Cake Lady

2475 E Pierceton Rd, Warsaw
(574) 253-2705

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nichole Fleming

I had the chance to try her cookie dough cheesecake that my daughter and son in-law brought to Thanksgiving. It was absolutely amazing…not to mention it was delicious!!!

Mc Nina

I picked up the cake I ordered for my husband’s office lunch and it was so pretty and really moist and delicious!

Terence Gay

Ordered an assortment of cookies for our group of 70... by end of the night, not a crumb was left! Delicious!!

Food: 5

Jacki Rutledge

We have had several cakes made for special occasions over the years. We have always been in awe with the amazing works of art that are created by Sarah! The cakes are delicious and everyone always says, “This is the best cake I have ever tasted”. I cannot recommend The Cake Lady enough! She’s the best!

Ashlee Coffin Sauer

Cakes are always beautiful, original, and always taste great! So thankful for a great baker so close to home :)

Jamie Gerkin

She is always willing to go above and beyond for my cakes and cupcakes. Truly amazing! Will never go to a different bakery

Lauren Sasso

These cheesecakes are to die for! We got blueberry, chocolate chip, strawberry and turtle in a cheesecake flight and they were all so delicious. Would recommend to anyone

Angie Capps

I attended a WACC banquet. I don't enjoy cake, but I love the Cake Lady's cake. I was hesitant to eat my cupcake, but took one bite and knew it was from the cake lady. It was delicious

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dee Dee

Her cakes taste amazing! They are beautiful as well!

Magnvs LeMain-Mann (BilboBagginsTwizeRemoved)

THE LADY OF THE CAKE, not to be confused with the Lady of the Lake, of whom provided King Arthur d'Camelot with the legendary cold-steel zweihander blade named Caledfwlch, or commonly, Excalibur. And one must not travel halfway across the land to Avalon to receive such magical gifts, nay, but a relatively swift carriage ride - in my case 10 minutes, as the crow flies. In the previous 1/5 score (I don't mean anything relating to a 1 out of 5 review score, etc, but rather meaning that a "score" is a measurement of time, 20 years to be exact...thus 1/5 of 20 years = 4 years time ??. So why did I go through all of this trouble when I could have concisely and/or succinctly just said 4 years? I DUNNO.) I and mine familia have conducted business with The Lady of the Cake 5 times and every instance has been met with nigh holistic perfection. The recipe of our primary recidivism has been the Blueberry-Lemon/Lemon-Blueberry, and boy-oh-boy/girl-oh-girl/man/oh-man/woman-oh-woman 'tis delicioso, indeed!!!!Dear The Lady of the Cake: I shall never throw any cake back into the lake!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Blueberry Topped Cheesecake

Katey Walls

Professional, beautiful, and delicious cakes and desserts!

Food: 5

Kendra Grose

Mini cheesecakes were delicious ?

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole' Jackson Felton

We have ordered 3 beautiful cakes🥰 from the Cake Lady and loved them all. Her cakes make our birthdays delicious!

Jerry Exo

We ordered the strawberries and cream cake for my Mother-in-Laws 88th birthday and it was fabulous!! This is the third time we ordered a cake from here. Each one was supremely delicious and always decorated so beautifully. We will definitely order from The Cake Lady again. My mouth is watering just thinking about it! Thank you so much!!

brittany strauss

Tried to get some information, she seem to come off rude and act like she didn't even want my business. I understand people and places are busy.

Loading...