and horseradish sauce on toasted ciabatta. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Spicy Southwest Chicken

Grilled chicken, roasted corn, poblano and black bean relish, pepper jack, avocado and chipotle ranch on toasted jalapeño roll. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Sweet and Smoky Chicken

Seasoned grilled chicken, sharp cheddar, and sweet & smoky barbecue sauce on a toasted ciabatta. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Fresh Favorites

BLT + Avocado

Applewood smoked bacon, spring mix, tomato, avocado and herb mayo on country white. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Garden Fresh Turkey

Smoked turkey, avocado, spinach, tomato, Swiss and Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinaigrette on 9-Grain. Includes a side and pickle spear.

The Veggie

Spinach, tomato, cucumber, red onion, house-roasted multicolored peppers, avocado and herb mayo on 9-grain. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, Romaine, Parmesan and Caesar dressing. Includes a side and pickle spear.

Fresh Salads

Garden Salad

Cheddar-jack, tomato, cucumber and croutons on mixed greens.

Pecanberry Salad

Fresh strawberries and blueberries, candied pecans and grilled chicken, served with Fat-Free Raspberry-Pecan Vinaigrette dressing.

Savannah Chopped Salad

Grilled chicken, dried cranberries, Gorgonzola, honey roasted almonds, tomato and cucumber on mixed greensTry it with Sherry Shallot dressing.

Southwest Chicken & Avocado Salad

Grilled chicken, roasted corn, poblano and black bean relish, red onion, tomato, cheddar-jack, blue corn tortilla strips, avocado on mixed greens.Try it with Chili Lime Vinaigrette dressing.

Grilled Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar-jack, tomato, cucumber and croutons on mixed greens

Harvest Chicken Salad (contains pecans)

Our Garden Salad with a scoop of Harvest Chicken Salad. *This product contains pecans.*

Chef Salad

Diced Turkey and ham, bacon, cheddar-jack, tomato, croutons and cucumber on mixed greens.

Caesar Salad

Parmesan, croutons and Caesar dressing on romaine lettuce.

Grilled Chicken Caesar

Parmesan, croutons and Caesar dressing on romaine lettuce with Grilled Chicken.

Shareables

Nacho Basket

RO*TEL cheese dip, jalapeños and tortillla chips.

Ultimate Nachos

Chili, RO*TEL cheese sauce, cheddar-jack, tomato, black olives, jalapeños, green onion, avocado and sour cream on tortilla chips.

Giant Spuds

Veggie Spud

Spinach, broccoli, red onions, house-roasted multicolored peppers, and RO*TEL cheese sauce.

Chipotle Chicken & Bacon Spud

Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar-jack, chipotle ranch and green onion.

Spud Max™

Ham, turkey, bacon, cheddar-jack, green onion, black olives and sour cream.

Justaspud®

With sour cream on the sideAdd Bacon or Add Cheddar-Jack prices vary by location.

Black Angus Roast Beef Spud

Black Angus roast beef, red onion, cheddar-jack, and au jus.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Spud

Seasoned grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar-jack, buttermilk ranch and green onions

Soups

Broccoli and Cheddar

Cheddar and Monterrey Jack Cheese mixed with chunks of Broccoli in a creamy base made from chicken broth.

Country Potato Soup

There's nothing like the down home taste of a hot potato soup, especially if it combines the flavors of potato, onion, bacon, chives and cheese.

Chicken Tortilla Soup

A hearty, satisfying soup that's packed with the flavorful ingredients of chicken, tomato, cilantro and cheese, with the kick of peppers.

Chili

Filled with beef, beef and more beef to give it a hearty flavor that will warm your heart.

Veggie Chili

A hearty, meatless, all-bean chili that has all the seasoning you love.

Kids Meals

Kids Auntie Anne's Mini Pretzel Dogs

Auntie Anne's sweet pretzel dough wrapped around a delicious bite-sized hot dog, baked to a golden perfection. Sold as a 5ct.

Kids Pizza

Mozzarella and marinara in a deep dish crust. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Kids Cheese Toastie

American cheese on toasted wheat bread. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Kids Ham Toastie

American cheese with ham on toasted wheat bread. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Kids Turkey Toastie

American cheese with turkey on toasted wheat bread. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Smucker's® Uncrustables® PB&J

Grape jelly and peanut butter on crust-less wheat bread. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Kids Mac & Cheese

Elbow macaroni noodles with creamy cheddar, American and Neufchatel cheeses. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Kids Spud

An Idaho potato served with butter and your choice of toppings: Cheddar-jack Cheese, Bacon, All-Natural Sour Cream. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Kids Garden Salad

Crisp cucumbers, tomatoes, cheese and croutons over fresh greens with your choice of dressing and protein: All-Natural Chicken Strips, Ham, or Turkey. Comes with your choice of a side and a Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Sides

Side Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with parmesan cheese and croutons and a side of Caesar dressing.

Tomato & Cucumber Salad

A blend of tomatoes and cucumbers with sliced red onions and mixed with balsamic vinaigrette

Fresh Fruit

A mixture of fresh, seasonal fruits.

Bag of Chips

Your meal with a side of crunch.It's the classic side for your classic choice.

Mac & Cheese

Elbow macaroni noodles with creamy cheddar, American and Neufchatel cheese.

Potato Salad

Southern style potato salad with chunks of potatoes blanketed with our creamy mustard and egg dressing.

Steamed Broccoli

Lightly seasoned steamed broccoli

Side Garden Salad

A light bite made with a bed of lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheddar-jack cheese and your choice of dressing.

Desserts

Brookie

A delicious blend of chocolate brownie and chocolate chip cookie

Sugar Cookie

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Colossal Carrot Cake

Giant slice of moist carrot cake with walnuts and cream cheese frosting.

Brownie

A moist and rich double fudge treat

Photos

+24 photos

+23 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Ubereats

Doordash

Recent Reviews

I come to this location frequently as I have a tea pass (great deal!!) and the staff is always friendly and kind. Being a regular for years now, I've gotten food a lot too and almost never have issues. Their salad and sandwiches are great :) highly recommend

December 2025

Here from out of town. When we stepped into the restaurant, it had a very strong stench like a stinky bathroom. There were no other customers at 3:30. Perhaps this is why? Food was good though

October 2025

Ever since I had McAlister's in Indianapolis for the first time, I have loved their food! Their choose 2 is fabulous since I can never just pick 1 item 🤣 The Italian sandwich is delicious 😋 I'm not big on mustard, but the kind this sandwich comes with is good. I take the olives off 🤮 & that makes it perfect for me. Their loaded baked potato is phenomenal! You get a whole spud with the choose 2 even though it says only half a spud 😆 their regular order...

October 2025

More Reviews

McAlister's Deli

Customers' Favorites