My Sugar Pie
40 E Pine St, Zionsville
(317) 733-8717
Customers' Favorites
Sugar Cream Pie
My Kentucky Pie
Slice of Pie
Apple Pie
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
What a wonderful and unexpected place. I was surprised that they hand make all their pies in actual glass pie pans. It's family ran (we meet the sister of the owner - supper nice folks), nice sitting area inside and outside. Very personal. We traveled to Indy from Arkansas for the weekend and My Sugar Pie will be on our list to visit again.
We were in Indiana visiting family and decided to try and track down a "Sugar Cream Pie" which apparently is kind of a regional specialty. Our investigations lead us to My Sugar Pie, and I'm glad we came! We did pick up a Sugar Cream Pie for everybody to share and try, but we also grabbed a few slices of other pies as well. Everything we tasted was absolutely delicious! I loved the crusts and my wife loved the Blueberry+Peach pie.
The whole pie...
The whole pie...
So many pies, so little time!
We had a really hard TE.tryimg.to find sugar cream pie, aka Hoosier Pie but finally found it. And boy, was it good!! I could almost dive 20 hours just for this one item!!
We had a really hard TE.tryimg.to find sugar cream pie, aka Hoosier Pie but finally found it. And boy, was it good!! I could almost dive 20 hours just for this one item!!
You May Also Like
AUBERGE - 175 S Main St
![]()
French, Wine Bar
Roasted in the Village - 27 E Pine St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Bakery, Cafe, Coffee
Tipsy Mermaid Conch House & Cocktails - 135 S Main St
![]()
Seafood, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly