Papa Johns Pizza

2226 N Section St, Sullivan
(812) 268-7500

Recent Reviews

eva hamby

The only good thing about the pizza was the fast delivery. The man that took my call was extremely difficult to understand. Ordered well done with light cheese. Crust was BARELY done and it was drowned in cheese! Hardly any sauce on it. Very disappointed.

Food: 2

Service: 4

Allen Crabbe

My wife and I ordered and got exactly what we wanted.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandie O'Vivion

Was good, but they did put Olives on when I ordered no olives. Wasn't happy about having to dissect my pizza before eating it. Overall it was good. Clean & friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Eli Tripps

I don't know what happened to papa John's. I was looking forward to a good crust with great sauce and a peppercini. What I got was a just chewy and flavorless and no peppercini. I would rather eat school pizza than what I got. 65$ of food for 5 people left half uneaten and sorely disappointed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Robert Barry

Best pizza in town

Bethany N.

we ordered food for carry out because delivery was not an option. i ordered a papa bowl for myself and my bf ordered his food. they called apologizing they didn't have any papa bowls in their location (why let me place it in my order even). so he said i would order something else in a few or when i got there. so i got on my phone and ordered papa bites, under the same name, number and email. i went up pick it up, they did not have my food anywhere in their system and the man tried to argue with me, it was confirmed on my bf email. the manager was right there could hear the whole conversation and never once tried to step in and i was visibly upset. and at the time the delivery guy came in bragging about the tip he made. so i wasted my time and gas just for my food not to be ordered.

Adam Vaseloff

Thanks for hooking it up bankside!!!

Shade DeBruhl

website was down for a very long time. now can't get food delivered. says open online but when you call they are closed.

Paula Robbins

They make me not fixing dinner an easy decision.

Scott Minier

Just recently fell in love with Papa John's Pizza restaurants.... Where have they been all my life?

Jesse Chastain

Called an hour before closing was told they're closed and hung up. Quality of the food is atrocious from the puddle of grease, undercooked even when it's "well done" to the crust being so thin it had holes and ripping apart when trying to pick up a slice. Would give 0 stars if it was an option.

Alicia Risley

Love the food but it usually takes forever and recently they have no delivery drivers.

Sherrie Mcbride

Fast friendly service. Crew is always laughing and having a good time making pizzas.

matt l (Lemur Productions)

Remember to have crust cooked longer.

Tyler Owen

This is a gas station also and the owner is is ridiculous almost ran out of gas with my 3 kids in the car and he wouldn't take change or a card with a couple dollars on it

Load More