Pie Five Pizza

3401 Nicholasville Rd Ste F-616, Lexington
(859) 271-6839

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza Special Promo
Build Your Own - Up to 5 Toppings
5 Star 11 Personal Pizza Combo
10 Count Boneless
Pepperoni Pizza
Cinnamon Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
High Five Pizza
Cheese Pizza

Menu

Featured items
Build Your Own Pizza (Special Promo)
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and up to 5 toppings.
Coke
20 oz bottle
Cinnamon Sticks
The name says it all. Our freshly baked breadstix topped with cinnamon, sugar and drizzled with icing.You'll want to eat the whole thing! That's okay, do it!
Build Your Own - Up to 5 Toppings
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and up to 5 toppings.
Cheesy Breadstix
Our standard breadstix just got cheesy! Each one is topped with plenty of mozzarella cheese that will melt in your mouth. 7 inch.
Garlic Butter Breadstix
Our classic pan pizza dough baked to perfection and topped with savory garlic butter & our special magic dust. 7 inch.
Sprite
20 oz bottle
Bacon Cheesy Breadstix
We took our cheesy breadstix to the next level and added savory pieces of bacon on top. You're welcome. 7 inch.
Build Your Own - Whatever I Want (unlimited toppings)
Uniquely yours! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want.
Coke Zero
20 oz bottle
Half Italian
premium chicken / romaine / green peppers / red onions / banana peppers / tomatoes / pepperoni / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella / shredded parmesan / balsamic drizzle / red wine vinaigrette
Diet Coke
20 oz bottle
NEW Parmesan Caesar
premium chicken / romaine / shaved parmesan / croutons / caesar dressing
NEW Half Parmesan Caesar
premium chicken / romaine / shaved parmesan / croutons / caesar dressing
NEW Gaucho Steak
Rustic flavors born in the La Pampa grass-lands and beloved as sandwiches on the streets of Argentina make up this little steak-centric piece of heaven[ marinated steak / mozzarella / roasted red peppers / parmesan / red onion / mushrooms/ tomatoes / fresh basil / lawry's casero seasoning / olive oil & garlic / parsley ]
NEW Apple Pecan
premium chicken / spring mix / candied pecans / dried apple crisps / blue cheese crumbles / tomatoes / red onions / cucumber / white balsamic vinaigrette
NEW Half Apple Pecan
premium chicken / spring mix / candied pecans / dried apple crisps / blue cheese crumbles / tomatoes / red onions / cucumber / white balsamic vinaigrette
NEW Mike's Sticky Fingers
spicy marinara / mozzarella / pepperoni / curl and crisp pepperoni / fresh basil / Mike's Hot Honey®
NEW Not Your Father's Veggie
Step aside pops, the new school veggie pizza isn't for the blue-haired crowd. It's made with pineapple, fresh jalapeno slices & lawry's casero seasoning.[ tuscan marinara / mozzarella / feta / green peppers / red onions / mushrooms / roasted red peppers / pineapple / tomatoes / fresh jalapeno slices / lawry's casero seasoning / fresh basil ]
High Five-Meat
tuscan marinara / mozzarella / pepperoni / italian sausage / bacon / Canadian bacon / beef

Buy 3 Pizzas, Get 4th Pizza FREE
Free 4th All
Buy 3 personal pizzas, get the 4th pizza FREE (offer valid for only personal pizzas in this group)

Personal
Build Your Own Pizza (Special Promo)
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and up to 5 toppings.
Cheese Pizza
signature flavor combination of crust / sauce / mozzarella
High Five-Meat
tuscan marinara / mozzarella / pepperoni / italian sausage / bacon / Canadian bacon / beef
NEW Old World Maggie
Named after our longest standing employee, this old school margherita boasts fresh mozzarella, olive oil, grape tomatoes, and fresh basil[ fresh mozzarella / tuscan marinara / olive oil / tomatoes / parmesan / fresh basil ]
NEW Mike's Sticky Fingers
spicy marinara / mozzarella / pepperoni / curl and crisp pepperoni / fresh basil / Mike's Hot Honey®
NEW Gaucho Steak
Rustic flavors born in the La Pampa grass-lands and beloved as sandwiches on the streets of Argentina make up this little steak-centric piece of heaven[ marinated steak / mozzarella / roasted red peppers / parmesan / red onion / mushrooms/ tomatoes / fresh basil / lawry's casero seasoning / olive oil & garlic / parsley ]
NEW Five-Alarm Fire
Brace yourself for our signature inferno sauce - a blistering blend of yellowbird ghost pepper sauce & mike's hot honey - and marinated inferno sausage.[ signature inferno sauce with mike's hot honey / ghost pepper marinated italian sausage / curl & crisp pepperoni / mozzarella / fresh jalapeno slices / red onions / tomatoes ]
NEW Not Your Father's Veggie
Step aside pops, the new school veggie pizza isn't for the blue-haired crowd. It's made with pineapple, fresh jalapeno slices & lawry's casero seasoning.[ tuscan marinara / mozzarella / feta / green peppers / red onions / mushrooms / roasted red peppers / pineapple / tomatoes / fresh jalapeno slices / lawry's casero seasoning / fresh basil ]
Build Your Own - Up to 5 Toppings
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and up to 5 toppings.
NEW Tandoori Feather
Birds of a feather - chickens, actually - get marinated in yogurt & eastern spices, grilled, and joined by spicy marinara & feta on this indian delight[ tandoori chicken / spicy marinara / mozzarella / green peppers / red onions / feta / cilantro / yogurt drizzle ]
Athenian
olive oil / mozzarella / feta / grilled chicken / minced garlic / banana peppers / red onions / basil / kalamata olives / sun-dried tomato purée
Five Star
tuscan marinara / mozzarella / italian sausage / pepperoni / beef / green olives / red & green peppers / black olives / red onions
Build Your Own - Whatever I Want (unlimited toppings)
Uniquely yours! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want.

The Win-Win
The Win-Win
7" pizza + half salad

Kids
Kids Pizza Bundle
Kids 2-topping pizza + dessert + kid's drink

Secret Menu
Pesto Chicken Alfredo
alfredo sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / chicken / red onions / tomatoes / basil pesto drizzle
BBQ Chicken
bbq sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / chicken / red onions / chopped cilantro
Maui Wowwi
bbq sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / Canadian bacon / bacon / red onions / pineapple / chopped cilantro
Chicken Carbonara
alfredo sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / parmesan cheese / chicken / bacon / mushrooms / crushed red peppers

Salads
Italian
premium chicken / romaine / green peppers / red onions / banana peppers / tomatoes / pepperoni / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella / shredded parmesan / balsamic drizzle / red wine vinaigrette
Half Italian
premium chicken / romaine / green peppers / red onions / banana peppers / tomatoes / pepperoni / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella / shredded parmesan / balsamic drizzle / red wine vinaigrette
NEW Half Apple Pecan
premium chicken / spring mix / candied pecans / dried apple crisps / blue cheese crumbles / tomatoes / red onions / cucumber / white balsamic vinaigrette
NEW Apple Pecan
premium chicken / spring mix / candied pecans / dried apple crisps / blue cheese crumbles / tomatoes / red onions / cucumber / white balsamic vinaigrette
NEW Half Parmesan Caesar
premium chicken / romaine / shaved parmesan / croutons / caesar dressing
NEW Parmesan Caesar
premium chicken / romaine / shaved parmesan / croutons / caesar dressing

Breadstix
Garlic Butter Breadstix
Our classic pan pizza dough baked to perfection and topped with savory garlic butter & our special magic dust. 7 inch.
Cheesy Breadstix
Our standard breadstix just got cheesy! Each one is topped with plenty of mozzarella cheese that will melt in your mouth. 7 inch.
Bacon Cheesy Breadstix
We took our cheesy breadstix to the next level and added savory pieces of bacon on top. You're welcome. 7 inch.

Sides
Side of Magic Butter
Side of Ranch
Side of Garlic Butter
Side of Spicy Marinara
Side of Marinara
Side of BBQ Sauce
Side of Jalapeños
Side of Mike's Hot Honey
Side of Basil Pesto
Side of Sun Dried Tomato Puree

Sweets
Cinnamon Sticks
The name says it all. Our freshly baked breadstix topped with cinnamon, sugar and drizzled with icing.You'll want to eat the whole thing! That's okay, do it!

Drinks
Sprite
20 oz bottle
Coke
20 oz bottle
Coke Zero
20 oz bottle
Diet Coke
20 oz bottle
Bottled Water
16 oz bottle

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+67 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+66 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Came for pizza week. Had the BBQ pizza. It was good. Thumbs up. My friend had the street corn pizza. The tajin was laid on WAY to thick to the point it ruined the pizza for her.
September 2025
am very pocky with my Pizza & cheese. the thickness was good for me. the sauce is delicious & variation of pizzas is very good. you can order bigger pizzas for catering. i will be visiting more often! the staff is making a lot of effort to make people happy!
May 2025
Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free crust to choose from. You don't have to settle for just the cardboard stuff.

Parking: It is located with an entrance both outside and inside the mall so parking is shared with the mall.

Kid-friendliness: High chairs available.
July 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Chipotle Mexican Grill - 3565 Nicholasville Rd
Mexican, Fast Food, Vegan
Mileta - 3565 Nicholasville Rd Suite 932
Seafood, Cocktail Bar
Auntie Anne's - Mall, 3401 Nicholasville Rd
Pretzel Store, Pretzels, Fast Food

Pie Five Pizza

3401 Nicholasville Rd Ste F-616, Lexington, KY 40503
(859) 271-6839