We stumbled on Orange Peel for one of their BBQ nights, and wow was it delicious!! Exceptional ribs and sides, and a biscuit that stole the show. Really friendly service, too. Happy to support this small business and siked to see them thrive!
Eric F
Stopped by a couple days ago… I was looking for a sourdough to accompany a mussel dinner. They, unfortunately didn’t have any. Owner took our number and said she’d call when she baked again and her starter would be ready… Well, she called last night and we picked it up this morning. Absolutely fantastic experience… Thank you for all the help 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Nathaniel Roe
Stopped by here on a bike ride out too Aquinnah Cliffs and would definitely recommend...just make sure you have cell service!
Bruce Borden
I bought an activated charcoal sourdough loaf. Literally black bread it was so cool I've never seen that before and so good. Also a pain raisin right out of the outdoor wood oven. Awesome experience to find on a scooter ride
Vecky Hernandez
We stopped by here once to check it out. Its is a bakery stand that relies on the honor system. There was lots of sweet and some savory baked goods options. It is cash or venmo only so if you have spotty cell service take cash so you don’t walk away empty handed like we did!
We came back on Thursday night for the wood oven pizza. We came during the off season (late June) and we were the only other pair of people there from 6-8pm. $35 per person, considering MV prices is not unreasonable. They provide a cheese pizza and some pizza toppings, we did not know this and brought all sorts of toppings. They asked us for every pizza we create to leave half and share with others to help create community! We brought our own wine and they had paper cups so if you prefer to have a nicer glass bring your own! They had lots of seating to enjoy your pizza and red wine (if you bring it yourself!)
Overall, if you are staying near by you should be stopping by every other day. If you’re in Vineyard Haven, Edgartown or Oak Bluffs, please make the trip down to eat some wood fire oven pizza and take some baked goods for the road!
Glen Vick
If you are ever in Martha's Vineyard, take an excursion to Aqiunnah Massachusetts. You must visit the Cliffs and stop by Orange Peel for the pizza and her baked goods.
Erica Milkovich-Padilla
One of the best kept secrets on MVY. This is a wonderful place to pick up delicious baked goods from a Wampanoag Indian Tribe member. I bring all my island guests to Orange Peel!
Traci Abbott
Adorable little self service shack on the west side of the island. We were there off season I imagine it gets a bit more lively when the pizza oven is going but I enjoyed my chocolate croissant and coffee!
My husband and I had the joy of stopping here and supporting this amazing Indigenously owned home bakery. the croissants were phenomenal, the feta, mushroom and fig was to die for. It's definitely a must stop if you're anywhere in the area.
Jonathan Rollo
Great home-baked goods with honor-system pricing. I have seen flies every few visits, but thankfully most of the goods are sealed or wrapped. I know from experience how hard it is to keep them away.
Parking: Parking is small but it’s usually not so busy that you cannot find a spot. There’s always the road
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Todd Margaret
Whoopie pie and cinnamon roll were pretty average. The roll was unusually dense and difficult to eat. Lower your expectations before coming here, the rave reviews are dubious.
Food: 3
Stephanie Klein Wassink
They are always open. This is one of the Vineyard’s hidden treasures.
Great bread and baked goods
We stumbled on Orange Peel for one of their BBQ nights, and wow was it delicious!! Exceptional ribs and sides, and a biscuit that stole the show. Really friendly service, too. Happy to support this small business and siked to see them thrive!
Stopped by a couple days ago… I was looking for a sourdough to accompany a mussel dinner. They, unfortunately didn’t have any. Owner took our number and said she’d call when she baked again and her starter would be ready… Well, she called last night and we picked it up this morning. Absolutely fantastic experience… Thank you for all the help 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Stopped by here on a bike ride out too Aquinnah Cliffs and would definitely recommend...just make sure you have cell service!
I bought an activated charcoal sourdough loaf. Literally black bread it was so cool I've never seen that before and so good. Also a pain raisin right out of the outdoor wood oven. Awesome experience to find on a scooter ride
We stopped by here once to check it out. Its is a bakery stand that relies on the honor system. There was lots of sweet and some savory baked goods options. It is cash or venmo only so if you have spotty cell service take cash so you don’t walk away empty handed like we did!
We came back on Thursday night for the wood oven pizza. We came during the off season (late June) and we were the only other pair of people there from 6-8pm. $35 per person, considering MV prices is not unreasonable. They provide a cheese pizza and some pizza toppings, we did not know this and brought all sorts of toppings. They asked us for every pizza we create to leave half and share with others to help create community! We brought our own wine and they had paper cups so if you prefer to have a nicer glass bring your own! They had lots of seating to enjoy your pizza and red wine (if you bring it yourself!)
Overall, if you are staying near by you should be stopping by every other day. If you’re in Vineyard Haven, Edgartown or Oak Bluffs, please make the trip down to eat some wood fire oven pizza and take some baked goods for the road!
If you are ever in Martha's Vineyard, take an excursion to Aqiunnah Massachusetts. You must visit the Cliffs and stop by Orange Peel for the pizza and her baked goods.
One of the best kept secrets on MVY. This is a wonderful place to pick up delicious baked goods from a Wampanoag Indian Tribe member. I bring all my island guests to Orange Peel!
Adorable little self service shack on the west side of the island. We were there off season I imagine it gets a bit more lively when the pizza oven is going but I enjoyed my chocolate croissant and coffee!
Got some goodies a while ago. Great stop
Restaurantji Recommends
The cinnamon roll is incredible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I had the joy of stopping here and supporting this amazing Indigenously owned home bakery. the croissants were phenomenal, the feta, mushroom and fig was to die for. It's definitely a must stop if you're anywhere in the area.
Great home-baked goods with honor-system pricing. I have seen flies every few visits, but thankfully most of the goods are sealed or wrapped. I know from experience how hard it is to keep them away.
Parking: Parking is small but it’s usually not so busy that you cannot find a spot. There’s always the road
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Whoopie pie and cinnamon roll were pretty average. The roll was unusually dense and difficult to eat. Lower your expectations before coming here, the rave reviews are dubious.
Food: 3
They are always open. This is one of the Vineyard’s hidden treasures.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stone Oven
Loading...