What a wonderful and unexpected place. I was surprised that they hand make all their pies in actual glass pie pans. It's family ran (we meet the sister of the owner - supper nice folks), nice sitting area inside and outside. Very personal. We traveled to Indy from Arkansas for the weekend and My Sugar Pie will be on our list to visit again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: My Kentucky Pie
Andrew Whitworth
We were in Indiana visiting family and decided to try and track down a "Sugar Cream Pie" which apparently is kind of a regional specialty. Our investigations lead us to My Sugar Pie, and I'm glad we came! We did pick up a Sugar Cream Pie for everybody to share and try, but we also grabbed a few slices of other pies as well. Everything we tasted was absolutely delicious! I loved the crusts and my wife loved the Blueberry+Peach pie.
The whole pie was a little bit on the pricy side, but then again it came with a glass pie dish!? So, honestly getting a reusable pie dish makes it a decent deal.
We liked this place a lot, it was a cute little stop for our group and we would definitely come back next time we are in Zionsville.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Megan Maze
My Kentucky pie was delicious, applie as well and the Hooiser sugar pie was amazing. Definitely lived up to the hype.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cream Pie
Anupa D.
So many pies, so little time! We had a really hard TE.tryimg.to find sugar cream pie, aka Hoosier Pie but finally found it. And boy, was it good!! I could almost dive 20 hours just for this one item!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cream Pie
Imagne mode
To the Business Owner "Kelly" from a Business Owner. The Staff need training on Customer Service! On Saturday, 9/28 at 9:30a, I came into to buy a pre-baked pie. After selecting my pie, I walked to the counter to pay. A worker from the back came out to ring me up. She was a tall, younger gal with a baseball hat. She looked down the entire time and didn't make any eye contact or even say Good Morning, Hi or is that all for you? She said that will be $43. I asked what the store recommends for heating the pie. She says, "its online - look it up". I said, I'm here in the store with no other customers, can't you just tell me? She reached down and picked up some instructions from under the counter, and said "here's some". Hello? You couldn't just give that to me in the first place? After this, there was not even a Thank you for coming in or nothing. She just turned around and walked to the back of store. Please train your staff on better Customer Service. There are other pie places that I can take my business elsewhere that offer more appreciation to its customers!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Bernardo salcido
A must try is the sugar cream pie- amazing!
If you have never had sugar cream pie, think banana crème with a little firmer texture, and no whip cream on top.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cream Pie
A B
Ordered a Dutch apple for my husband’s birthday. It was fine, not great. It was also very pricey for a pie. We prefer Pots and Pans and will go back there next year.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Angela B
Ordered a Dutch apple for my husband’s birthday. It was fine, not great. It was also very pricey for a pie. We prefer Pots and Pans and will go back there next year.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
RACHEL HILL
Delicious pies and cutest little shop. I love all the pies we have bought here. My husband’s favorite is the rhubarb. Yum! You can tell they bake the pies with love!
The pies are great but it’s so dirty inside and out that I will never go back again. It needs updated, cleaned, painted and it’s crammed inside. It’s gotten junky inside with the new cases. It’s too cluttered and they need to spend the money doing some updates if they want $40 plus for a pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 2
Rhys Weber
Ordered a coconut cream pie for my dad's birthday. Braved snow and wind to pick it up, and it was worth every penny.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brittani Burnham
I wanted to try this place cause it sounded good. I’m not a huge pie person so that is probably why I found them just mediocre. I tried the confetti pie. It was ok. The Apple pie was good and I would like to try the strawberry rhubarb. I recommend getting their traditional pie flavors. Next time I decide I would like pie I will probably go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie, Slice of Pie
Derek Strainer
My wife brought home Dutch Apple Pie. This pie was the best apple pie/dessert I have had. They are pricey but we were given ours as a gift. I seriously talked about this pie for DAYS. I ate off of it for 4 days and it stayed delicious the whole time. Thank you!!!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Ian
Legit the best apple pie I’ve ever had. I need more. I need like 6 on hand always.
What a wonderful and unexpected place. I was surprised that they hand make all their pies in actual glass pie pans. It's family ran (we meet the sister of the owner - supper nice folks), nice sitting area inside and outside. Very personal. We traveled to Indy from Arkansas for the weekend and My Sugar Pie will be on our list to visit again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: My Kentucky Pie
We were in Indiana visiting family and decided to try and track down a "Sugar Cream Pie" which apparently is kind of a regional specialty. Our investigations lead us to My Sugar Pie, and I'm glad we came! We did pick up a Sugar Cream Pie for everybody to share and try, but we also grabbed a few slices of other pies as well. Everything we tasted was absolutely delicious! I loved the crusts and my wife loved the Blueberry+Peach pie.
The whole pie was a little bit on the pricy side, but then again it came with a glass pie dish!? So, honestly getting a reusable pie dish makes it a decent deal.
We liked this place a lot, it was a cute little stop for our group and we would definitely come back next time we are in Zionsville.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My Kentucky pie was delicious, applie as well and the Hooiser sugar pie was amazing. Definitely lived up to the hype.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cream Pie
So many pies, so little time!
We had a really hard TE.tryimg.to find sugar cream pie, aka Hoosier Pie but finally found it. And boy, was it good!! I could almost dive 20 hours just for this one item!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cream Pie
To the Business Owner "Kelly" from a Business Owner. The Staff need training on Customer Service! On Saturday, 9/28 at 9:30a, I came into to buy a pre-baked pie. After selecting my pie, I walked to the counter to pay. A worker from the back came out to ring me up. She was a tall, younger gal with a baseball hat. She looked down the entire time and didn't make any eye contact or even say Good Morning, Hi or is that all for you? She said that will be $43. I asked what the store recommends for heating the pie. She says, "its online - look it up". I said, I'm here in the store with no other customers, can't you just tell me? She reached down and picked up some instructions from under the counter, and said "here's some". Hello? You couldn't just give that to me in the first place? After this, there was not even a Thank you for coming in or nothing. She just turned around and walked to the back of store. Please train your staff on better Customer Service. There are other pie places that I can take my business elsewhere that offer more appreciation to its customers!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
A must try is the sugar cream pie- amazing!
If you have never had sugar cream pie, think banana crème with a little firmer texture, and no whip cream on top.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cream Pie
Ordered a Dutch apple for my husband’s birthday. It was fine, not great. It was also very pricey for a pie. We prefer Pots and Pans and will go back there next year.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ordered a Dutch apple for my husband’s birthday. It was fine, not great. It was also very pricey for a pie. We prefer Pots and Pans and will go back there next year.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Delicious pies and cutest little shop. I love all the pies we have bought here. My husband’s favorite is the rhubarb. Yum! You can tell they bake the pies with love!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sugar cream pie is avaliable :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The pies are great but it’s so dirty inside and out that I will never go back again. It needs updated, cleaned, painted and it’s crammed inside. It’s gotten junky inside with the new cases. It’s too cluttered and they need to spend the money doing some updates if they want $40 plus for a pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 2
Ordered a coconut cream pie for my dad's birthday. Braved snow and wind to pick it up, and it was worth every penny.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wanted to try this place cause it sounded good. I’m not a huge pie person so that is probably why I found them just mediocre. I tried the confetti pie. It was ok. The Apple pie was good and I would like to try the strawberry rhubarb. I recommend getting their traditional pie flavors. Next time I decide I would like pie I will probably go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie, Slice of Pie
My wife brought home Dutch Apple Pie. This pie was the best apple pie/dessert I have had. They are pricey but we were given ours as a gift. I seriously talked about this pie for DAYS. I ate off of it for 4 days and it stayed delicious the whole time. Thank you!!!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Legit the best apple pie I’ve ever had. I need more. I need like 6 on hand always.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Loading...