New Haven's Pizza Shoppe
137 S Main St, New Haven
(502) 549-3000
Customers' Favorites
Medium Calzone
Pizza Bread W
Meat Lovers
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Home of the Best Pizza and Stromboli Around! A must-visit spot while you’re in New Haven—authentic flavor, unbeatable quality, and a local favorite for a reason. Don’t miss it.
We’ve had several folks recommend New Haven Pizza Shop and decided to give it a try today. Let me tell you, we’ve eaten pizza all over the United States and New Haven, KY has a real gem of a pizza place. Was the best pizza we’ve had. The sauce was something else; exceptional flavor. And that first bite had me sold on the quality. Nice crunch from his homemade dough…perfection. We will definitely go back for more.
If you are looking to sink your teeth into incredible handmade artisan pizza you have come to the right place! We were told to come and sample the “Pizza Man’s” wares and we were so glad we did!
Shout out to Blane! You are that good at your craft!
Take our advice and make the trek to New Haven Pizza Shop… you’ll be so glad you did!
You May Also Like
longbranch saloon - 135 S Main St
![]()
Bar, Bar & Grill
Smoke Show Barbecue - 127 S Main St
![]()
Family, American, Barbecue
Log Still Distillery - 225 Dee Head Rd
![]()
Distilleries