Miss May Designs Bake Shop

We asked for a 90s/80s tiered cake for our wedding and she delivered! It turned out wonderful. We also did a dessert buffet for the guests and they were a hit! Very reasonably priced as well.

Food: 5

Service: 5

They did a phenomenal job of my custom cake order. I ordered a ghost face cake and gave them creative freedom and it came out absolutely perfect. The cake was also really delicious in the icing was so good. Definitely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great gluten free cake! She is very helpful with getting the order right!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered a birthday cake for my daughter’s 33rd birthday. Reasonable price for such a delicious and beautifully decorated cake. Perfect size to have at a family cookout birthday dinner. Lemon cake was moist and favorable, the buttercream light and delicious with no overly sweet notes. Raspberry filling was a lovely addition. Services and communication was great throughout the whole process. Highly recommend this shop!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Can’t recommend Miss May Designs Bake Shop enough! Their attention to detail, flavor, and presentation is unmatched. I’ll absolutely be back for future events!

The nicest and most accommodating owner. Her chocolate cookies look amazing. Cant wait to try them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My daughter and I went to the shop today and had such a wonderful experience! The ladies were friendly and didn't rush us while we were there. We had a lemon cupcake, chocolate cake pop, a chocolate chip cookie, and a few of their decorated cookies. We sampled everything when we got home and it was all delicious! We will definitely be back next time we are in the area.

Ordered through Uber Eats. Just brownies (fudge and turtle), millionaire bars, and cupcakes.

I don’t typically use hyperbole, but this was amazing. Probably the best fudge brownie I have ever had in recent memory. Kids loved the cupcakes. Everything we received was larger than expected, which garnered zero complaints from the kiddos.

First time ordering, but not the last. We live in downtown-area but will travel to Speedway to check this place out in person.

Food: 5

My custom cake order was perfect! Went in on a Thursday at 11am and was ready for pickup next day. Showed her my Pinterest inspo and was pretty much spot on. Great price and delicious carrot cake with cream cheese icing. 10/10!

I am a former food reviewer. I went in and picked out some cupcakes to try and bought four different ones. I tried each one, and each one was dry. The vanilla cupcake didn’t have a robust taste. I would NOT recommend this shop. The lady in the shop rushed me through my order so she could close up. The lady was friendly though. However, she didn’t inform me of the store’s no refund policy. I did not see a sign either. I placed an order for two cakes, and went home. I sampled the cupcakes at home and after realizing they didn’t taste delicious, I contacted the shop to cancel the order. I talked to a person who said the manger would call me back, and the manager never called me back. I wanted to cancel the order and get a refund because the cupcakes were not up to par. Now, I have no cakes and am out $120. My suggestion is to try the merchandise before you put an order in.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

The wedding cake of our dreams!! Miss May Designs baked the most delicious, beautiful cake for our wedding day. Kristen was so helpful in answering any questions and preparing months in advance a cake taste test for us. There were so many cake, fillings, and icing flavors/options to choose from. She allowed us to get creative with any mixes we wanted to make our wedding cake unique to use and what we liked. We cannot thank her enough for the hard work and talent in creating our cake. She's the best!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am a former food reviewer. I went in and picked out some cupcakes to try and bought four different ones. I tried each one, and each one was dry. The vanilla cupcake didn’t have a robust taste. I would NOT recommend this shop. The lady in the shop rushed me through my order so she could close up. The lady was friendly though. However, she didn’t inform me of the store’s no refund policy. I did not see a sign either. I placed an order for two cakes, and went home. I sampled the cupcakes at home and after realizing they didn’t taste delicious, I contacted the shop to cancel the order. I talked to a person who said the manger would call me back, and the manager never called me back. I wanted to cancel the order and get a refund because the cupcakes were not up to par. Now, I have no cakes and am out $120. My suggestion is to try the merchandise before you put an order in.

My wife and I did a two tier, round cake for our wedding and all our guests raved about how delicious it was. There were only a few pieces left at the end of night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Very friendly shop, was running late to pick up my order and they were able to work out an alternative pick up strategy. The desserts are beautiful and definitely are as delicious as they look ?

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Sammie, Chocolate Chip Cookie

adapted my grandmother's recipe

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake