Guapo's Tortilla Shack - Brewster

i've gone here every summer with family my whole life, it's one of the best mexican restaurants i've ever been too! everything is always perfect and absolutely delicious. i can't wait to come back!

Best fish tacos on the Cape!

Not sure what happened to this spot.As a kid I remember it having amazing food, unreal tortilla chips and good service. Went back this year and well, it's a bit of a disaster.Group of 10 ordered (separately) and half of us got a slightly wrong order. The food was "OKAY" but really was not what I had come to expect from Guapos.Saving grace was the frozen marg. That was amazing.

This has to be one of the worst “Mexican” places I’ve ever ate at. The food was bland, cold, unseasoned, you name it. Looked like a kid’s lunchable taco kit and it tasted like nothing. Ordered 2 small tacos and they weren’t even put together. Every topping was in those tiny 2oz plastic containers and to make it worse it was $20! Stopped here because it was on a bike path, but head my warning…DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE! I don’t usually leave poor reviews, but I genuinely feel ripped off. Went to a pizza place, and got a coal fired specialty pizza for $20. This place was not worth $20.

Need to sit outside but that's is a great place to be on a warm summer night like it was for us. We loved their fish tacos.

Nice spot to stop by for a quick bite if you're riding on the Cape Cod trail trail. The prices are reasonable and the food is pretty good. Definitely should try the fish tacos. The cheese quesadilla is also very good.

Incredible frozen margarita.

Although it took a while to get our order, it was understandable because it was packed. The parking lot was a bit insane - Taco Tuesday I guess. I had the Costa Rican which was supposed to come with cheese and sour cream but there were no traces of either but hey, fewer calories. I probably would have liked it better with the dairy. We also had a Costa Rican gluten free which was also mysteriously dairy free. The feedback on the Chicken Fajita Burrito was that it was “very good” and the tacos were very good. The guacamole and chips were fresh and very good although there was a bit too much lemon and they forgot to give us our chips so we had to go back to get them. Luckily, we only made as far as the parking lot. But word to the wise: check your order before you leave! Overall, very good just very busy!

The food is terrible. The food was store bought taco kits. Very disappointing.

We stayed in Cape Cod for five nights and we went to this place twice. Love their guac, frozen margaritas and crispy fish tacos. Staff was very nice too.

Best margarita I’ve ever had! Food was incredible too. Nice portion sizes. A little pricy but worth it for the convenient stop along the bike path. Looking forward to our next visit!

Best fish tacos ever! Family also had beef tacos, quesadillas, and a beef burrito. All very good. Somewhat complicated order/pick up to keep their limited staff safe but well worth the effort. Guapo's has been a great lunch/dinner stop (and takeout) for years and managed to continue their great run in this difficult summer (2021).

Amazing fish tacos and shredded beef tacos. Try the rice and beans, too!

Tastiest fish burritos ever. The other food is good as well. Nice choice of local beers. Every time we're on the Cape we definitely go there as much as we can.

I had the beef tacos, delicious and fresh. My son had the fish burrito and said it was the best he ever had. Great stop for lunch along the Cape Cod Rail Trail.