The Brick Cellar is a quintessential Cape Cod bar. The artistry of the cocktails are reflective of the commitment to honoring the past while embracing the genius of the next generation. They never disappoint. Here’s to you and the joy you’ll experience from the first drink to the best burgers on the island.
Dietary restrictions: The staff is trained to offer guidance related to accommodations for dietary needs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terry Thomas
Whenever I visit Martha’s Vineyard, I do not miss an opportunity eat at The Brick Cellar. Last night did not disappoint. The atmosphere is the cellar of an old captain’s house, that gives a warm, cozy feel of coming in from a storm. The staff is welcoming, attentive and willing to entertain all requests for our group. As for the food, in my opinion they offer the best burger on the island. The Cellar offer the full menu so if you are looking for the amazing food offer upstairs at Atria in casual dining experience, I say go for it. If you find yourself on the Vineyard, do yourself a favor and visit The Brick Cellar restaurant, I always do.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evan O'Reilly
it was good. I loved the burger. Service was delightful. Ambiance was petite, but nonetheless endearing. Would recommend for anyone who loves a great night out on the town!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Richard L
We would definitely go back. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The food was delicious. The atmosphere was wonderful. Would have been five stars except that, like so many other businesses on the Island at this time of year, the restaurant was short-staffed and service suffered.
taraaitro
I’ve been coming to the island my whole life and my favorite restaurant has always been Atria. From the service to the food to the beautiful exterior and tent I’ve always loved it so it’s only fitting I had my wedding reception there! From the beginning Greer and Christian and her team were nothing but accommodating and kind to my family, husband, and I! The day was nothing less than perfect and will be forever grateful for making it one of the most special days of my life! Looking forward to visiting again soon, thank you so much Atria and Greer for everything!
Stephanie C
We are at Atria with our family of four, including two elementary aged kids. One is a vegetarian and sometimes it can be hard to find kid-vegetarian food on dinner menus. We took a chance on Atria and found out that there were kids options (pasta, burgers, Mac n Cheese) that weren’t publicized. Our kids enjoyed the swing in the yard more than the Mac n Cheese. We had the chickpea dish and chicken. Chicken got a five star review, chickpea dish was a little too salty for my palate. Sparking iced tea was delicious. Overall - a good experience.
mslcw07
This is our yearly go to restaurant when we visit Edgartown. It has a tasty unique menu and daily specials that never disappoint. The service is premier! Although pricy, it is worth it!
Mehrnaz V
We contacted Atria owner Greer T in late August 2022 about holding my daughter’s rehearsal dinner for her Wedding in September of 2023. She seemed quite enthusiastic and we met with her in person in May 5th of 2023. She reviewed information and we all agreed on all aspects of the dinner. A check was mailed to the address given my the wedding planner early May for deposit that was returned as it was sent to the actual restaurant. I emailed as well as my daughter and our Wedsing planner at minimum 16 times without a return call or email. When I reached out in end of June nervous about the check not being cashed and us not having heard from her or her staff and that I felt her lack of response was due to our ethnic background and just her micro aggression type attitude while we were there ans after and suggested that she google my background to assure her that I can meet the payment requirement, she contacted me saying she is sorry for lack of response, attached a contract to sign and. PO Box address to send the check and contract. Given that the address is to a PO Box we could not ask for a signed receipt (convenient way to reject clients). It is now third week of July, the wedding is 7 weeks away, we do not have confirmation of anything or a response despite numerous calls and emails. DO NOT HOLD YOUR EVENT at ATRIA unless you meet a certain subjective criteria that is acceptable to Greer and her team. Her behavior, Lack of communication and total irresponsible attitude is abhorrent and exemplary of prejudicial behavior I sensed but could not confirm during our meeting with her. I just expected different in the Vineyards having owned a home there for two decades. I will be reporting them to better business bureau as well.
Will Ellis-Adams
Amazing burger, great vibes, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trip13427875438
Limited menu with one vegetarian option. Overly formal vibe that left us cold. Once we had a chance to look over the menu and realize it wasn’t for us we said thank you - no thank you. On our way out were informed by the overly polite (unctuous) host that we would be charged $50 per person as a no- show! Pointing out that we were in fact there but not interested in what they were offering we still were unpersuasive! It was suggested that if we stayed for cocktails we could avoid the $200 charge! Needless to say we won’t ever be back and warn others that should you book in advance and guarantee with your card, you MUST eat dinner or at the very least have a cocktail in their basement bar!
I made a reservation in the Brick Cellar and was seated across from the Bar. The music was so loud to the point that we could not talk, we asked the waitress to lower the music and were told that she could not as we were seated at the bar. The service was slow, the burgers were cold, will definitely not be back.
SunnyDays27
We celebrated our anniversary at Atria and overall it was a good experience with a lovely atmosphere and good food. We had the fried lobster. However, I was disappointed that they did not acknowledge our anniversary in any aspect. I appreciate that extra special touch and personalization when celebrating a special occasion like many other restaurants do.
T. R. (Tàád Nazzty)
Always great. GET TO HERE! Getting tired of yelling. Just friggin' GO!
Laura Dubek
Good!Food. Great service and atmosphere!
NYscholar2
In an old house in Edgartown. I had only eaten there once before, and then down in the lower level. When a friend and I arrived for our reservation, we discovered a large noisy table nearby and asked to be moved, which the staff immediately accommodated. We shared a salad (enough for two). My friend had scallops and I had duck. Both were delicious and perfectly cooked. The desserts were yummy. Not cheap, but worth the money. (we had individual glasses of wine rather than a bottle, and started with cocktails.) The wait staff, young people from Eastern Europe, were delightful to talk to.
The Brick Cellar is a quintessential Cape Cod bar. The artistry of the cocktails are reflective of the commitment to honoring the past while embracing the genius of the next generation. They never disappoint. Here’s to you and the joy you’ll experience from the first drink to the best burgers on the island.
Dietary restrictions: The staff is trained to offer guidance related to accommodations for dietary needs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Whenever I visit Martha’s Vineyard, I do not miss an opportunity eat at The Brick Cellar. Last night did not disappoint. The atmosphere is the cellar of an old captain’s house, that gives a warm, cozy feel of coming in from a storm. The staff is welcoming, attentive and willing to entertain all requests for our group. As for the food, in my opinion they offer the best burger on the island. The Cellar offer the full menu so if you are looking for the amazing food offer upstairs at Atria in casual dining experience, I say go for it. If you find yourself on the Vineyard, do yourself a favor and visit The Brick Cellar restaurant, I always do.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
it was good. I loved the burger. Service was delightful. Ambiance was petite, but nonetheless endearing. Would recommend for anyone who loves a great night out on the town!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We would definitely go back. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The food was delicious. The atmosphere was wonderful. Would have been five stars except that, like so many other businesses on the Island at this time of year, the restaurant was short-staffed and service suffered.
I’ve been coming to the island my whole life and my favorite restaurant has always been Atria. From the service to the food to the beautiful exterior and tent I’ve always loved it so it’s only fitting I had my wedding reception there! From the beginning Greer and Christian and her team were nothing but accommodating and kind to my family, husband, and I! The day was nothing less than perfect and will be forever grateful for making it one of the most special days of my life! Looking forward to visiting again soon, thank you so much Atria and Greer for everything!
We are at Atria with our family of four, including two elementary aged kids. One is a vegetarian and sometimes it can be hard to find kid-vegetarian food on dinner menus. We took a chance on Atria and found out that there were kids options (pasta, burgers, Mac n Cheese) that weren’t publicized. Our kids enjoyed the swing in the yard more than the Mac n Cheese. We had the chickpea dish and chicken. Chicken got a five star review, chickpea dish was a little too salty for my palate. Sparking iced tea was delicious. Overall - a good experience.
This is our yearly go to restaurant when we visit Edgartown. It has a tasty unique menu and daily specials that never disappoint. The service is premier! Although pricy, it is worth it!
We contacted Atria owner Greer T in late August 2022 about holding my daughter’s rehearsal dinner for her Wedding in September of 2023. She seemed quite enthusiastic and we met with her in person in May 5th of 2023. She reviewed information and we all agreed on all aspects of the dinner. A check was mailed to the address given my the wedding planner early May for deposit that was returned as it was sent to the actual restaurant. I emailed as well as my daughter and our Wedsing planner at minimum 16 times without a return call or email. When I reached out in end of June nervous about the check not being cashed and us not having heard from her or her staff and that I felt her lack of response was due to our ethnic background and just her micro aggression type attitude while we were there ans after and suggested that she google my background to assure her that I can meet the payment requirement, she contacted me saying she is sorry for lack of response, attached a contract to sign and. PO Box address to send the check and contract. Given that the address is to a PO Box we could not ask for a signed receipt (convenient way to reject clients). It is now third week of July, the wedding is 7 weeks away, we do not have confirmation of anything or a response despite numerous calls and emails. DO NOT HOLD YOUR EVENT at ATRIA unless you meet a certain subjective criteria that is acceptable to Greer and her team. Her behavior, Lack of communication and total irresponsible attitude is abhorrent and exemplary of prejudicial behavior I sensed but could not confirm during our meeting with her. I just expected different in the Vineyards having owned a home there for two decades. I will be reporting them to better business bureau as well.
Amazing burger, great vibes, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Limited menu with one vegetarian option. Overly formal vibe that left us cold. Once we had a chance to look over the menu and realize it wasn’t for us we said thank you - no thank you. On our way out were informed by the overly polite (unctuous) host that we would be charged $50 per person as a no- show! Pointing out that we were in fact there but not interested in what they were offering we still were unpersuasive! It was suggested that if we stayed for cocktails we could avoid the $200 charge! Needless to say we won’t ever be back and warn others that should you book in advance and guarantee with your card, you MUST eat dinner or at the very least have a cocktail in their basement bar!
Restaurantji Recommends
I made a reservation in the Brick Cellar and was seated across from the Bar. The music was so loud to the point that we could not talk, we asked the waitress to lower the music and were told that she could not as we were seated at the bar. The service was slow, the burgers were cold, will definitely not be back.
We celebrated our anniversary at Atria and overall it was a good experience with a lovely atmosphere and good food. We had the fried lobster. However, I was disappointed that they did not acknowledge our anniversary in any aspect. I appreciate that extra special touch and personalization when celebrating a special occasion like many other restaurants do.
Always great. GET TO HERE! Getting tired of yelling. Just friggin' GO!
Good!Food. Great service and atmosphere!
In an old house in Edgartown. I had only eaten there once before, and then down in the lower level. When a friend and I arrived for our reservation, we discovered a large noisy table nearby and asked to be moved, which the staff immediately accommodated. We shared a salad (enough for two). My friend had scallops and I had duck. Both were delicious and perfectly cooked. The desserts were yummy. Not cheap, but worth the money. (we had individual glasses of wine rather than a bottle, and started with cocktails.) The wait staff, young people from Eastern Europe, were delightful to talk to.
Loading...