McMenamy Seafoods

I spent almost $100 on fisherman's platter and 1 pound of fried scallops
But what I got was ALL OVERCOOKED and dry.
I got the food home and shared it with my neighbor, we both got diarrhea from eating this
God awful seafood. I'm definitely never going back and will tell anyone who asks me for
My opinion on this so called seafood restaurant to avoid it at all costs.
Definitely not worth taking a chance with your health. If I could give it a Negative score?I would

I just love this place when that guy Danny is on the back. The food always comes out so fresh and perfect. Me and my wife go here at least once a week.

Visiting from Florida was told by a relative that lives here, that it was very good. And there's nothing short of the truth. It was absolutely fabulous, great selection. Great food, very good service. This is a must free one that's seeking good seafood.

Very good fried fish! Tried scallop basket.

Went here for lunch with a friend and it was pretty good! Will visit again

Oooofff. The clam chowder is not clam chowder. Looked and tasted like dirty water with chicken in it, no clam taste. Had one bite and immediately had to flush it down the toilet, non edible. The steamers smelled so foul, like they have been sitting in a garbage bin for a week, no I’m not exaggerating, had to immediately discard them in the garbage bin out by the road, thankfully it was trash night. Never again. I learned my lesson.

First and last time coming here!!! The food lacked seasoning and took 30 minutes to get and the order was wrong!!!! The lobster roll was suppose to be hot and came out cold and looked like immigration crab salad from Golden Corral. The “haddock” tasted like mud which means it was a freshwater fish and I am willing to bet it was nasty ass tilapia! The place was dead so there’s no excuse!!! Long John silvers is better than this dump!!! The tables and floors are also sticky and nasty and only one working toilet. This place is severely overpriced, their lobster roll is $34 and it’s around 6” long!!!! Pathetic!!!! I went to Tori Japan down the street to eat something good!!!

I feel that I was robbed for my hard earned money, $43 for a lobster plate and it was only a half a pound of lobster. I’ve been going to McMenamy’s for years, but will never go there again. The quality is horrible.

Parking: 20 parking spots

Wheelchair accessibility: Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish, Haddock

not the freshest seafood

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ordered haddock, was given a good piece and a piece of fried skin... paid 18dollars..
Its happen more than once.. I wanted to see if it would change

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Seafood

My husband and I literally been coming here for years but 2 days ago we always ordered the same thing fisherman platter I was so disappointed in the food fodder was dry, overcooked , French fries were soggy and the whole platter when we opened the box was a mess no favor and the girls were nasty, attitudes, no respect for the customers I’m feel sorry for the other people next to me bcuz them girls gave them a hard time and they were elderly couple SAD never recommend this place for anyone and they lost regular customers like us

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

This Restaurant Is Awesome For Fisherman's Platter. My Friend Bought 2 We Have Enough For 3 Days. Was Worth The Price.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood

Great food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Haddock, Seafood

I live in Missouri and was in town looking for some East Coast Sea food, and I chose this restaurant by their reviews and the fact of years in business. BUT it was very disappointing. The food had no flavor, and the calm chowder tasted like it came out of the can .I was disappointed and the cost was not worth the food! I would never go back or recommend this place.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1