The Red Room Cakery

3641 S Murphy St, Prairieton
(812) 814-4880

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bev Merritt-Hicks

The cake was ABSOLUTELY delicious! Thank you for the unique style and thought that went into the entire cake! 10/10 will use again!

Jonathan Cable

All of their desserts are good but the banana pie is my favorite!

Samantha Dickerson

This place is gem! I had the best experience choosing my wedding cake, and tasting cupcakes and icing. I got a free slice of cheesecake that was mouthwatering and a scrumptious blueberry muffin.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cupcakes, Birthday Cakes, Wedding Cake

Samantha Dickerson

Great cupcakes and cheesecake! Muffins are amazing! 🤩

Madelyn Rodriguez

HANDS DOWN Jamie is the best. I will always reccomend anyone and everyone to get cakes from him! His cakes are so amazing and the decorations on the cakes are so beautiful! Our wedding cake was so good we had none left!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Madelyn Pauser

HANDS DOWN Jamie is the best. I will always reccomend anyone and everyone to get cakes from him! His cakes are so amazing and the decorations on the cakes are so beautiful! Our wedding cake was so good we had none left!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Larry Evinger

Delicious desserts at great prices.

YJ Z

Had 2 pieces of cake and 2 muffins yesterday. They are all really good — moist, the right amount of sweetness, unique taste that you can’t just buy from anywhere. The chef was really welcoming and nice.

Beth Spurgin

The custom cakes and other desserts are amazing. The place to go when you want something out of the ordinary. The owner and his assistant are pretty cool too.

Natalia Lima

I had a wonderful experience with The Red Room Cakery! First, I would like to say that Chef Jamie is awesome and he delivered exactly what I asked for. I wanted a naked wedding cake with 4 tiers, a different flavor for each tier, and with filling. I know that it’s a lot, but he did such an amazing job and all the flavors were so tasty! Our favorite flavor was definitely the white chocolate with raspberry filling :) I also asked him to use real flowers to decorate the cake and the result was stunning. We also received lots of compliments from our wedding guests about the cake flavors. Overall, I would definitely recommend their business for any event that needs a a cake or desert. I tried a few other places before and I can definitely say that RRC is high quality and very professional. Thank you for the great service guys!

Daydream135833

This place was a delight! Great food, great service and a very nice and friendly waitress. Win, win, win. Highly recommend.

Matthew Barts

Amazing desserts and breads! Ordered two cakes for a party and spoke to Chef J about what kinds we wanted and he made them based on our input. The focaccia bread was very good!

Yiji Zhang

Had 2 pieces of cake and 2 muffins yesterday. They are all really good — moist, the right amount of sweetness, unique taste that you can’t just buy from anywhere. The chef was really welcoming and nice.

Mari Jackson

Jamie was so personable and welcoming. I tried the cinnamon roll twists and herbed focaccia bread. They were both delicious, and my husband and two young sons gave their thumbs up as well! I will definitely be bringing the whole family by again for more amazing treats!

Heath D

Super nice people, and they're easy to work with. We did a small cake for us to cut and cupcakes so we didn't have to mess with plates and silverware. The strawberries and cream were DELICIOUS. I'm usually not a big fan of vanilla with vanilla icing, but the white velvet was delicious, not overly almond, like most I've had. The red velvet was a little dry the day of the wedding, but I think they just baked for a little too long, as the other ones were very moist. We over ordered, on purpose, so we'd have plenty leftover. Let's say they didn't last long in the freezer before we ate them all. I am not a fan of carrot cake, or so I thought, because we ended up choosing that as our wedding cake flavor. I also really loved their white chocolate with raspberry, I believe. Never in a million years did I think I'd like it, but it was a contender for one of our flavors. However, we chose more common flavors for our guests..

Loading...