Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats

21 S Main St, Sullivan
(812) 638-2997

Recent Reviews

Jaycee Ahlefeld

I've used Alyssa 2x for birthday cakes & both times have been great! I also love visiting her shop for a quick treat & yummy fountain pops! Better than the gas station for sure!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jamie Eytchison

I order cupcakes for my niece's birthday, and they were not at all what they were supposed to look like. I spent 2 hours the night before the party fixing them, thankfully I was able to.First photo is what I ordered second photo is what I receivedhighly unsatisfied

Treina Fifer

Cake was so tiny was under the impression it would be 3 layers not 2. The flowers in the cake slid down to the bottom layer and left a grassy butter

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Lisa Johns

I love this bakery! The work Alyssa does it outstanding. 2 time ordering and they both came out awesome. My little wedding cake for my anniversary and my son's 20th birthday cake she made, perfect.I will never go anywhere else. Thank you again Alyssa.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Perkins

Alyssa is the best. She made our wedding something special. Beautiful cake and the service was amazing. Thank you for the delivery of an awesome and delicious cake.

Rosemary Daugherty

Wonderful cakes and cupcakes.

Mark Johns

My daughter's birthday cake is AMAZING... Thank you again for making her cake for me.. she lived it!

Joseph Mattison

Tastes amazing with great prices

E. Glynn Beck

Had the Lemon and White Wedding cupckes, and sugar cookie. Excellent. Great service and small town atmosphere.

Shannon Chi

This was our first time using Alyssa’s. We’re new to the area and I’m so glad that we decided to have my daughter’s birthday cake made here. It was super cute and very tasty! I normally don’t eat any cake even on birthdays because I just haven’t been a huge fan, but I had a slice and it was easily some of the best cake I’ve ever tasted. All of the guests were just as pleased and asked where I got it from. It was moist and the frosting was just as tasty and not that chemical taste you often get in colored frosting. My daughters also love their cupcakes and cake pops. I didn’t manage to get a pic of the cake before my daughter added the candles. She called it hair and laser beam eyes. ? But you can still see how cute the cake was! I was also quite surprised how well priced their products are. I highly recommend. My youngest has a birthday coming up in a few months and she’s already asked that I get her cake from here too! You won’t be disappointed!

Marian Medsker Parish

Last fall my daughter set up an order for her wedding. She got married this May and 30 minutes before the wedding she called the cake place and the owner had put her on her schedule for June 25th?!?!?! My daughters text messages with her clearly state what the order is and the correct date of the wedding and the cake place responded with “I have you on my calendar”. Needless to say there was no way to get any wedding cake to the wedding with only 30 minutes to spare. I understand mistakes can happen but to have the right date in writing and then still get it wrong is unacceptable. A wedding is a once in a lifetime event and to make this grave of an error is totally irresponsible. So buyer beware of this business.

Emily Patrick

My family loved the unique cake and cupcakes. Tastes amazing

Yu-Hsuan Cheng

I ordered a three tiered cake for my wedding on October 10th. The look and the taste were amazing! I got a lot of good comments about the cake from friends. They kept asking where I got the cake from!!We got three different flavor layers: red velvet cake with strawberries, chocolate cake with chocolate cream and walnuts, and lemon cake with lemon custard! All of them tasted wonderful, but lemon cake and lemon custard is our favorite!!!Plus, Alyssa is super friendly and easy to work with!

Tamara Biddle

Some of the BEST cupcakes and cakes ever. The salad bar was a much needed in our community. The staff is always friendly and willing to help in anyway...

Brittney Lynne Hancock

I highly recommend Alyssa’s custom cakes & treats for all your sweet tooth needs! Not only did she make my daughters birthday cake & cupcakes look amazing they tasted amazing too! 8 days before the party I messaged her & asked if she could make more then I had originally asked for & she happily did it for me! She also has slushees, cookies, and cake pops that my kids absolutely love! We personally haven’t tried anything from there we didn’t love.

Load More

Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats

21 S Main St, Sullivan, IN 47882
(812) 638-2997