Edgartown Seafood Market

138 Cooke St, Edgartown
(508) 627-3791

Recent Reviews

Sort by
A C

Definitely worth checking out! The lobster rolls are the best around and the gentlemen working are extremely kind and helpful. Great service. Highly recommend if you are in the area.

Albert Anthony Lattanzi

Excellent piece of tuna! I’ll be back tomorrow!

Meghan Charles

Best chowder. Best lobster rolls. Agreed by everyone at dinner and then some. Great job guys!

kalen watson

Very good customer service! Thank you????

Adam Strunk

Amazing seafood. Great fish for cooking, best lobster roll I have ever had and great take out lobster. We go every day we are on the vineyard

Justin Thompson-Tucker

Best lobster roll on Martha's Vineyard, cold or hot.
Excellent clam chowder.
Phenomenal crab cakes.
10/10 customer service.

Jon Hines

always high quality / friendly service

Peter Licht

Decent selection and convenient. My timing was good and parking problems were avoided.

Tracy B

We were looking for the best lobster rolls on Martha’s Vineyard. Stopped here. Best lobster rolls ever. Loaded with lobster meat and light mayo. Service was awesome!! We went back and did it all over again the next day!

Julius Hochberg

Super fresh fish + nice people.

kathleen smith

The twins are always so helpful , and they seem to be open to hearing ways to enhance their business ! They have delicious lobster salad and lobster rolls . I told them they should make some up in the morning for grab and go . The chowder is yummy too . The bluefish pate ( bluefish and cream cheese ) is a family fave , as is the smoked fish !

C H P

Let me say this, I just finished several of the freshly cooked shrimp and hats off to the staff. We ordered a cooked lobster, pasta, salmon and several other items. The team was friendly and responsive to our request. It's good to see young people working in a business they enjoy.

A Lowe

Always have had great service here and great quality fish. The twins who run it are wonderful islanders.

Bob Fiorito

The new owners are great! Got some fresh sword and the cut it to order. Stuffed clams and stuffed scallops were delicious with plenty of meat

Lakisha Bah

Friendly service, was able to answer all of my questions

Loading...