Home of the Best Pizza and Stromboli Around! A must-visit spot while you’re in New Haven—authentic flavor, unbeatable quality, and a local favorite for a reason. Don’t miss it.
Madeline Perry Cordrey
Some of the best pizza that we’ve ever had! Super nice owner too.
Natasha Henderson
We’ve had several folks recommend New Haven Pizza Shop and decided to give it a try today. Let me tell you, we’ve eaten pizza all over the United States and New Haven, KY has a real gem of a pizza place. Was the best pizza we’ve had. The sauce was something else; exceptional flavor. And that first bite had me sold on the quality. Nice crunch from his homemade dough…perfection. We will definitely go back for more.
Elizabeth A
Excellent pizza and Blane is a cool
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie Ann Ball
If you are looking to sink your teeth into incredible handmade artisan pizza you have come to the right place! We were told to come and sample the “Pizza Man’s” wares and we were so glad we did!
Shout out to Blane! You are that good at your craft!
Take our advice and make the trek to New Haven Pizza Shop… you’ll be so glad you did!
Don Johnston
My wife, granddaughter and I found this gem after a historic train jaunt several weeks ago. We still talk about our time there. The owner told us it would be the best pizza we ever had and it was phenomenal. Loved our time chatting with him, too!
Marsha Barr Thornton
We tried Blane’s original recipe of bacon, cranberry, and red pepper pizza. Delicious! We got a small because we weren’t sure about it, but now wish we had gotten it larger. Amazingly good food and good conversation from a wonderful person!
Ethan Davis
We were at the rail museum next door and decided to grab some pizza and calzones for a snack. Food was great! Everything had amazing flavor, the owner gave us a rundown of the menu and the many creative pizza combinations he offered, a genuinely nice guy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
michael crowe
Food was stellar with lots of flavor and service to match great experience all around.
Kid-friendliness: Owner makes kids feel welcome and caters to them giving them a great experience.
Today my family visited the Train museum across the way. We were walking around the train yard outside of the museum and I kept catching an amazing smell of pizza. Once we left the museum I saw the pizza shop right up the street and had to stop. I've never had such a cool and unique dining experience. It really topped our day! Would visit again ?
Kid-friendliness: My son loved the old car magazines and loved the owners singing and funny noises
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Bread W
Kaitlyn Nichelle Bond
Amazing pizza! Highly recommend
Chrissy Lally
We were in New Haven for the Santa Express Ride and decided to eat here based on the reviews. At first we were hesitant. But we decided to come in and take a seat. What a friendly, and hard-working man! Do not turn around when you enter. You would be making a mistake. The pizza and cheese sticks aredelicious! The kids loved it, too! They are quite picky. I actually feel like going there uplifted my spirits. I think you should go in and try it out. You won’t regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Cambron
Best pizza EVER!!!! SERVICE WAS GREAT ALONG WITH THE BEST STORYTIME!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
Brian Packard
Terrific made from scratch pizza and calzones, yummy garlic bread w/cheese and sauce for dipping. This is the definition of hole-in-the-wall local dining, which we love. You actually enter through the kitchen, which is also where you pay. The owner, Blane is a fun free-spirited person who loves what he does, and loves singing along to music. He is a hard working one-man-show.
Best tasting pizza around for the price and size!
Home of the Best Pizza and Stromboli Around! A must-visit spot while you’re in New Haven—authentic flavor, unbeatable quality, and a local favorite for a reason. Don’t miss it.
Some of the best pizza that we’ve ever had! Super nice owner too.
We’ve had several folks recommend New Haven Pizza Shop and decided to give it a try today. Let me tell you, we’ve eaten pizza all over the United States and New Haven, KY has a real gem of a pizza place. Was the best pizza we’ve had. The sauce was something else; exceptional flavor. And that first bite had me sold on the quality. Nice crunch from his homemade dough…perfection. We will definitely go back for more.
Excellent pizza and Blane is a cool
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you are looking to sink your teeth into incredible handmade artisan pizza you have come to the right place! We were told to come and sample the “Pizza Man’s” wares and we were so glad we did! Shout out to Blane! You are that good at your craft! Take our advice and make the trek to New Haven Pizza Shop… you’ll be so glad you did!
My wife, granddaughter and I found this gem after a historic train jaunt several weeks ago. We still talk about our time there. The owner told us it would be the best pizza we ever had and it was phenomenal. Loved our time chatting with him, too!
We tried Blane’s original recipe of bacon, cranberry, and red pepper pizza. Delicious! We got a small because we weren’t sure about it, but now wish we had gotten it larger. Amazingly good food and good conversation from a wonderful person!
We were at the rail museum next door and decided to grab some pizza and calzones for a snack. Food was great! Everything had amazing flavor, the owner gave us a rundown of the menu and the many creative pizza combinations he offered, a genuinely nice guy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was stellar with lots of flavor and service to match great experience all around.
Kid-friendliness: Owner makes kids feel welcome and caters to them giving them a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Today my family visited the Train museum across the way. We were walking around the train yard outside of the museum and I kept catching an amazing smell of pizza. Once we left the museum I saw the pizza shop right up the street and had to stop. I've never had such a cool and unique dining experience. It really topped our day! Would visit again ?
Kid-friendliness: My son loved the old car magazines and loved the owners singing and funny noises
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Bread W
Amazing pizza! Highly recommend
We were in New Haven for the Santa Express Ride and decided to eat here based on the reviews. At first we were hesitant. But we decided to come in and take a seat. What a friendly, and hard-working man! Do not turn around when you enter. You would be making a mistake. The pizza and cheese sticks aredelicious! The kids loved it, too! They are quite picky. I actually feel like going there uplifted my spirits. I think you should go in and try it out. You won’t regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza EVER!!!! SERVICE WAS GREAT ALONG WITH THE BEST STORYTIME!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
Terrific made from scratch pizza and calzones, yummy garlic bread w/cheese and sauce for dipping. This is the definition of hole-in-the-wall local dining, which we love. You actually enter through the kitchen, which is also where you pay. The owner, Blane is a fun free-spirited person who loves what he does, and loves singing along to music. He is a hard working one-man-show.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...