Stuffed! Potatoes & Poboys

1801 Nashville Ave, Hammond
(985) 402-3021

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eric Imdieke

If you are wondering if you should ever check this place out, ask yourself these three questions.
1. Do you like potatoes and/or poboys?
2. Do you like being hungry?
3. Do you like affordability?

If you answered yes to #1 great they have so many great and unique options to choose from! If you answered no to #2, that's great because this place will leave you Stuffed! for sure after your done. The experience made me a couch potato! Haha. The best part is if you answered yes to #3, then you gotta check them out! For everything you get, you will still have enough left over to get some dessert. So grab your keys and start heading their way!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Mac

Faye

Everything on the menu sounded delicious but I could only choose one! I will definitely be back to try more. A friend and I stopped by extremely hungry and they did not fail us. I chose the seafood potato and I just don’t have any words that would do the flavor any justice! Just know that if you choose to stop by, you will not be disappointed! The service was outstanding. Our server gave genuine, friendly and attentive service.❤️ DELICIOUS!!!

Kid-friendliness: Atmosphere and great kids menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Williams

Man this place just rocks. Large portions. Fair pricing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim Johnson

This is a fairly new restaurant in the area. We figured we'd give it a try. Started off with an appetizer of stuffed boudin egg rolls. They were good but be aware they are fairly spicy. Aunt, the wife and I split a meatball stuffed baked potato. It was okay. Could have used a little more marinara sauce on it. We walked out with leftovers so plenty of food. Service was fine. A little slower than I thought it would be for a baked potato place. But otherwise it was okay.

Parking: The parking lot is very dark at night.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Danielle Trahan

Everytime we have gone here something is either messed up or one time even bad as in expired or something. The roast beef poboy was so gross it had to be bad. And twice I've gotten a potato and some toppings were missing . They gladly fixed it the first time. But the second time the girl looked at me like really! You are coming back bc it's missing the brown sugar that goes all over the top. It was a to go. That sugar makes it taste different. And for the prices you pay for those bc it's really pricey I expect it to be right. Who wouldn't. It was absolutely delicious the very first time we ate there I got the same sweet potato dream but since then it's never been done the same way at all so don't know if I'll be going back. That dish is the only reason I go in the first place but if I'm gonna pay that and it doesn't even taste good anymore I'll have no choice. Bc lately I can make that kind of sweet potato at home.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Jasmine Mouhot

Let me start by saying the staff was friendly and this review is to no fault of them. Also as a veteran of 10 plus years in the service industry i can count on one hand how many times I've sent food back.
First and last time there.
First time experience as follows:

I get there after dreaming about trying this place for the first time after my shift. I already know what I want and I'm starving. I promptly order my sandwich and egg rolls Togo. With in 15mins food was out and ready .
I excitedly took the bag and went on my way. I went and sat down in my car to eat. I opened the egg rolls first. Those bad boys had the right amount of crunch. Unfortunately no sauce? A BBQ sauce would have completed these so well.

Now on to the sandwich. Throw the breaks. It's not a sandwich. It's a potato. So I bring it back and tell the fella behind the counter it was supposed to be a sandwich. He shrugged and said it doesn't come that way. I was taken back and thought maybe I misread the menu and took my potato and left. So I get back to my house and sit down to eat . It's too salty and I was so disappointed cause I had my mouth set for a sandwich. So with a hard nudge from my sister I took it back to the restaurant. I pulled up the online menus on the resturant page. I show where it infact was a sandwich at one point.
The boy from behind the counter called someone else over. I talk to the new server who calls for a manager. I show the online menu to her and she apologized.The manager promptly brings it to the back to fix it after telling me since it's on there she will fix it but if I love it, it will be the only one I get cause they don't offer it anymore. That's fine . So I go outside to sit and wait. Counter boy comes out and offers me a drink and I say no . He responded " but it's freee" I say " I'm good I got a coke in the car. A cheesecake would be cool tho"
Shortly after that the manager comes out with my sandwich and I thank her and go on my way. At this point I've lost my appetite and don't even want it. Maybe I'll revisit it for dinner. What a disappointing first impression.

Ps. No cheesecake in the bag either.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Carolyn Warden

We shared a roast beef poboy. We enjoyed it, and it was overstuffed with meat. We'll be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lakesha Johnson

I love this place. I have never been disappointed. Only thing is sometimes they do sell out of certain food and the potatoes did change a bit. Overall the food is good and they are quick. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sampler Platter

Walter Austin

I am a very picky person when it comes to food. I couldn't find anything to be picky about here. The food was fantastic, the service was friendly, and the portions were huge. 10/10 highly recommend it. I got the double trouble stuffed potato, and the pulled pork on it was just melt in your mouth tender. I 100% plan on going again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Brown

Food and service was excellent! I really enjoyed the seafood potato.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erika Calcagno

The family and I came in for the first time tonight for dinner. We were greeted by such friendly staff! We were seated right away, the staff member who sat us came back to our table and gave our son a piece of candy. Our waitress, Rhianna was wonderful and attentive. She gave us great food recommendations as first timers and made sure to include our 9 year old in conversation. I had the crawdaddy potato and it was huge, delicious, and cooked to perfection. I just cannot say enough good things about this place. Our son told us tonight that this is his new favorite restaurant. We will be back next week to celebrate his birthday here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shannon Mckenzie

I eat out as an incentive. This has always been my choice since I've found them. Seriously I only eat here and raising Cane's and at home. I have NOTHING negative to say about this place from food to employees. And this isn't a " fake hype " comment. I didn't even wanna share this gem with the world but they just so great and the food is definitely made with love. Which is very important!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cj Dimarco

Had the seafood potato and it was delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Hicks

I ordered a seafood potato. The potato looked delicious, but It seemed to be extremely salty! Almost as if the lid came off the salt shaker!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Tareh Gann

Potatoes are

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...