Pizza is great if you can get it, but they're NEVER open. If you're permanently closed, update your listing. If your hours changed, update your listing.
clay groeschen
Love this pizza. IMO, it's better than Giordano's. Slightly different style, but by far the best deep dish you can get in NKY. However, that's only when they answer the phone. I've called randomly throughout the day during open hours on various days and no response. Had to go elsewhere.
David South
Would love to leave a review. It's 6:42 on Saturday and they won't answer the phone.
Corey Marsh
Wonderful service, and even better food. Cheesy garlic drips smelled so good I couldn’t resist myself once I sat them in the car to take home. And the G.O.A.T. Pizza … has that name for good reason. Thank you Poseidon Pizza for making our life easier on where to get good pizza from.
Rob G
Great food, however, I really wish they would give a bit more sauce with their breadsticks and Garlic knots. The cups are really small, and are unable to hold enough for the amount of food provided.
Rachel Pape
Would LOVE to be able to leave a real review but the Cold Spring location NEVER ANSWERS THEIR PHONE during business hours and do not have online ordering. This is the 3rd time we've tried to order from here and cannot get anyone to answer. Do better.Aaaand online shows they are open at 12 today. Not 4.
Cassie Brown
Tried Poseidon's Pizza for the first time last week in Cold Spring, KY and it was some of the best pizza I have ever had! Amazing! Can't wait to go back this week!
Jennifer Quesada
First time ever trying this place out and I'm sold. Looks alone had my mouth watering. The pineapples were so sweet and juicy (which I've never had.) The garlic knots were delicious and the in-house sauce and ranch was just unreal. Thank you so much! Will be back for sure!
Tad Murphy
Caleb makes an amazing pizza! Perfect with every bite. 5/5 definitely recommend Poseidon's on 27. Great staff and better food!
Sandy RIEDINGER
Pizza was just fantastic! The crust was cooked perfectly and the toppings were delicious. They actually cooked the pizza for take out instead of just throwing something in a box just to fill the order.We ordered breadsticks (note: I never eat breadsticks) and they were super great. So fresh and plump like homemade bread from an Italian kitchen.We’ve been looking for a new go to pizza place and this is it!!! We will be back!! Thank you for putting the extra CARE in take out. It matters.
Fast delivery and best pizza in the area!!! I think the owner is Veteran so support you local veteran small business owners(photo is the medium hand tossed veggie modified and also asked to bake well so if it looks overcooked its because I specifically requested a well done pizza) the ordering process is easy although the product photos/ website design and overall marketing delivery would boost this already fantastic business to the level of National competiors in the area having to compete! (shameless plug if you need to hire a marketing company or product photographer)
Simon Sapsford
Great deep dish and specialty pizza. Wish they had good salads or other whole food plant based additions.
Ed Peters
Pizza was awesome. Had the deep dish. One of the best ever ate.. Will definitely be back..
Nick Johnson
The pizza is warm and tastes great every time we have ordered, but it's difficult to give it five stars. We've ordered carry out a handful of successful times, but when it comes to delivery, they are lacking. 3 of 3 delivery experiences were delivered 1.5-2 hours later. The most recent was not only late, but the pizza was wrong: toppings, crust, and size all wrong. It's a shame because it's five minutes from the house and everyone there seems friendly. Hopefully they improve their consistency and delivery times going forward!
matt Davidson
Was hopeful, but mediocre at best. The pizza tasted fine, but was very overpriced. This just tasted like "typical" pizza, but at a premium. Definitelt won't be back, unfortunately.
Pizza is great if you can get it, but they're NEVER open. If you're permanently closed, update your listing. If your hours changed, update your listing.
Love this pizza. IMO, it's better than Giordano's. Slightly different style, but by far the best deep dish you can get in NKY. However, that's only when they answer the phone. I've called randomly throughout the day during open hours on various days and no response. Had to go elsewhere.
Would love to leave a review. It's 6:42 on Saturday and they won't answer the phone.
Wonderful service, and even better food. Cheesy garlic drips smelled so good I couldn’t resist myself once I sat them in the car to take home. And the G.O.A.T. Pizza … has that name for good reason. Thank you Poseidon Pizza for making our life easier on where to get good pizza from.
Great food, however, I really wish they would give a bit more sauce with their breadsticks and Garlic knots. The cups are really small, and are unable to hold enough for the amount of food provided.
Would LOVE to be able to leave a real review but the Cold Spring location NEVER ANSWERS THEIR PHONE during business hours and do not have online ordering. This is the 3rd time we've tried to order from here and cannot get anyone to answer. Do better.Aaaand online shows they are open at 12 today. Not 4.
Tried Poseidon's Pizza for the first time last week in Cold Spring, KY and it was some of the best pizza I have ever had! Amazing! Can't wait to go back this week!
First time ever trying this place out and I'm sold. Looks alone had my mouth watering. The pineapples were so sweet and juicy (which I've never had.) The garlic knots were delicious and the in-house sauce and ranch was just unreal. Thank you so much! Will be back for sure!
Caleb makes an amazing pizza! Perfect with every bite. 5/5 definitely recommend Poseidon's on 27. Great staff and better food!
Pizza was just fantastic! The crust was cooked perfectly and the toppings were delicious. They actually cooked the pizza for take out instead of just throwing something in a box just to fill the order.We ordered breadsticks (note: I never eat breadsticks) and they were super great. So fresh and plump like homemade bread from an Italian kitchen.We’ve been looking for a new go to pizza place and this is it!!! We will be back!! Thank you for putting the extra CARE in take out. It matters.
Restaurantji Recommends
Fast delivery and best pizza in the area!!! I think the owner is Veteran so support you local veteran small business owners(photo is the medium hand tossed veggie modified and also asked to bake well so if it looks overcooked its because I specifically requested a well done pizza) the ordering process is easy although the product photos/ website design and overall marketing delivery would boost this already fantastic business to the level of National competiors in the area having to compete! (shameless plug if you need to hire a marketing company or product photographer)
Great deep dish and specialty pizza. Wish they had good salads or other whole food plant based additions.
Pizza was awesome. Had the deep dish. One of the best ever ate.. Will definitely be back..
The pizza is warm and tastes great every time we have ordered, but it's difficult to give it five stars. We've ordered carry out a handful of successful times, but when it comes to delivery, they are lacking. 3 of 3 delivery experiences were delivered 1.5-2 hours later. The most recent was not only late, but the pizza was wrong: toppings, crust, and size all wrong. It's a shame because it's five minutes from the house and everyone there seems friendly. Hopefully they improve their consistency and delivery times going forward!
Was hopeful, but mediocre at best. The pizza tasted fine, but was very overpriced. This just tasted like "typical" pizza, but at a premium. Definitelt won't be back, unfortunately.