Casey's

123 Robbins St, Wheatfield
(219) 956-3022

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Faine Tebo

Pizza was absolutely disgusting and severely undercooked. We couldn't even eat it. Had to throw it away. Never again. Do not recommend.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Kelly Jurkowski

Super friendly staff and the coffee and doughnuts are great

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Shrink

I still haven't received the refund from the 4 items Missing on my delivery order that I purchased on the Casey's app, going on a month now. Don't order from this store ever!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rina

Never again!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lauren F

Best pizza in my opinion. So long as you eat it fresh. :-)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

king gaming

Sad experience when it came to ordering delivery pizza called and was told I needed to come pick up the pizza myself after paying a delivery fee and tip will not be doing business here anymore

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Connor Griffin

IF YOURE LOOKING FOR A PLACE TO GET YOUR ORDER WRONG LITERALLY EVERY SINGLE TIME THIS IS THE PLACE FOR YOU ! I DONT KNOW HOW ITS EVEN POSSIBLE ?

Paul Loslo

Clean, convenient, friendly service and good pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Ramirez

Well ordered 4 pizzas at 1050 asked to be ready for birthday party at 1130 said would be ready in 25 minutes went in at 1125 and she said haven't been put in yet would be a half hour I said alright but would be late for the party.at 1145 seen. Them throw 2 pizzas away and they come up and said just cleaned ovens and wasn't hot enough so we're doughy and would have to make again got home and 2 single toppings were ok but both specialties were still not completely cooked not happy and will probably drive to demonte from now on

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza

aar t

I am regular, long time customer on this Location. They just hired a new girl name JILL, Oh boy she really has bad mouth. She is very rude and obnoxious. She was even rude to a elderly couple ahead of me. She will make a lot of regulars to stop coming to this location.

V

My kids like the pizza, and I don't think it's too bad either. They did give us sausage on a taco pizza instead of the beef which didn't taste that great. However the employees always seem so miserable and rude. There are a few nice ones but I don't like going in because they're definitely not the friendliest bunch.To the response. We did try it again and the pizza was bad. Pepperoni was full of grease. Ordered the. Brisket pizza and it was just a huge sloppy mess. Won't be spending anymore money on this place.

Alaina Carter

Amazing service even when they had over 14 orders at night time!!!!!

James Ahrendt II

Everything is so overpriced and the ladies are pretty helpful but when you have more than three or four people in line someone should come out and help open another register causes people to be late to work

Golden Girls

Got to the store when they said it would be done and waited another 30 minutes for our pizza and sides. The girl up front was very nice but one of the guys supposed to be working/cooking was literally just standing back there talking. Very ridiculous. Several other people were waiting forever too.

Selena Besner

Almost always a pleasant transaction.

Loading...