Montana Mike's Steakhouse

1626 Willow St, Vincennes
(812) 882-2818

Recent Reviews

Sort by
GD D

The Sunday bartender has no personality. You walk in she doesn't greet you but throws a cple coasters your way than finally takes your drink order. We didn't stay for food. We went someplace else. Only on Sundays do we get that treatment!

Ryan Portee

Nice date night place not super

Carol Arvin

Atmosphere was very rustic, felt like we were in a cabin. Food could've been better. Our waitress did a very good job.

Tammy Butler

We came here for the 1st time, and it wont be our last, we ordered 8oz fillet mignon, the steaks were tender just A tad overdone for A medium steak, mine was medium well so somewhat overdone but still delicious and tender. Our server was awesome, very attentive and sweet. The only thing I really noticed was the floor was very sticky walking to the booth, but their was small kids in the area and could have easily spilled A drink. All in all 100% better than the Texas roadhouse here in Vincennes. This is definitely A great place for steak, and the Margaritas was on point....

Melanie East_mel,

Great food! My steak was tender and juicy, no steak sauce needed, very flavorful. Service was excellent and friendly from the minute we entered. Wonderful experience!

Marty Holman

Steak was terrible. Rest of the food wasn't bad. DO NOT order your steak Pittsburgh here. It is supposed to be seared at the hottest possible temperature in butter; seared shut. This tasted like it was dropped in a fireplace full of ash.

Kelly B

The whole staff was very friendly but our waitress stole the show. She must have been 7 months pregnant but she was amazing! The food was big in portion size and also very good. Also the bathroom, although outdated was very clean. Overall a great experience.

dschroyer

I was in town recently for a class reunion. I actually ate here twice and found good value and customer service throughout the visit. The food was good and the value was excellent. I will come back here again when I am in town.

Spawn0fShane (Gaming)

I got the fried catfish, in which I will say was absolutely delicious. I ate every bit despite being as fool as I was from all of the appetizers etc. One warning though, never get the pasta. I got the sample some of the Alfredo and it's not that it was bad or anything, it was just actively tasteless. Completely and utterly tasteless. Sauce and all. Everything else that was fairly good.

Jeannie Bray

My husband ordered the stake and shrimp which he said was ok I ordered a full slab of Ribs which was awful, very tough and hard to eat or even cut off the bone. Thankfully our server Debbie who was very nice took them back and brought me something else.

Jake Hunter

Wife's steak was overcooked and had to be sent back, but besides that, the experience was good. All other food was really good. Would recommend for anyone in the area

Terri Stoltz

I'm not sure what has happened here. But the food was just awful. I ordered salmon which was the only thing worth eating. Mashed potatoes were very rubbery, fresh vegetables were under cooked and the sweet potatoes were very old. I am not one to complain but this was bad.

Susann McEuen

Went to this place for Mothers Day dinner. Yes, it was busy. However, let me say this:Our waitress was polite and efficent. But, that is about the extend of my good comments.1. Our table was given to someone2. The host stood at the desk and picked his nose. I did bring it to the woman standing there with him. Told her before he saw us to our seats he should wash his hands, because he had been picking his nose.3. He did go somewhere and then cameback. Washed his hands with hand sanitizer, dried them and saw us to our seats.I did not use the menu or silverware he had touched.4. Couldn't keep the beer orders straight.5.The other nine people got their food, but I did not. The waitress saw that I didn't have food and she checked on it. Said she wrote down the wrong sandwich, brought me fries and said my sandwich would arrive shortly. The other nine people were almost finished with their meal before I got mine.6. My chicken sandwich was raw and rubbery. Did not eat it. The waitress redid the ticket and did not charge for the sandwich.7. The boy that brought the food had hair down over his eyes and he kept shaking his head.Not a good experience. Needless, to say, this was the second time I have been in this place, but, IT WILL BE THE LAST.

Jody Golish

I'd give a MINUS IF I COULD!! We paid 70$$ for steak we took home and fed to our dogs!! Told the girl that was waiting on us that they weren't very good and she says that Don't surprise me!!! Didn't offer to get a manager.. Didn't offer to do anything!! Our mushrooms and zucchini were good!! Will NOT BE BACK!!! May 7th.. I Have to update my review... I will now give you all 5 ? STARS .. we received great service.. our food was absolutely delicious.. from the salads.. to our appetizers.. mushrooms and zucchini.. I had the Cajun shrimp ribeye and my husband had the bone in ribeye.. they were delicious.. cooked to perfection..

Angela

Gentleman who seated us was polite. Debra was an excellent server. Shrimp appetizer was phenomenal when lemon juice was drizzled. Son's monster burger was delicious. Buns were wonderful. Chicken fried chicken that replaced an undercooked rib rack was fabulous. Debra and manager replaced the undercooked ribs without complaint. They were busy. The manager was cleaning tables. Like most restaurants, they need more staff. We will return again. Check with $10.00 tip was $54.00 for three. Two meals, a shrimp appetizer and a $4.95 extra set up with side salad, roll and potato for adult on a diet.

Loading...