Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street
110 N Mill St, Lexington
(859) 281-1101
Customers' Favorites
Bottelo Chicken Cheese Bread
Pepperoni and Mushroom
Extra Large Breadstick
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Lunch Specialty Slice
My Combination Pizza
Craft Your Own Pizza
New York Style Pizza
The Vinny Pizza
Mill Street
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Have been wanting to try Goodfellas ever since I started coming to Lexington annually. I stopped by around 2:00 pm on a Saturday, so there was no wait. I bought two slices; one chicken bacon and one pepperoni. Honestly I found them disappointing. The cheese was overly chewy and rubbery, and both pieces were fairly dry. The chicken bacon aldo didn't taste particularly fresh. The young lady working the counter was very nice.
This place is amazing! You can buy by the slice or get a whole pie. We walked in as they were pulling a fresh one out of the oven. My husband and I both had a slice of Hawaiian and the pizza was so good we went back for another slice of just cheese but was equally as good! Fresh ingredients and seeing the one guy flipping the dough in the air was the best experience. Great guys working there and you can tell they love what they do. Thank you so much for the amazing pizza!
This pizza has to be one of the best I’ve had. The crust is the perfect amount of chewy with crusty. The sauce has the best flavor and the pepperoni was spot on with spice. 100% satisfied.
You May Also Like
The Rosebud Bar - 121 N Mill St
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar, Lounges
Stagger Inn - 269 W Main St #50
![]()
Bar, Country Dance Halls, Music Venues
Jimmy John's - 105 N Mill St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food