If only Brooklyn Pizza would have the courtesy to update its website, and let customers know they are CLOSED at the Keithshire location! Our group of friends were semi-regulars, but are greatly disappointed by the thoughtless lack of communication.
jksmall
I really want to like this place...it's in my hood. If there are more than 5 customers, trying to get a slice and a beer is an impossible task. They have no concept of what a "slice pie" is and they freak out when they actually have customers. These guys need to spend 10 minutes in Famous Ray's in Verona, NJ and find out what serving slices is all about. Brooklyn Brothers in Corbin,KY is far better.
Carol G
I'm born and raised in New York City and if there is something New Yorkers know is pizza! Now they say it's authentic NY pizza it's not cause all New Yorkers know the reason our pizza is the best it's in the WADA (water) for everyone else. With that being said they have huge slices and you know you have a good slice when you fold it and the oil drips down your arm. Garlic knots, mozzarella sticks are really good! I do like the fact you are getting fresh ingredients. The wait time is worth it cause you will get quality. It is the best pizza joint here in Kentucky.
cooleylicious
This is a dirty little dive bar that you'll grow to love. The appetizers were surprisingly tasty, but the pizza was bad. They ran out of tap beer pretty often and the locals don't necessarily favor visitors. A group of 15 of us had a blast playing trivia and laughing with the staff. Bring a buddy and have a beer.
SEKYTravlin
We stopped in last night to try it for the first time. We waited about 10 minutes at the host stand on a slow night without anyone saying anything to us. Eventually the waitress finally came up and apologized and got us seated. She also said she was the only one working minus the bartender in terms of servers. We were then seated and given our menus. My wife and I ordered a large pizza and waited about 45 minutes to get it. I was shocked given that there were maybe only 7 other tables being occupied plus the bar. It wouldn't have hurt for the bartender to have helped her out as she was obviously struggling, but he looked to be laughing with the Keno players. When the pizza finally came out it was covered in grease. My wife and I don't mind a greasy pizza, but good grief. After wiping the excess grease off, the taste was good and the crust was crisp. I would return to give it another try, but the customer service needs a tweak. The waitress apologized unprompted at the end of the meal for not checking on us much and letting the drinks run out and said that she was totally overwhelmed. I told her not to worry about it and that I understood she was trying.
Preacherswife502
Ordered some pizzas for our office for lunch and was blown away by the size of the pizzas. We chose a few different varieties and enjoyed them all !
lamphinhome
We make them big here! So glad to hear you enjoyed your experience. Come back and see us!
Heather N
Our large family came for dinner and loved the experience. The oversized pizza was perfect for the teens and we adults loved our strombolis. Lots of choices on the menu, fantastic. Thanks!
dreamteamsvc
I have gone to Brooklyn Pizza for a long time and I don't know what is going on but evidently they are under new management. I ordered food it came out uncooked and cold. The bar tender was too busy eating her food at the bar. I waited over 45 minutes for food even though there was not very many people in the restaurant. It looked like the managers were setting at the bar. The server ask if I wanted to reorder and I said no. If this is how the new management is going to run this restaurant I would have to say go somewhere else..
Taste Good.
If only Brooklyn Pizza would have the courtesy to update its website, and let customers know they are CLOSED at the Keithshire location! Our group of friends were semi-regulars, but are greatly disappointed by the thoughtless lack of communication.
I really want to like this place...it's in my hood. If there are more than 5 customers, trying to get a slice and a beer is an impossible task. They have no concept of what a "slice pie" is and they freak out when they actually have customers. These guys need to spend 10 minutes in Famous Ray's in Verona, NJ and find out what serving slices is all about. Brooklyn Brothers in Corbin,KY is far better.
I'm born and raised in New York City and if there is something New Yorkers know is pizza! Now they say it's authentic NY pizza it's not cause all New Yorkers know the reason our pizza is the best it's in the WADA (water) for everyone else. With that being said they have huge slices and you know you have a good slice when you fold it and the oil drips down your arm. Garlic knots, mozzarella sticks are really good! I do like the fact you are getting fresh ingredients. The wait time is worth it cause you will get quality. It is the best pizza joint here in Kentucky.
This is a dirty little dive bar that you'll grow to love. The appetizers were surprisingly tasty, but the pizza was bad. They ran out of tap beer pretty often and the locals don't necessarily favor visitors. A group of 15 of us had a blast playing trivia and laughing with the staff. Bring a buddy and have a beer.
We stopped in last night to try it for the first time. We waited about 10 minutes at the host stand on a slow night without anyone saying anything to us. Eventually the waitress finally came up and apologized and got us seated. She also said she was the only one working minus the bartender in terms of servers. We were then seated and given our menus. My wife and I ordered a large pizza and waited about 45 minutes to get it. I was shocked given that there were maybe only 7 other tables being occupied plus the bar. It wouldn't have hurt for the bartender to have helped her out as she was obviously struggling, but he looked to be laughing with the Keno players. When the pizza finally came out it was covered in grease. My wife and I don't mind a greasy pizza, but good grief. After wiping the excess grease off, the taste was good and the crust was crisp. I would return to give it another try, but the customer service needs a tweak. The waitress apologized unprompted at the end of the meal for not checking on us much and letting the drinks run out and said that she was totally overwhelmed. I told her not to worry about it and that I understood she was trying.
Ordered some pizzas for our office for lunch and was blown away by the size of the pizzas. We chose a few different varieties and enjoyed them all !
We make them big here! So glad to hear you enjoyed your experience. Come back and see us!
Our large family came for dinner and loved the experience. The oversized pizza was perfect for the teens and we adults loved our strombolis. Lots of choices on the menu, fantastic. Thanks!
I have gone to Brooklyn Pizza for a long time and I don't know what is going on but evidently they are under new management. I ordered food it came out uncooked and cold. The bar tender was too busy eating her food at the bar. I waited over 45 minutes for food even though there was not very many people in the restaurant. It looked like the managers were setting at the bar. The server ask if I wanted to reorder and I said no. If this is how the new management is going to run this restaurant I would have to say go somewhere else..
Restaurantji Recommends