Went in for a coffee, but they gave me a cup of some burnt pond water.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
john daley
Ugh. Skip it, there are like 25 better options within half a mile.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Amanda Caney
Really stale bun. All you have to do is toast it and it will taste better, but the sandwich was inedible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Alex K
The breakfast burrito I ordered was extremely disappointing. The bacon inside was raw and undercooked, and they completely forgot to include the avocado that was supposed to come with it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Chuck Hatem
$30 Lobster Roll, “The Best On the Island” was underwhelming - Not allot of meat, what there was were tiny pieces and no chunks. ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
NY chinchilla
A theme I found in Martha’s Vineyard was the feeling of being rushed. I ordered their lobster roll. The cashier rung me up. I wanted to add a soda. He rang me up again and then I decided I should get a water. The cashier rolled his eyes harder than a heavy rock rolling down a steep hill. While I get that I didn’t order everything at once. It’s my first time here and I was looking around.The lobster roll was good and apparently a small bag of lays potato chips are included. I am glad I tried it not sure I would want to try that again.One waterOne sodaOne lobster roll $44.69 (with a $5.83 tip included)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Angie Honey
We had a really good lunch here last week. Lovely friendly staff and food made to order quickly. The veggie burger and egg sandwich were delish! We'll be back ??
Vegetarian options: Veggie burger
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natalie Caldwell
Best and LARGEST lobster roll on the island. Hefty warm roll filled with chilled, large chunks of lobster salad. So amazing I wanted to go back for another.If you really want to treat yourself, get the frozen Arnold Palmer (frozen lemonade with iced tea) or the old school Stewart’s root beer.
Jimmy Keough
Great staff, positive, friendly.Food is always fresh .I've made several trips thereAlways consistent
Bridgette Coniglio
This was the worst food I have ever eaten and to top it off it was over 50 dollars for 2 people where the amount of food could have fed a toddler and the quality could be served to prison inmates.
This little spot has fantastic food. Lobster roll - very good; breakfast burrito - excellent and fried chicken - great! Everything comes with the ubiquitous Cape Cod chips. I’d recommend
HappierInNewEngland
After an active day in Katama, we were in search of casual dining in downtown Edgartown. We happened upon the inviting MacPhail's Corner Cafe with its wide open doors and friendly greeter. Avid Red Sox fans, we stayed the course even after seeing photos of Mickey Mantle and other famous Yankees flanked by members of the MacPhail family who had strong connections to MLB, lining the outer wall. The menu is limited but what they offer is prepared well. We ordered cheeseburger and fried chicken sandwiches on Brioche bread with delicious fixin's. We couldn't resist adding tater tots that were listed on the All Day Breakfast Menu. The frozen Arnold Palmer completed the meal we didn't even know we were craving. MacPhail's is hiding in plain site along the water in the middle of Dock Street. It seemed to be a destination for many teens whose parents were probably up on Main Street dining at one of the upscale establishments. You will not strike out if you visit MacPhail's for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!!!
Aaliyah Biondo
Oh lordy. Inflation has hit this place the hardest: A chicken patty (which used to be an entire breast), minimal cheese, and a drizzle of the secret sauce. A LIGHT DRIZZLE. The bun just wasn’t even the same - cheap and stale.The 1.5 pieces of bacon were the microwaveable ones it seemed. To top it off, it was $18 and change. No fries, just a mini bag of sea salt Cape Cod chips. More expensive met with poorer quality than previous summers. I really hope this is addressed as the season begins.- A disappointed regular
Jacqueline Borges
Quick bite. Amazing breakfast sandwich, buttery and delicious!!
Todd Stewart
Breakfast sandwiches are good. Great quick breakfast stop with great frozen Arnold Palmers and breakfast burritos and sandwiches. The sausage and egg is excellent.
Went in for a coffee, but they gave me a cup of some burnt pond water.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Ugh. Skip it, there are like 25 better options within half a mile.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Really stale bun. All you have to do is toast it and it will taste better, but the sandwich was inedible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
The breakfast burrito I ordered was extremely disappointing. The bacon inside was raw and undercooked, and they completely forgot to include the avocado that was supposed to come with it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
$30 Lobster Roll, “The Best On the Island” was underwhelming - Not allot of meat, what there was were tiny pieces and no chunks. ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
A theme I found in Martha’s Vineyard was the feeling of being rushed. I ordered their lobster roll. The cashier rung me up. I wanted to add a soda. He rang me up again and then I decided I should get a water. The cashier rolled his eyes harder than a heavy rock rolling down a steep hill. While I get that I didn’t order everything at once. It’s my first time here and I was looking around.The lobster roll was good and apparently a small bag of lays potato chips are included. I am glad I tried it not sure I would want to try that again.One waterOne sodaOne lobster roll $44.69 (with a $5.83 tip included)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
We had a really good lunch here last week. Lovely friendly staff and food made to order quickly. The veggie burger and egg sandwich were delish! We'll be back ??
Vegetarian options: Veggie burger
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best and LARGEST lobster roll on the island. Hefty warm roll filled with chilled, large chunks of lobster salad. So amazing I wanted to go back for another.If you really want to treat yourself, get the frozen Arnold Palmer (frozen lemonade with iced tea) or the old school Stewart’s root beer.
Great staff, positive, friendly.Food is always fresh .I've made several trips thereAlways consistent
This was the worst food I have ever eaten and to top it off it was over 50 dollars for 2 people where the amount of food could have fed a toddler and the quality could be served to prison inmates.
Restaurantji Recommends
This little spot has fantastic food. Lobster roll - very good; breakfast burrito - excellent and fried chicken - great! Everything comes with the ubiquitous Cape Cod chips. I’d recommend
After an active day in Katama, we were in search of casual dining in downtown Edgartown. We happened upon the inviting MacPhail's Corner Cafe with its wide open doors and friendly greeter. Avid Red Sox fans, we stayed the course even after seeing photos of Mickey Mantle and other famous Yankees flanked by members of the MacPhail family who had strong connections to MLB, lining the outer wall. The menu is limited but what they offer is prepared well. We ordered cheeseburger and fried chicken sandwiches on Brioche bread with delicious fixin's. We couldn't resist adding tater tots that were listed on the All Day Breakfast Menu. The frozen Arnold Palmer completed the meal we didn't even know we were craving. MacPhail's is hiding in plain site along the water in the middle of Dock Street. It seemed to be a destination for many teens whose parents were probably up on Main Street dining at one of the upscale establishments. You will not strike out if you visit MacPhail's for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!!!
Oh lordy. Inflation has hit this place the hardest: A chicken patty (which used to be an entire breast), minimal cheese, and a drizzle of the secret sauce. A LIGHT DRIZZLE. The bun just wasn’t even the same - cheap and stale.The 1.5 pieces of bacon were the microwaveable ones it seemed. To top it off, it was $18 and change. No fries, just a mini bag of sea salt Cape Cod chips. More expensive met with poorer quality than previous summers. I really hope this is addressed as the season begins.- A disappointed regular
Quick bite. Amazing breakfast sandwich, buttery and delicious!!
Breakfast sandwiches are good. Great quick breakfast stop with great frozen Arnold Palmers and breakfast burritos and sandwiches. The sausage and egg is excellent.
Loading...